ElkY's statement lines up with what I believe most in the community (myself included) have finally come to realize: (a) that TSG is simply going to go in the direction its decision makers want, and (b) that we were
naive to think our feedback/experience in the industry would eventually sway TSG execs from taking the site in the direction it has.
IMO it has taken some time for this reality to sink in for players, sponsored pros, Twitch/YouTube personalities, media reps, forum contributors... a large percentage of all of us, myself included. I think all of us have thought to ourselves more than once over the past 3+ years something along the lines of, "
surely they won't take Stars in this direction. They'll listen to me, my ideas, or someone will whisper in their ear, share their knowledge and the direction TSG is heading will shift."
And that's not to say that TSG isn't "receptive" to ideas/criticism or what have you. It's just an observation. The top people at TSG are going to take their company and corresponding products in the direction THEY want to in the end, and THEY will have the final word, period.
You can get a feel for what I'm referring to in Rafi Ashkenazi's (The Stars Group CEO) Aug 11, 2017 Bloomberg interview here:
Poker Site Wants Card Sharks to Fold So The Rest of Us Can Win
Take a look at the Twitter reaction thread (involving TSG reps, Ike Haxton and poker media) a few days after that interview was published.
https://twitter.com/pokerprojones/st...34794365698049
At first, even media and PokerStars' staunchest supporters were re-arranging the CEO's rhetoric b/c they couldn't believe what he was telling Bloomberg was fully accurate, or in line with TSG's vision, or the communication it wanted to relay. And that's
not a "shots fired" call-out of any of my colleagues in "poker media" circles... I'm equally guilty of being just as "naive" as the next longtime PokerStars player/fan/affiliate content producer. But as you can see, TSG rep Eric Hollreiser responded in that Twitter thread and made it clear that Ashkenazi's communication (that Stars wants withdrawing players to go away) was accurate (albeit "inarticulate" and "insensitive").
So I think ElkY pretty much thought like so many of us did... that sooner or later TSG would come around to a different way of thinking on some of the bigger decisions... and we were all wrong about that in the end. And again, that's not to say that TSG
hasn't made some adjustments here & there based on feedback, or
hasn't made some recent decisions that benefit the "recreational" poker playing community they so adamantly claim to "protect" (bailing out PKR, creating the Platinum Pass concept, and limiting online satellite winners to 1 entry for live tour events come to mind). It's just that the final decision on what to do -- whether you, me, or anyone else agrees with it -- is going to be made by TSG decision makers, and that's that.
This goes as far back as DNegs thinking he would convince (then-CEO) Baazov and other top execs to hold off another year on abruptly removing the SN/SNE cashback programs -- to Mason Malmuth telling Joey Ingram on the Poker Life Podcast that he hoped TSG and SN/SNE players could eventually work out a deal -- to Doug Polk being surprised when TSG continued to make changes unfavorable to pros in 2016/2017 -- to Joey Ingram's recent frustration regarding HS cash games -- to pretty much everyone... me, you, posters on this forum, media reps, players, personalities, sponsored pros, etc.
So to summarize a long story, I believe ElkY's statement simply communicates that he was naive about the influence his experience/knowledge/expertise would have on TSG's bigger decisions just like so many of us were.