Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Live play vs. Online & why the Top ten players in the world will always be live players Live play vs. Online & why the Top ten players in the world will always be live players

08-23-2011 , 02:20 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by EDDtown
Well, neither of us play an orthodox strategy because we are watching tells, so a math determination of whether or not a certain hand was played correctly would never work. We flat certain hands in position that others wouldnt.
The problem is you don't acknowledge how important fundamentals are in poker compared to physical reads. Clear cut fundamental mistakes can never be overcome via tells in the long-term especially given the short stack nature of many tournament situations such as this one.
Live play vs. Online & why the Top ten players in the world will always be live players Quote
08-23-2011 , 02:21 AM
Every couple , father & son, friends etc. They all check down hands HU, I've even seen strangers meet at a table for the 1st time & agree to check it out with each other because they become friends & I could give a rats ass what they do with their money once I'm out of the pot. It's irrellevant to me.
Live play vs. Online & why the Top ten players in the world will always be live players Quote
08-23-2011 , 02:24 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by LT22
The problem is you don't acknowledge how important fundamentals are in poker compared to physical reads. Clear cut fundamental mistakes can never be overcome via tells in the long-term especially given the short stack nature of many tournament situations such as this one.
Why would you say something this stupid?

So you think I just quit playing poker for tells or do you think as someone thats trying to create the highest ev game I try to incorporate a strategy that involves both to create an overall best strategy. Moron
Live play vs. Online & why the Top ten players in the world will always be live players Quote
08-23-2011 , 02:29 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by EDDtown
Why would you say something this stupid?

So you think I just quit playing poker for tells or do you think as someone thats trying to create the highest ev game I try to incorporate a strategy that involves both to create an overall best strategy. Moron
Your so called "edge" gained by tells decreases as stacks get smaller, is that so hard to understand?

Ex) I think he's weak. Oh ****, he only has 10bbs and he's all in. edge nearly 100% negated as most good players have a standard range they would shove here and I highly doubt you can say, "I eliminate all solid hands from his range b/c his face twitched."

I never said you don't incorporate both, you are simply overrating things.
Live play vs. Online & why the Top ten players in the world will always be live players Quote
08-23-2011 , 02:31 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by EDDtown
WOW, Just read that, I can imagine you are still upset over that. I'm glad you came into the forum because that hand is a perfect example of this entire thread, I opened UTG & got reraised & cold called, You were sitting on my right & I was watching you when you decided to move in. It was really a bizarre hand & a lot people were asking about it afterward, Why I had moved in with A5 on top of so much action. One of the reasons was because I just sensed that you were making a play. I could feel it when you talked yourself into moving in so I though my A5 was ahead even though it shouldn't have been with all the action. I think you made a great play & made a great read, I made a great reread, but Unfortunately you were still ahead with A7, I think one of the other guys folded JJ. I got super lucky with the 5, I'll never forget that hand & I'm sure you definately won't, Tough break

I ended up making the final table 2nd in chips playing for a million, but super bad luck on the final table, 8th place, gross
ladies and gentlemen, get this man a wishbone and an abandoned oil field - he can sense things!
Live play vs. Online & why the Top ten players in the world will always be live players Quote
08-23-2011 , 02:38 AM
Sense was used instead of listing specifically what it is that I actually look for since I'm not going to tell a bunch of poker players how I'm beating them.
Live play vs. Online & why the Top ten players in the world will always be live players Quote
08-23-2011 , 02:40 AM
You think that tells don't matter to this man, I can't imagine this play could be made online & be positive EV


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=--Qap3VT_ZY
Live play vs. Online & why the Top ten players in the world will always be live players Quote
08-23-2011 , 02:42 AM
Not checking down hands with acquaintances is much shadier in my opinion. At least people know where you stand when you check down hands. Making weird poker plays against someone you share money with allows you to basically build a false image. I'd much rather play with people who are checking down cause I know where I stand.
Live play vs. Online & why the Top ten players in the world will always be live players Quote
08-23-2011 , 02:48 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by apokerplayer
Not checking down hands with acquaintances is much shadier in my opinion. At least people know where you stand when you check down hands. Making weird poker plays against someone you share money with allows you to basically build a false image. I'd much rather play with people who are checking down cause I know where I stand.

