Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Decentralised poker is the future Decentralised poker is the future

11-08-2017 , 08:56 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nooseknot
Our gaming laws are a function or extensions of our constitutions. As the population favors games the laws will change with that favor. So there is a relevant relationship there.
oh my. Im guessing you are between 24-28 cuz you sound like my 26 year old daughter, her husband and all their millennial friends. so optimistic and hopeful that in the end the good and righteous will prevail

If this thread is about what could happen when constitutions are changed please wake me up in 30 years..

If this thread is about what could happen when laws are changed then someone please wake me up in 10 years.

If this thread is about what could happen now within the bounds of existing gaming laws and/or more importantly gaming regs, then lets talk.
Decentralised poker is the future Quote
11-08-2017 , 09:16 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by PTLou
oh my. Im guessing you are between 24-28 cuz you sound like my 26 year old daughter, her husband and all their millennial friends. so optimistic and hopeful that in the end the good and righteous will prevail
We already established I know more about these things than you

Quote:
If this thread is about what could happen when constitutions are changed please wake me up in 30 years..

If this thread is about what could happen when laws are changed then someone please wake me up in 10 years.
None of these need to changed
Quote:
If this thread is about what could happen now within the bounds of existing gaming laws and/or more importantly gaming regs, then lets talk.
You already introduced yourself to the concept of the new emerging model (ico's and hypbrid/serverless models).

It's already time to talk.
Decentralised poker is the future Quote
11-09-2017 , 06:01 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nooseknot
We already established I know more about these things than you
blockchain tech and associated things, I will give to you

Business along with general workings of the world at large ... not quite there. Lets just say I have a much larger sample size and better graph

Quote:
None of these need to changed
OK agreed. Then why do you keep bringing up the 'Philosophy of Constitutional Law Class and Role of Society' class. MIght be something you studied in school, might be something you are interested in, but its barely relevant to discussion ITT.


back to my CoinPoker head assplode of two nights ago, Ive thought a bit more and could use some help sorting this all out.


Legacy sites make money one way.... rake. got it. easy.

CoinPoker can make money two ways.... rake plus manipulation of their coin value.


Since their coin can only be used on their site and they control supply, are they mostly (or totally ?) in control if its value, defined in terms of exchange rate one would receive when converting to $ or Bitc or whatever.

Thus their coin (your bankroll on their site) might be worth $100 or $1000 or $1 on any given day (extreme example) depending on how they manipulate supply.

what I am missing here?

Last edited by PTLou; 11-09-2017 at 06:25 AM.
Decentralised poker is the future Quote
11-09-2017 , 07:17 AM
As far as I see it, Coin Poker reserves 10% of the 500,000,000 CHP for themselves, and 75% will be on the market. I don't see how they can manipulate the market with freely traded coins?

The disadvantage of these ICO's is that so called whales can buy up a big chunk of the offered tokens, which offers them the opportunity to manipulate the market in their own advantage.

EDIT: You touch on an important point though, the fluctuations of fiat vs any cryptocurrency. It could very well be possible that, while you played a 6 hour tournament, the price of the cryptocurrency you are gaming with, drops 20% in value.
There are some solutions to this, but I don't see any of the whitepapers mentioning this, yet.
Decentralised poker is the future Quote
11-09-2017 , 07:57 AM
Lots of people in the 2000s in the US liked online poker, it didn't make the legal environment improve, in fact just the opposite. P2p poker doesn't change that. Also playing in dollars or euros is common on international sites. I suggest nooseknot reads this to get a basic background in the topic

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Online_poker

Also if Nooseknot wants to talk about "Constitutional" countries (well a constitution can say Sharia law is supreme, I think he means what are called liberal democracies in the rest of the world where those words aren't associated so specifically with a particular political party), then plenty of those countries already have legal poker.
Decentralised poker is the future Quote
11-09-2017 , 08:53 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Stroopwafel
As far as I see it, Coin Poker reserves 10% of the 500,000,000 CHP for themselves, and 75% will be on the market. I don't see how they can manipulate the market with freely traded coins?
.
regarding reserve. I assume that means their "rake" is already 10% before the actual rake starts? spin n goes on stars start to look like pretty good deal

are their coins freely traded though? they can only be used in game or exchanged in a ewallet that decides to exchange them.

