Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Collusion or not, you be the judge Collusion or not, you be the judge

08-02-2010 , 10:47 PM
these guys look too big to be Asian imo
Collusion or not, you be the judge Quote
08-02-2010 , 10:49 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by djkelly69
meh i doubt it. people with half a brain (most 2p2ers??) would realise they could just buy 2 or 3 more aircards and play in one of their mom's basements rather than in public using a likely trackable IP address.
that's right because there are no morons on 2+2
Collusion or not, you be the judge Quote
08-02-2010 , 11:28 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by sqwerty12
that's right because there are no morons on 2+2
i didnt think mormans used computers??
Collusion or not, you be the judge Quote
08-02-2010 , 11:37 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by moki
Given that they are likely using the Borders wireless connection, and thus would be coming from the same external IP to PokerStars, the software wouldn't let them be at the same table anyway.

Not saying there can't be collusion going on here, but it's not that likely they are all sitting at the same tables.
i think this is true, so no collusion. what if they be ghosting?
Collusion or not, you be the judge Quote
08-02-2010 , 11:39 PM
Probably just sharing hand histories on Isildur1.
Collusion or not, you be the judge Quote
08-03-2010 , 05:53 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jetto
i think this is true, so no collusion. what if they be ghosting?
If there were 3 people playing on 3 laptops at same table some people would get suspicious other would say "meh".
Here however there are AT LEAST 6 laptops visible all connected to stars.
The girl that took the picture said they were playing on stars with 2 laptops EACH.
Are you blind?
How do you explain 6 laptops?
Collusion or not, you be the judge Quote
08-03-2010 , 07:26 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jetto
i think this is true, so no collusion. what if they be ghosting?
They were probably ghosting on a laptop and playing on the other. That's what ppl usually do. Anyone who likes ghosting ppl will buy a wireless card and a spare laptop because that's what friends do.
Collusion or not, you be the judge Quote
08-03-2010 , 08:11 AM
You can't have multiple accounts playing on the same table connected from the same IP address.
Collusion or not, you be the judge Quote
08-03-2010 , 08:28 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by aztecx
You can't have multiple accounts playing on the same table connected from the same IP address.
Captain Obvious to the rescue.
How about accounts connected from different IP addresses?
Collusion or not, you be the judge Quote
08-03-2010 , 09:25 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Josem
Firstly, PokerStars does not have any employees in the USA. That makes physical access to that particular location difficult.

Secondly, as has been previously discussed in this thread, people who log in from the same IP address are unable to play at the same cash game or Sit & Go Tournament table. Thus, if they were using the Borders internet connection to connect, then that rules out the possibility of them playing in the same event (and thus, any form of collusion).

You were 0 for 2 on this one. It was pretty clear (from what you quoted), that I meant someone from this thread go into the Borders, log in to Stars, PM you "Hey, screenname123 logged in from that Borders today at 10am EST". Now your system has that IP, and maybe you can find out what other accounts were on that IP at the time the photo was taken.

It's also pretty clear from the thread, that some of those laptops are using air cards. We know the software restricts multiple people from the same IP, it's been mentioned in this thread.

I realize this isn't top priority, but it would be nice to see that Stars can think out of the box on collusion issues. Stars has traditionally been good at investigating collusion cases, especially when e-mails come in accusing players. The next step is thinking outside the box. "Wow, a lot of our DON players are from China".

Maybe it's VP$IP's fault for mixing in so many jokes, but there are people in this thread (including VP$IP) who think it's over 95% these people were colluding, and who think there are ways to find out who they were.
Collusion or not, you be the judge Quote
08-03-2010 , 11:44 AM
Looks like stars needs to call the cyberpolice to get those dudes backtraced
Collusion or not, you be the judge Quote
08-03-2010 , 11:49 AM
If they were colluding, they would have to bet KK into trup QQ so that it wouldn't be obvious that they were working together.
Collusion or not, you be the judge Quote
08-03-2010 , 12:02 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by wamplerr
I meant someone from this thread go into the Borders, log in to Stars, PM you "Hey, screenname123 logged in from that Borders today at 10am EST". Now your system has that IP
Or someone from this thread go into the Borders, connect to the Wifi, open www.whatsmyip.org and then post the IP address.
Collusion or not, you be the judge Quote
08-03-2010 , 12:05 PM
Wait.... they don't look Chinese!
Collusion or not, you be the judge Quote
08-03-2010 , 12:09 PM
Collusion or not, you be the judge Quote
08-03-2010 , 12:50 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Josem
Firstly, PokerStars does not have any employees in the USA. That makes physical access to that particular location difficult.

Secondly, as has been previously discussed in this thread, people who log in from the same IP address are unable to play at the same cash game or Sit & Go Tournament table. Thus, if they were using the Borders internet connection to connect, then that rules out the possibility of them playing in the same event (and thus, any form of collusion).

