Quote:
Originally Posted by PointlessWords
Hmmm. Sue them for defamation. Subpoena the documents that have to do with the banning. I’m sure you can find the email exchange that says he we need to ban these guys that are accused of cheating.
Would that work
You're asking if an exchange of emails, in which one person (call him Person A) says "we need to ban these guys who are accused of cheating," would constitute defamation?
I'm not a lawyer, but I have a better-than-average command of libel laws from working as a PIO for almost 30 years. So I'll play along and say no for the following reasons:
a) this exchange of emails was not publicly accessible. For that matter, the documents you wish to subpoena – if they were also private, then the same defense applies.
b) the statement "accused of cheating" is true. Note that "guys who are accused of cheating" is significantly different from "guys who cheated."
c) Person A is not the one at fault for such alleged defamation, unless that email was the first time any insinuation had ever been made about Ali and Jake being cheaters.
Item c) is unimportant in your example, because a) and b) would supersede any at-fault concerns. But it
is part of the overall defense of a libel, slander or overall defamation action.
Last edited by Wilbury Twist; 10-07-2022 at 03:39 AM.
Reason: Also, to get nitpicky, you can't just say "guys who cheated," you'd actually have to name them. Otherwise, you're clear.