What of no credible exchanges decides its worth the hassle to exchange yet another of the plethora of new coins coming into market? then what?
Quote:
Originally Posted by LektorAJ
Lots of people in the 2000s in the US liked online poker, it didn't make the legal environment improve, in fact just the opposite. P2p poker doesn't change that.
yes so not only is the discussion on constitutional law not very relevant to thread, as you point out has no basis in real world events

Its fine though, millennials are so optimistic and unwilling to accept the status quo and I love them for that.

Last edited by PTLou; 11-09-2017 at 08:59 AM.
Decentralised poker is the future Quote
11-09-2017 , 11:25 AM
Lots of people in the 2000s in the US liked online poker, it didn't make the legal environment improve, in fact just the opposite. P2p poker doesn't change that.


I think p2p poker can change that because it takes away the legal control which was via the servers.
Decentralised poker is the future Quote
11-09-2017 , 11:49 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by LektorAJ
Lots of people in the 2000s in the US liked online poker, it didn't make the legal environment improve, in fact just the opposite. P2p poker doesn't change that. Also playing in dollars or euros is common on international sites. I suggest nooseknot reads this to get a basic background in the topic
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Online_poker

Listen, I'm not trying to make a cut and dry "this tech ends law"...at this point I'm trying to get my foot in the door to open the dialogue. This is from your link:

Quote:
Originally Posted by Wiki;online poker
On October 13, 2006, President Bush officially signed into law the SAFE Port Act, a bill aimed at enhancing security at U.S. ports.[13] Attached to the Safe Port Act was a provision known as the Unlawful Internet Gambling Enforcement Act of 2006 (UIGEA). According to the UIGEA, "unlawful internet gambling" means to place, receive, or otherwise knowingly transmit a bet or wager by means of the internet where such bet is unlawful under any law in the State in which the bet is initiated, received, or otherwise made. Thus, the UIGEA prohibits online gambling sites from performing transactions with American financial institutions.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Wiki;online poker
Many online poker sites, particularly those that serve the United States, began adopting cryptocurrencies in 2013 as a means of bypassing the UIGEA.

Last edited by Nooseknot; 11-09-2017 at 11:55 AM.
Decentralised poker is the future Quote
11-09-2017 , 11:54 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by PTLou
yes so not only is the discussion on constitutional law not very relevant to thread, as you point out has no basis in real world events
By consitution, yes I mean to point to our democracies. I mean to point to the division of duities for the sepatioon of powers. That we (if we live under such governance) create government in order to ensure the greatest freedoms we can afford.

There is a limitation on our freedom in this regard, but its growing. It's very relevant because poker can change first. We notice through the history it was technology that created change and brought freedom, regardless of law, and then law evolves as our psychology changes.

Games are extremely relevant as well. A society weak at games and game theory will be a failing one.

Quote:
Its fine though, millennials are so optimistic and unwilling to accept the status quo and I love them for that.
Don't do this.
Decentralised poker is the future Quote
11-09-2017 , 12:00 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Stroopwafel
There are some solutions to this, but I don't see any of the whitepapers mentioning this, yet.
It's already standard for sites to deal with it (from lektor's link):

Quote:
One issue exclusive to online poker is the fact that players come from around the world and deal in a variety of currencies. This is not an issue in live poker where everyone present can be expected to carry the local currency. Most online poker sites operate games exclusively in U.S. dollars, even if they do not accept players based in the United States. There are two methods by which poker sites can cater to players who do not deal with U.S. dollars on a regular basis.

The first method is to hold players' funds in their native currencies and convert them only when players enter and leave games. The main benefit of this method for players is to ensure that bankrolls are not subject to exchange rate fluctuations against their local currencies while they are not playing. Also, most sites that use this method usually apply the same exchange rate when a player cashes out of a game as when he bought in, ensuring that players do not expend significant sums simply by entering and leaving games.

The other method is to require players to convert their funds when depositing them. However, some sites that use this policy do accept payments in a variety of currencies and convert funds at a lower premium compared to what banks and credit card companies would charge. Others only accept payment in U.S. dollars. One benefit of this method is that a player who constantly "tops up" his chip stack to a constant level (some poker rooms have an optional feature that can perform this function automatically) does not have to worry about rounding issues when topping up with a nominal sum – these could add up over time.