Josem - I think this is not a very good response at all.

Firstly, somebody could help you get the IP address of the borders in question. I'm sure it's not too hard to look it up online.

Secondly, why are you ignoring the very obvious aspect that some of the computers have wireless air-cards?

I'm really confused by some of your responses in this thread.

Granted, this would be a slightly more difficult one to figure out and it would have been nice if the person observing this had done more than just take one picture. But I don't think figuring this out a bit further should be completely impossible.

It almost seems like you are willfully ignoring some of the other aspects discussed in this thread. I do not understand how you can NOT think it suspicious at all that one player would be playing on two different computers at the same time....much less three different guys all doing that.

The people in this thread are actually going pretty far out of their way to help you and you seem to be kind of blowing them off.
Collusion or not, you be the judge Quote
08-03-2010 , 12:55 PM
All - Based on the picture showing the outside of the building do we think it's possible that a couple are on air-cards, one would be on the Borders WiFi, and then another would be on the WiFi from one of the buildings next door?

Perhaps the fact that they can receive 2 or 3 different WiFi signals in that place on top of their 2 or 3 air-cards is why they kind of dig it...along with the nice long table, tasty beverages and awesome guitar talent while occasionally scoping the fine bookstore babes who happen by.
Collusion or not, you be the judge Quote
08-03-2010 , 01:17 PM
We need to have boots on the ground. To determine the Border's WiFi IP address, and to determine what other WiFi signals are usable from that location.

I have been to that shopping center before, but I am not even close to it now. It is on LV Blvd, down near the airport. Off the beaten track for most tourists.

Disturbing.
Collusion or not, you be the judge Quote
08-03-2010 , 01:22 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by MicroBob
Josem - I think this is not a very good response at all.

Firstly, somebody could help you get the IP address of the borders in question. I'm sure it's not too hard to look it up online.

Secondly, why are you ignoring the very obvious aspect that some of the computers have wireless air-cards?

I'm really confused by some of your responses in this thread.

Granted, this would be a slightly more difficult one to figure out and it would have been nice if the person observing this had done more than just take one picture. But I don't think figuring this out a bit further should be completely impossible.

It almost seems like you are willfully ignoring some of the other aspects discussed in this thread. I do not understand how you can NOT think it suspicious at all that one player would be playing on two different computers at the same time....much less three different guys all doing that.

The people in this thread are actually going pretty far out of their way to help you and you seem to be kind of blowing them off.
+1. does this josem dude actually work for stars? if so that is the true crime being committed. arent employess at least supposed to pretend they give a **** when dealing with customers? i would not trust my money with these people. i mean, in essence, stars is a bank and youre telling the bankers that there COULD BE a theft and providing some very good evidence. then the bankers are calling you a crazed stalker. id be withdrawing my money faster than the 3 alleged cheaters if they are indeed cheating which no one knows...yet.
Collusion or not, you be the judge Quote
08-03-2010 , 01:23 PM
I have started withdrawing my money from Stars.

Sad.
Collusion or not, you be the judge Quote
08-03-2010 , 01:28 PM
Don't worry guys, I enhanced the picture (learned it off of movies).



Don't worry, they're just railing Isildur1 and PA.
Collusion or not, you be the judge Quote
08-03-2010 , 01:33 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by VP$IP
We need to have boots on the ground. To determine the Border's WiFi IP address, and to determine what other WiFi signals are usable from that location.

I have been to that shopping center before, but I am not even close to it now. It is on LV Blvd, down near the airport. Off the beaten track for most tourists.

Disturbing.
i know that area and immediately thought these dudes were on flight delay or something. set up shop real quick and got sloppy. its still better than 50/50 that they ARENT cheating. which makes the stars response and subsequent loss of customers even more insane. REMEMBER, when it comes out that this was innocent and the dudes were just railing or something those facts do not change the stars response AT ALL.
Collusion or not, you be the judge Quote
08-03-2010 , 01:39 PM
Good point.

E. Sunset Rd. is the way to the airport car rental returns.
Collusion or not, you be the judge Quote
08-03-2010 , 01:59 PM
Someone should contact the photographer because she probably has a higher res version of this photo, assuming she didn't take it on her phone.
Collusion or not, you be the judge Quote
08-03-2010 , 02:04 PM
limon - How do think it is better than 50/50 that they aren't cheating? Just curious.

You don't need to set up a different computer with an air-card just to rail somebody.

I don't think it's 100% that they are cheating. There are some goofy scenarios and hypotheticals to justify what they are doing without it being cheating.

But I think it's less than 50/50 for 3 players to use 2 computers each AND with air-cards without it being a situation where they are breaking the rules somehow.
Collusion or not, you be the judge Quote

      
m