Quote:
Originally Posted by 458 Lott
Pilots can't control mechanical or electronic malfunctions, or weather, or any number of things that might arise. The point is, No matter what you do, you have to gamble at some point, and because of training, or experience, or past knowledge, the gamble you are taking is an educated gamble and you are far less likely to fail than someone with lesser skills, knowledge, and experience.
Pilots aren't asked to fly blindfolded. Poker players are. Poker players believe that "skill" can overcome this, however,I am saying that no amount of experience will save you from the abundant blindspots in poker. For example, two people consistently raise the same amount with a big pair. What skillset are you going to use to figure out how big when the flop comes 7 2 10 rainbow an they go all in? You are holding pocket jacks. What do you do, and based on what? If you are going to try and explain that you goto your memory banks of how they play to find an answer lets further consider this 1.) you have never played the person before or 2.) they are trying to trick you. Now you may say, ahh they want me to fold because they went all in,or you may say ahh they want me call because its a deliberate overbet. You could be wrong in both choices. Where is the "skill"?
Quote:
Originally Posted by 458 Lott
Luck plays a part in everything. But how much? An inexperienced poker player doesn't stand a snowballs chance in he## at a table with pros. Now he could get lucky once and make a big haul. But it won't happen too often. He/she would be so outgunned and over-matched by the skill of the pros that the odds are far too great against them to succeed.
Well this depends on what you classify as an inexperienced player. If you are saying that they only learnt the rules in the morning and they were due to play in the afternoon, then no probably not. But I also think that a "fairly experienced player" could sit at the table and have a good chance of winning.
There aren't as many levels of poker skill as people make out. People always like to use the "ultimate beginner" example to prove that skill is very important in poker but it is just common sense that someone new to something wont know what they are doing. Iam saying there is a big difference between the ultimate beginer and the experienced player but after that, there isn't much that sets anyone apart