Players may also make use of ewallets, virtual wallets that will allow players to store their funds online in the currency of their choice. This allows them to deposit at poker sites without worrying about further currency conversion.[42]
This tech makes it easy though and more trustworthy. There are also already coins pegged to USD, or other fiat...and each nation is already developing their own crypto fiat.

It's simply not an issue for player or sites.
Decentralised poker is the future Quote
11-09-2017 , 12:03 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by PTLou
regarding reserve. I assume that means their "rake" is already 10% before the actual rake starts? spin n goes on stars start to look like pretty good deal

are their coins freely traded though? they can only be used in game or exchanged in a ewallet that decides to exchange them.

What of no credible exchanges decides its worth the hassle to exchange yet another of the plethora of new coins coming into market? then what?
Yup its the wild wild west. The difference here is the top site is not the one that the government handed a monopoly. The one that is the most accessible because of laws and payment processing restrictions. Rather, the top site is the one that the players most want to play on.

It's quite easy to exchange your bitcoin for any other coin or for fiat. Takes a few clicks just like poker. Some exchanges and coins have major liquidity, and this is growing daily. Some don't.

You are asking the right question, but people have already been doing this for years.
Decentralised poker is the future Quote
11-09-2017 , 12:54 PM
but I thought one of the motivations here was better site for players and lower rake.

an effective 10% rake (based on currency manipulation) before you even play a hand seems to be moving in the wrong direction ?
Decentralised poker is the future Quote
11-09-2017 , 01:05 PM
why would you lose equity on a conversion? where does the 10% come from?
Decentralised poker is the future Quote
11-09-2017 , 01:50 PM
Im still getting head wrapped around all this but was referring to this

Quote:
Originally Posted by Stroopwafel
As far as I see it, Coin Poker reserves 10% of the 500,000,000 CHP for themselves, and 75% will be on the market. I don't see how they can manipulate the market with freely traded coins?
Decentralised poker is the future Quote
11-09-2017 , 02:02 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by PTLou
Im still getting head wrapped around all this but was referring to this
I don't think it is how you put it, but I'm terrible at those specifics because they are uninteresting to me. I think thats for the crowd sale. So the business model keeps 10% of the finite coins they create, and different models will do different things and have different promises, and this can be locked and automated into smart contracts.

It's quite clear, that those that lock in their promises, in a technology in which the locks cannot be reversed, will be more trusted than those that make promises but don't utilize the tech.

This will reflect in the price of the token. So if they have a large amount set aside, then they can make provisions that ensure they cannot manipulate.

Some models have two layers of tokens and one that keeps the game currency stable with a peg etc.
Decentralised poker is the future Quote
11-09-2017 , 02:18 PM
I don't know where to write this, but coinpoker is claiming that M Josem is their head of security and at this point based on posts here and elsewhere by the coinpoker rep, I don't believe them.

Josem gave me a weird pm that made me question whether he is on the team, but he hasn't responded to my reply.
Decentralised poker is the future Quote
11-09-2017 , 02:34 PM
he's definitely on their website with full BIO along with rest of team.
Decentralised poker is the future Quote
11-09-2017 , 02:38 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by PTLou
he's definitely on their website with full BIO along with rest of team.
The industry is full of scams that use peoples names without their knowing even when its blatant.

Doesn't this seem weird, he would associate with a company that has a rep that misappropriates poker history like this:

Quote:
Originally Posted by Coinpoker
We strongly believe in our product as well, and we are aware of past problems online poker has encounter with Full Tilt Poker among other platforms. That is one of the reason why CoinPoker.com is actually very innovative when it comes to handling bots and collusion, and Blockchain technology will greatly help by identifying the unethical accounts. As all game play results (hand history) will be placed on Blockchain, operator won't be able to compromise RNG output in any way, securing that issues we have seen with Full Tilt poker and other entities won't happen again.
Full tilt poker didn't have a broken rng ;p
Decentralised poker is the future Quote
11-09-2017 , 03:18 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nooseknot
The industry is full of scams that use peoples names without their knowing even when its blatant.

Doesn't this seem weird, he would associate with a company that has a rep that misappropriates poker history like this:



Full tilt poker didn't have a broken rng ;p
"As all game play results (hand history) will be placed on Blockchain" ...

Basically, this does not sound like a decentralized game at all, only a game where the off-chain game engine results are posted to the blockchain. Sort of like on running a game on any regular site, then putting Pokertracker onto the blockchain ?

