Quote:
Originally Posted by ElevenGrover
I actually contacted the Peacekeepers and had a brief interchange w/Chief Dwayne Zacharie. His predecessor was ousted when he went against Joe Norton and other influential leaders so I didn't expect much cooperation. And didn't get it either.
That's not quite accurate. Cliffs at the end.
Zacharie became Chief Peacekeeer by resolution of Mohawk Council of Kahnawake on June 30, 2004 after Joseph Norton resigned on June 1, 2004 as Grand Chief in the wake of losing (for a second time) a referendum to allow a casino to operate in the community. So Zacharie was appointed by the council headed by the Grand Chief who replaced Norton.
Zacharie's predecessor as chief Peacekeeper was John K. Diabo. Diabo retired March 31, 2004, shortly before Norton retired from Kahnawake politics. I don't know whether Diabo's decision to retire was affected by Norton's departure from office, but the sequencing suggests otherwise. It is reasonable to presume that Diabo's retirement in 2004 had nothing to do with the suspension of a previous Chief Peacekeeper in 1996 when Norton was Grand Chief. Diabo is widely respected by native police across Canada - so much so that he is the only life member of the First Nations Chiefs of Police Association.
You are probably thinking of the
post by tk1133. I have a few problems with that post. The source of the article is not cited. The article is factually inaccurate and otherwise flawed. The post presents itself as quotes from a single article, but I haven't been able to find that article anywhere through google. It takes Norton's comment out of context, not revealing that the comment was made three years after the event, nor was it made in direct relation to the firing of Montour. It refers to the firing of Joseph Montour, when in fact he was only suspended at the time of the incident. Finally, it is presenting as fact what is obviously only (an extreme) opinion piece.
People reading ElevenGrover's post quoted above will likely come away with the impression that Norton replaced Montour with Zacharie when Montour crossed Norton and others. ElevenGrover seems to imply Zacharie is Norton's man and that Zacharie will cover up for Norton. Actually, Zacharie was appointed by the people who replaced Norton after the Kahnawake voters rejected Norton's approach on one aspect of gambling. He replaced a highly regarded Peacekeeper who retired, under no apparent pressure from Norton or anyone else. This is not the Chief Peacekeeper cited in the tk1133 post. If we are to infer anything about Zacharie's loyalty from this, it would be more reasonable to believe that Zacharie is trusted by a faction opposed to Norton.
However, the circumstances surrounding the suspension of Joseph Montour in 1996 are instructive when trying to determine who the Kahnawake Mohawks will recognize as "appropriate law enforcement agencies" WRT the KGC's findings in the UB scandal. Montour was suspended when he arrested, at the request of the Quebec Provincial Police, two men who had participated in an Extreme Fighting event in Kahnawake. This sort of contest was illegal under Canadian law. However, the event had been specifically sanctioned by the Kahnawake Mohawk Council, which asserted its right to decide if the event was legal in Kahnawake. Montour was suspended because he took actions contrary to the wishes of his employer - the Kahnawake Mohawk Council. These actions served to undermine the hard-won agreement on Kahnawake independent self-policing. Montour obviously acted in such a way that showed he believed that the laws he was supposed to enforce were the laws of Quebec and Canada, while the Council wanted him to enforce the rules put in place by the Council, where those rules differed from the Canadian law Quebec wished to enforce.
Kahnawake has consistently claimed the right to exercise sovereignty over matters such as gaming, and entertainment, and also exerts its right to be the sole police enforcer in its territory in these or any other matters. Montour's enforcement of the Quebec law, contrary to the Council's decision on the fight and in violation of Council policy on the independence of the Peacekeepers from Quebec or Canadian authority was a severe blow to Kahnawake's assertion of sovereignty.
Quote:
Originally Posted by ElevenGrover
I have spoken with a couple FBI agents who would neither confirm or deny an investigation existed though both were clearly aware of the situation.
Were the FBI agents appointed by Norton?
Rather than ascribe Zacharie's lack of cooperation to him being in Norton's pocket, I suggest that you try to understand how important the issue of sovereignty is to the people of Kahnawake and understand that he was not more or less forthcoming than those FBI agents you talked to, and for very similar reasons.
Cliffs:
1. ElevenGrover's comment quoted above, implies that Norton installed Zacharie to replace Montour when Montour personally crossed Norton, and further implies . Zacharie is Norton's man who will cover up for him. The actual facts of the history of appointments of Chief Peacekeepers do not support this interpretation.
2. Kahnawake regards itself as sovereign territory with the right to legislate and police itself WRT gambling and all other matters on its territory. When a law is broken on Kahnawake Territory it is the Kahnawake Peacekeepers who investigate and make any arrests. Likely the KGC will report wrongdoing to the Peacekeepers, and nobody else.
Last edited by DoTheMath; 01-24-2011 at 08:42 PM.