That's 100% correct. I run across some funny people every so often that will say something about it, but it's generally someone that's fairly new to the game & don't know any better. Anyone that's been playing for an extended period doesn't care what you do with the pot after theyre out & they apprectiate that they actually get to see that your not cheating when the cards are shown.
Live play vs. Online & why the Top ten players in the world will always be live players Quote
08-23-2011 , 02:50 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by EDDtown
I was thinking it got 3 bet, but that's been three years ago so not sure. I knew I wasn't going to be far ahead if you had a random hand but with the dead money in the pot I figured it was worth it if I could get HU 3/2 fav with all the dead equity in the pot.
At the time you went allin with A5 there was no dead money in the pot.
There were still players to act, so there is nothing dead about that money.
Live play vs. Online & why the Top ten players in the world will always be live players Quote
08-23-2011 , 02:55 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Deurdy
At the time you went allin with A5 there was no dead money in the pot.
There were still players to act, so there is nothing dead about that money.
Really deurdy, Were you there?


There was plenty dead money in the pot after I raised UTG & got called or 3 bet in 2 spots , that means antes, SB, both callers plus my bet & the squeezers money.

I knew the players behind were folding
Live play vs. Online & why the Top ten players in the world will always be live players Quote
08-23-2011 , 03:04 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by EDDtown
Really deurdy, Were you there?


There was plenty dead money in the pot after I raised UTG & got called or 3 bet in 2 spots , that means antes, SB, both callers plus my bet & the squeezers money.

I knew the players behind were folding
Yeah lol, just like you knew you were a 3/2 favourite against BB..oh wait.
Live play vs. Online & why the Top ten players in the world will always be live players Quote
08-23-2011 , 03:14 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by EDDtown
You think that tells don't matter to this man, I can't imagine this play could be made online & be positive EV


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=--Qap3VT_ZY
I am just an avg player, but from what I understand, this play made by Phil Ivey is very much based on acute common sense and - it had nothing to do with live tells. Phil Ivey would have played it the same online too.
Live play vs. Online & why the Top ten players in the world will always be live players Quote
08-23-2011 , 03:18 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by KingOfAces
I am just an avg player, but from what I understand, this play made by Phil Ivey is very much based on acute common sense and - it had nothing to do with live tells. Phil Ivey would have played it the same online too.

Key
Live play vs. Online & why the Top ten players in the world will always be live players Quote
08-23-2011 , 03:21 AM
^ Please enlighten me - what was the "LIVE TELL"?
Live play vs. Online & why the Top ten players in the world will always be live players Quote
08-23-2011 , 04:11 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by KingOfAces
^ Please enlighten me - what was the "LIVE TELL"?
No answer to this?
I guess its not convenient for you to answer since there were NO live tells.
Live play vs. Online & why the Top ten players in the world will always be live players Quote
08-23-2011 , 04:31 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by EDDtown
You think that tells don't matter to this man, I can't imagine this play could be made online & be positive EV


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=--Qap3VT_ZY
Which I counter with this and this.

I can come up with just as many cases of "tells" gone wrong as great reads. Still waiting to hear about a tell you used to make a big fold, though, seems like all you and your girl can do is get $$$ in bad because you always think everyone is weak, (which I witnessed live).
Live play vs. Online & why the Top ten players in the world will always be live players Quote
08-23-2011 , 05:07 AM
I think most people are forgetting the obvious.

Live games are mostly 10 handed and frequently much deeper than online, also they commonly have 5-6+ huge fish in the game that like to limp from EP/overlimp LP/cold call 3 bets/make funky donks/etc.
Due to the sheer number of people that want to see a flop, this basically eliminates the ability to isolate & outplay postflop (what are you gonna do vs. 4 limpers? + 2 blinds)
So the game changes to a more honest nut-peddaling one. There's usually more than 1 sherrif on the table to prevent rampid bluffing.

Conversely, online people can multitable, see 20-30x the number of hands per hour and thus average table VPIP goes WWAAYY down. So, then the game becomes one more involved with attacking blinds, etc.

This is why the old nit at the table can still stack the young-gun who 3 bets him with AKs and cant fold to his 4 bet. Old man always shows up with KK+ and young-gun internet kid cant adjust his stacking off range for a passive table, and probably has never flat called AKs pre in his life.
Live play vs. Online & why the Top ten players in the world will always be live players Quote
08-23-2011 , 05:11 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by EDDtown
She made an unbelievable play on day 6 with a k5 off against pius heintz on a read after he raised utg, she was in BB. She 5 bet him head up & he finally 6 bet her in & she had to fold, but he showed a 9, So just great poker , but she can play with anyone .
wow such an awesome play...
wat
???
Live play vs. Online & why the Top ten players in the world will always be live players Quote
08-23-2011 , 06:33 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Quartersack
Listen man, I'm not going to get into a pissing contest with you. My post was to simply point out that the games at the Beau play much bigger then most and that winning 5k+ in a 2/5 game is certainly not beyond the realm of possibility. Actually, pretty common. From what I heard about the action the 5/10 game was seeing this weekend, winning 25k was certainly possible. Did Gabe win 25k? Did Claudia win 5k? I dont know, nor do I care, but the money was on the table for it to happen.

