Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
New Online Gambling Law in Germany New Online Gambling Law in Germany

01-22-2020 , 01:30 PM
https://www.tagesschau.de/inland/onl...piele-101.html

Bulletpoints:
1) Every form of online Poker is now made fully legal (right now its a gray area)
2) Monthly deposit limit of 1000€
3) Playerprofil every site needs to report to the authoraties that insures you don't deposit more then 1000€ per month

All in all not bad at all little bit worse since degens to punt of more then 1000€ at the table.
New Online Gambling Law in Germany Quote
01-22-2020 , 01:49 PM
So, high stakes on line in Germany is dead?

Are transfers allowed? Going to be ripe for abuse. Also means you can never really withdraw any money if you wish to play high stakes.
New Online Gambling Law in Germany Quote
01-22-2020 , 02:16 PM
super strange
New Online Gambling Law in Germany Quote
01-22-2020 , 02:28 PM
I think it is super bad news.

Doesn't that mean that Germany will be the next segregated pool?
New Online Gambling Law in Germany Quote
01-22-2020 , 03:22 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Zivermiver
2) Monthly deposit limit of 1000€
Wow. **** that.

People probably thought I was overreacting yelling at that British dude a few weeks ago who wanted to impose some rule along these lines (his version was % of income or net worth or something like that).

But look here, nanny state swooping in to snatch people's individual rights and freedoms away, right here, as we speak.

Fight for your freedoms, people, or the government will take them away at any and every opportunity that presents itself. And one thing is for damned sure: they won't stop at poker...
New Online Gambling Law in Germany Quote
01-22-2020 , 03:59 PM
It takes effect 2021 summer.
They always try to regulate everything.
Hopefully its just a plan...
People can and will find ways through friends transfers...
Swapping... still does this mean cash out is regulated too? Bc I haven't read this in the article.
New Online Gambling Law in Germany Quote
01-22-2020 , 04:14 PM
Funny was just thinking yesterday how Germany is basically the richest fish country left expect UK. GL Germany.
New Online Gambling Law in Germany Quote
01-22-2020 , 04:17 PM
just another helpful regulation invented by rich monkeys for the poor monkeys that trust them with all their rights no questions asked .
New Online Gambling Law in Germany Quote
01-22-2020 , 04:23 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Herrigel
I think it is super bad news.

Doesn't that mean that Germany will be the next segregated pool?
No it wont

Quote:
Originally Posted by Smudger2408
So, high stakes on line in Germany is dead?

Are transfers allowed? Going to be ripe for abuse. Also means you can never really withdraw any money if you wish to play high stakes.
Yes it means high stakes is dead online in germany so just get your roll online before 2021
New Online Gambling Law in Germany Quote
01-22-2020 , 04:25 PM
amazing how countries can just strip rights away and the people take it 8 inches up the ass like good little monkeys.
New Online Gambling Law in Germany Quote
01-22-2020 , 04:33 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Zivermiver
No it wont

Would you mind elaborating on that?

Isn't whole Germany now following the example of Schleswig-Holstein, which, as far as I know, is separated from the international pool since a couple of years, despite (or let's say "because of") being the only Federal state with legalization?
New Online Gambling Law in Germany Quote
01-22-2020 , 04:34 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by WateryBoil
amazing how countries can just strip rights away and the people take it 8 inches up the ass like good little monkeys.
Except the 1000€ Limit its actually really nice. You are now legal to play and earn money tax free! Before that you had to Tax your income as a Pro which put you with half feet in jail.

A lot of people even wanted it forbidden and banned totally. So this is a good compromise.
New Online Gambling Law in Germany Quote
01-22-2020 , 04:41 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Herrigel
Would you mind elaborating on that?

Isn't whole Germany now following the example of Schleswig-Holstein, which, as far as I know, is separated from the international pool since a couple of years, despite (or let's say "because of") being the only Federal state with legalization?
No its just legal to play in SH online. In the other states it was technically illigal, but no one enforces the law. Its not like in the US. You play always with the whole world in germany.

Prior to this you are only to gamble in privat for pennys and only in state casinos except SH where it was allowed to gamble online.

Now we can gamble everywhere in germany tax free legal!
New Online Gambling Law in Germany Quote
01-22-2020 , 04:53 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Zivermiver
No its just legal to play in SH online. In the other states it was technically illigal, but no one enforces the law. Its not like in the US. You play always with the whole world in germany.

Prior to this you are only to gamble in privat for pennys and only in state casinos except SH where it was allowed to gamble online.

