Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
[DooDooPoker] /hr **BEST VALUE** [2nl-100nl High Level MDA Coaching] [DooDooPoker] /hr **BEST VALUE** [2nl-100nl High Level MDA Coaching]

04-01-2024 , 12:29 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by editundo
No serious online player has only played 60k hands. If you purport yourself to be an expert, you should back up your claims without the need to cherrypick results. Multiple people asked him to post his whole graph, which is a basic request, and he dodged that request and instead insulted them by calling them beginners. I have played millions of hands, if I wanted to coach, I wouldn't just cherrypick the best 60k hands I can find.
I didn't cherry pick the hands those are my results in the last 6 months.
[DooDooPoker] /hr **BEST VALUE** [2nl-100nl High Level MDA Coaching] Quote
04-01-2024 , 01:56 PM
If he’s doing an analysis of a large number of hands and is able to identify errors that are fairly common among typical players, who cares what his results are. What DooDoo should do, in my opinion, is to give a couple of his conclusions, explain why he came to those conclusions, and show some supporting data from his MDA.

Mason
[DooDooPoker] /hr **BEST VALUE** [2nl-100nl High Level MDA Coaching] Quote
04-01-2024 , 02:01 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mason Malmuth
If hes doing an analysis of a large number of hands and is able to identify errors that are fairly common among typical players, who cares what his results are. What DooDoo should do, in my opinion, is to give a couple of his conclusions, explain why he came to those conclusions, and show some supporting data from his MDA.

Mason
Thanks for the suggestion.

I might link a video of a coaching session (a small snippet, maybe 10 minutes) to give prospective students an idea of my approach.

I would need to get the student's permission before I do this though.
[DooDooPoker] /hr **BEST VALUE** [2nl-100nl High Level MDA Coaching] Quote
04-01-2024 , 05:26 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by DooDooPoker
I didn't cherry pick the hands those are my results in the last 6 months.
It would still be cherry-picking if for example you went on a massive downswing from Jan-Jun and then went on a heater Jul-Dec, but only showed the Jul-Dec results. The more reputable coaches share their actual screen name so that the results can be independently verified, and show a much larger sample. Otherwise it would be very naive to assume your winrate is actually 11bb/100. Most people would not want coaching from someone who's losing at poker, and these results don't even prove you are beating the games (except to some of the more naive posters).
[DooDooPoker] /hr **BEST VALUE** [2nl-100nl High Level MDA Coaching] Quote
04-01-2024 , 05:36 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by editundo
It would still be cherry-picking if for example you went on a massive downswing from Jan-Jun and then went on a heater Jul-Dec, but only showed the Jul-Dec results. The more reputable coaches share their actual screen name so that the results can be independently verified, and show a much larger sample. Otherwise it would be very naive to assume your winrate is actually 11bb/100. Most people would not want coaching from someone who's losing at poker, and these results don't even prove you are beating the games (except to some of the more naive posters).
I play on Ignition which is by definition an anonymous site so there are no screen names.

And my winrate is probably higher than 11bb/100 all things being equal. Since I'm a better player now than I was at the beginning of the 65k hands. Either way it's very obvious I'm beating the games.

I'll be posting a 10minute clip of a coaching session soon so you can judge for yourself.
[DooDooPoker] /hr **BEST VALUE** [2nl-100nl High Level MDA Coaching] Quote
04-01-2024 , 05:43 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by editundo
It would still be cherry-picking if for example you went on a massive downswing from Jan-Jun and then went on a heater Jul-Dec, but only showed the Jul-Dec results. The more reputable coaches share their actual screen name so that the results can be independently verified, and show a much larger sample. Otherwise it would be very naive to assume your winrate is actually 11bb/100. Most people would not want coaching from someone who's losing at poker, and these results don't even prove you are beating the games (except to some of the more naive posters).

Even if he was sun-running over this sample size, the likelihood of him not being a winning player is pretty much 0%.
[DooDooPoker] /hr **BEST VALUE** [2nl-100nl High Level MDA Coaching] Quote
04-01-2024 , 06:04 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by DooDooPoker
I play on Ignition which is by definition an anonymous site so there are no screen names.
Fair enough. I was under the impression that you were choosing to hide your screenname, so it's not as bad as I thought.

Quote:
Originally Posted by DooDooPoker
Either way it's very obvious I'm beating the games.
I think you are very likely beating the games for >0bb/100, although it would be more like 95% likely as opposed to "very obvious". A simple sim can prove this. 60k hands at 6max simply isn't that much, even with 11bb/100, so you are still overstating the significance of the sample (for a MDA specialist, this is a red flag).


The reason you got a strong pushback from me is exchanges like this. He makes a reasonable request, for data which you clearly should be expected to have, but the request is ignored for no apparent reason. You didn't then and still haven't given any explanation as to why you are not showing the other hands. Obviously, if you beat the games for 11bb/100 for say 500k hands, you would gladly show it when asked, or at least explain why you can't. I think it would be very foolish not to consider this another red flag.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Kendoo
Why only 50k hands? Maybe I would book an hour but first I would like to see your whole graph with at least 1000k hands+
Quote:
Originally Posted by DooDooPoker
So what I recommend for beginners like yourself is to learn preflop GTO fundamentals first. Then once you are proficient with those we can schedule a session

Then finally, your name is basically "poo" poker. This is a third red flag. If you want to be taken more seriously, maybe consider address these red flags in addition to posting the video (the video alone doesn't really address the issues I'm raising).

I won't post anymore in your thread. I think my position is pretty clear and people can judge for themselves how credible you are.
[DooDooPoker] /hr **BEST VALUE** [2nl-100nl High Level MDA Coaching] Quote
04-01-2024 , 06:36 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by editundo
I think you are very likely beating the games for >0bb/100, although it would be more like 95% likely as opposed to "very obvious". A simple sim can prove this. 60k hands at 6max simply isn't that much, even with 11bb/100, so you are still overstating the significance of the sample (for a MDA specialist, this is a red flag).
It would only be a red flag if the material he was using to teach MDA was from that 60k sample.

But...it's not.

So carry on.
[DooDooPoker] /hr **BEST VALUE** [2nl-100nl High Level MDA Coaching] Quote
04-02-2024 , 09:19 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by editundo
Fair enough. I was under the impression that you were choosing to hide your screenname, so it's not as bad as I thought.


I think you are very likely beating the games for >0bb/100, although it would be more like 95% likely as opposed to "very obvious". A simple sim can prove this. 60k hands at 6max simply isn't that much, even with 11bb/100, so you are still overstating the significance of the sample (for a MDA specialist, this is a red flag).

It's more like 99.9% that he has a positive winrate. Assuming a std of 90 BB/100, the chances of a breakeven player having a winrate of 11 over 63k hands is 0.1078%.
[DooDooPoker] /hr **BEST VALUE** [2nl-100nl High Level MDA Coaching] Quote
04-03-2024 , 10:41 AM
Shout out to the following people:

@newguyhere
@charlesChickens
@Mr.Plinkett
@bigdave2304

Thank you for the support.

Slyless just helped me add a 10min video clip on the front page. It might be interesting to some of you so when you have time please check it out.

Last edited by DooDooPoker; 04-03-2024 at 11:05 AM.
[DooDooPoker] /hr **BEST VALUE** [2nl-100nl High Level MDA Coaching] Quote
04-13-2024 , 05:17 PM
4/20 sale

I'm going to go back to my original price of $50/hr.

**Important** All students receive the MDA we go over in the 1 hour session for themselves.
[DooDooPoker] /hr **BEST VALUE** [2nl-100nl High Level MDA Coaching] Quote

      
m