I have not waded through the Whitepaper as yet, so I might be mistaken....

I did get the part about pegging the intial pre-sale to a fixed Eurovalue, pricing the offeror-retained portion at at almost 7,000 000 Euros value ... nice capital raise if it goes.

I'll stay tuned though.

Anyone ?

Last edited by Gzesh; 11-09-2017 at 03:30 PM.
Decentralised poker is the future Quote
11-09-2017 , 03:28 PM
You are correct. It is their RNG which they are claiming is "decentralized". So the randomization is provably fair because each party gets a shuffle input of their own. So its kind of a disingenuous use of the word decentralized which is something I want to bring up with their head of security.

They also mention in their whitepaper:

Quote:
Originally Posted by Coin Poker


Game integrity fears reached fever pitch during the Absolute Poker scandal when it was uncovered that there was systematic cheating via a backdoor entry that allowed some accounts to see other players hold cards.
But their rep readily admits they have not actually addressed this problem stated of back dooring a super user account. They have explicitly created a hole for one. The crowd sale is a week away, and I would dare say there isn't enough time for enough questions to be answered.

I don't like this.
Decentralised poker is the future Quote
11-09-2017 , 04:07 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Bobo Fett
It would be pretty silly of me to dislike someone I don't even know simply because I disagree with their posts. You're reading much more into my posts than is there.
yet he is not the 2nd, the 3rd, or the 4th person to feel that way based on your posts. is it a coincidence that so many people get the impression you are being rude??

maybe the problem is you. the way you talk/condescend to people on this forum.
Decentralised poker is the future Quote
11-09-2017 , 04:27 PM
jfc rich... plz go get your own containment thread... like on some other forum some forum very very far away 2+2

back to off topic of main topic regarding coin poker and Josem ?

interesting plot twist. guess coinpoker rep and josem gonna stay quiet. thats weird in and of itself.
Decentralised poker is the future Quote
11-09-2017 , 04:30 PM
So Josem IS head of security for this site
Quote:
Originally Posted by Coinpoker
Yes, we can assure you, that Michael Josem is our team member.
https://forumserver.twoplustwo.com/s...4&postcount=38

And this is interesting to me, from a site that is using the word "decentralized" which in the crypto world is a word that points to security. That centralization is a point of failure, and the whole curx of creating security is to avoid it.

But Josem is an outspoken proponent of centralization, especially in regard to poker:
https://forumserver.twoplustwo.com/s...&postcount=136
Quote:
Originally Posted by Josem
Inherently, the whole point of a centralised system is dependent upon there being no central authority to make decisions.

I can't imagine how you can apply that to poker when you need a central authority or host to repair cheating, prevent children playing and combating problem gambling
It would be interesting to know if he knows their marketing campaign is using the word decentralization in a misleading way as he is the head of the division the word is supposed to be a reference to.

The rep alluded to full tilt having an rng problem, and admitted they have a back door super user possibility, while claiming in their whitepaper they have addressed the super use problem. Is the head of security aware?
Decentralised poker is the future Quote
11-09-2017 , 04:36 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Rich Checkmaker
yet he is not the 2nd, the 3rd, or the 4th person to feel that way based on your posts. is it a coincidence that so many people get the impression you are being rude??

maybe the problem is you. the way you talk/condescend to people on this forum.
Wow, this is way way off-base. Bobo Fett is the kindest, gentlest, and most informative admin/mod on all of 2+2.
Decentralised poker is the future Quote
11-09-2017 , 04:48 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nooseknot

And this is interesting to me, from a site that is using the word "decentralized" which in the crypto world is a word that points to security. That centralization is a point of failure, and the whole curx of creating security is to avoid it.
from their whitepaper... as least they think they are a decentralized .

Im guessing they would not get TheNooseProtocol ™ good housekeeping seal of decentralized approval?


Quote:
1.2. How CoinPoker can tackle these problems
The blockchain revolution has the potential to solve the key challenges identified above. It’s perhaps the
biggest hope for the future of the industry.
CoinPoker’s is an online poker platform which uses a fully decentralized programmatic set of contracts
using advanced blockchain technologies via Ethereum and other blockchain technologies. These
processes will help eliminate/limit the major online poker problems we are facing today
Decentralised poker is the future Quote

      
m