Now we can gamble everywhere in germany tax free legal!
Ah, OK, all I knew is that SH is restricted on RIO: (I guess the license is too expensive for RIO)

https://help.runitonce.eu/kb/restric...d-territories/

So on other international sites SH players are welcome?
New Online Gambling Law in Germany Quote
01-22-2020 , 05:09 PM
going to jail cause not paying taxes for money that you bring and spend in your country's economy from other countries that otherwise would not come in .
and/ or tax the tiny % of lucky people that win in casinos while sucking the dicks of online operators that make billions every year while paying moslty 0% in taxes moving that money straight to tax heavens from your average public sector loser that deposits his/her goverment check month in and month out.

that is the way to "regulate" in most countries and seems like most normal people agree with that so what you can do about it?
New Online Gambling Law in Germany Quote
01-22-2020 , 06:14 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Zivermiver
Except the 1000€ Limit its actually really nice. You are now legal to play and earn money tax free! Before that you had to Tax your income as a Pro which put you with half feet in jail.

A lot of people even wanted it forbidden and banned totally. So this is a good compromise.
Are you sure about that? Just because its legal to play pros wont have to pay taxes anymore? I mean I hope you are right but I dont see the connection.
New Online Gambling Law in Germany Quote
01-22-2020 , 06:26 PM
Fellow german here, the linked news article did not say anything about taxes and the tax situation legally was not connected to the "illegality" of online gambling so I do not think that is gonna change. Obviously really bad for nl100+ but the slot providers are probably gonna take the biggest hit so maybe hope for some lobbying efforts on their part in the next 1,5 years to raise the proposed monthly deposit limit.
New Online Gambling Law in Germany Quote
01-23-2020 , 07:31 AM
the limit does not account for winnings. so if you won and withdrew 2k you could still deposit 3k to spew off in the same month to reach the limit of 1k. At least thats how i understand. They basically don’t want people to gamble away more than 1k/month.

Also interesting that every site has to store and provide ALL game data including hands etc so it is guaranteed that no site is manipulating games in their favor.

Should the new sites have these absurd rake schemes too I will think about sueing them for profiteering and make complaints to the authorities...like a proper german would do.
New Online Gambling Law in Germany Quote
01-23-2020 , 07:41 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Zivermiver
Except the 1000€ Limit its actually really nice. You are now legal to play and earn money tax free! Before that you had to Tax your income as a Pro which put you with half feet in jail.

A lot of people even wanted it forbidden and banned totally. So this is a good compromise.
How do you come to the conclusion that it will be tax free?
New Online Gambling Law in Germany Quote
01-23-2020 , 09:02 AM
Does not change anything in regards to tax.
New Online Gambling Law in Germany Quote
01-23-2020 , 11:18 AM
Well i suppose we are now forced to keep larger rolls online again
New Online Gambling Law in Germany Quote
01-23-2020 , 11:42 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by washoe
It takes effect 2021 summer.
They always try to regulate everything.
Hopefully its just a plan...
It's planned to take effect in Summer 2021.
This version is a first proposal to get some kind of regulation with the example
of SH (Schleswig-Holstein).

Before this is possible to go into law, german federal states have to agree to that.
One of the reasons why it will take time.

The much bigger problem here is the record tracking. That goes far beyond keeping and tracking
personal information than is allowed by german law !
This will probably be the biggest counter argument against that proposal.

I know that you need regulation to protect gamblers who have an illness and
to provide a legal and secure business environment, but this is not quite
the best way to approach that topic.

And believe me - we (germans) will try to regulate every possible bit if we start doing this...

And the 1k€ will be a problem, too. Especially if you are operating on various sites,
not only for poker but also for sports betting.
New Online Gambling Law in Germany Quote
01-23-2020 , 03:42 PM
As you probably know any serious player (not all) from Germany relocated to Austria, UK, thailand, malta, or to many other countries. So this effects more recs.

Last edited by washoe; 01-23-2020 at 03:48 PM.
New Online Gambling Law in Germany Quote
01-23-2020 , 08:07 PM
That really ****ing sucks
Everyone who is always saying they want online poker to be "officially legalized, taxed and regulated", this is what you will end up with
New Online Gambling Law in Germany Quote
01-23-2020 , 09:12 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by NINzent
That really ****ing sucks
Everyone who is always saying they want online poker to be "officially legalized, taxed and regulated", this is what you will end up with
Tax free? I still take it. Would take me probably like 2-3 months to build bankroll again on sites . Also wondering how they will treat P2P transfer.

Also nothing stops your buddy to lose couple of K in a logical way from abroad to you .

After you get your bankroll going it seems it will be tax free.
New Online Gambling Law in Germany Quote

      
m