When answering his question, I was assuming he was use to people sitting in games with 100bb stacks. My post was not meant to suggest there is a proper strategy to play against 30bb opens. Rather, by letting him know the games are usually 500bb+ deep, it makes the situation a little more clear as to whats going on (that is, the game being super deep full of people with complete disregard to money, clueless when it come to fundamentals and overall not giving a damn). I guess I shouldve explained myself a little better but I thought my answer to his question was pretty clear. So I ask you, what are you going to do when you have an idiot at the table making 30bb opens? You gonna get up and move games? Or you gonna put as much money on the table as you can? Obv I was referring to the later.

And yes, go sit with 100bb in a 1/2 or 2/5 game and you will feel out of place. Assuming no straddle, the standard opens are 7-10bb. The one hand comment was a slight exaggeration but Im pretty sure you, along with everyone else, can smell what I'm stepping in.

I'm not here to defend Gabe (I dont even know him personally) or to verify his claims. All I did was come here to shed some light on the games at the Beau. Which I did. And anyone thats spent time in the room will back up my statements, regardless of what you saw this summer at the Rio during wsop.
You must be thinking of some other game. The people Gabe plays with are the best players in the world. Just ask Gabe if you don't believe me.
Live play vs. Online & why the Top ten players in the world will always be live players Quote
08-23-2011 , 09:20 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by EDDtown
I just started the thread to state a fact. I didnt realize I would be attacked personally for putting information out there that others didn't understand. But you as much as anyone pushed this match with Samo so & criticized me for not playing someone that insulted me so your although I think your right now, your past actions regarding the thread don't reflect that.
If you mean the fact that live players are better at reading tells that a pure internet player, probably. If you mean your contention that the best players in the world will always be a live player because of the value of those tells, that is not a fact, that is your opinion. Until there's some way to actually measure and prove it, it will continue to be your opinion rather than a fact, and not one that appears to be shared by many, at least not in this forum.

I did not push the match. I wanted to see the outcome, but otherwise posted very little about the Samo match until the end. And I find your statement that you would never play someone who insulted you to be logically ridiculous, given that you claim to be a poker professional who plays live every day. Professionals shrug off mild slights to take huge +EV spots.

And you still haven't explained your reluctance to use escrow, which AFAIK is the only stumbling block to the second match vs. another player you should have a huge edge against who DIDN'T insult you.

These are merely examples of questions or comments you have refused to answer or comment on, which is why you have garnered the nickname in this thread that you have. A nickname that I personally have not yet used to label you, despite your allegations that I am impartial and unfairly minded against you specifically.

Last edited by SGT RJ; 08-23-2011 at 09:55 AM.
Live play vs. Online & why the Top ten players in the world will always be live players Quote
08-23-2011 , 09:36 AM
FWIW, just because you do something unorthodox doesn't mean you're some kind of genius. I could run backwards every time someone passes me the ball, or even 5% of the time, in soccer, and it'd still be ******ed regardless of if I sometimes win. This would be especially true in the last couple minutes of a big game/tournament where we need to score to advance.
Live play vs. Online & why the Top ten players in the world will always be live players Quote
08-23-2011 , 11:53 AM
waiting for Gabe to respond to someone who disagrees with him with something more than hilarious unfounded opinion.

i think it would make the thread pretty good.
Live play vs. Online & why the Top ten players in the world will always be live players Quote
08-23-2011 , 12:02 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by EDDtown
Really deurdy, Were you there?


There was plenty dead money in the pot after I raised UTG & got called or 3 bet in 2 spots , that means antes, SB, both callers plus my bet & the squeezers money.

I knew the players behind were folding
I don't think this is as crazy as most people. I frequently get reliable reads that tell me when people will not call a big bet, or conversely, that they wouldn't mind action. The main thing I look for is eye contact. For SOME people, the amount of eye contact in certain situations tells you whether they are in defensive mode, or relaxed mode. I'll elaborate more later if anyone cares.
Live play vs. Online & why the Top ten players in the world will always be live players Quote

      
m