Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Chicago Joey accuses WPN (ACR) of massive botting and cheating, beware? Chicago Joey accuses WPN (ACR) of massive botting and cheating, beware?

02-13-2018 , 10:11 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by hAmThEkIlLeR
Could WPN have a worse response to all this? One post here from a non-modded account and a claim that they're "looking into it" when asked about security issues.

I was thinking the same thing till yesterday am when I saw a new vid for the sunday milly a rep of theirs posted in their subforum about a time adjustment. After seeing their new youtube vid that they shared with us I took it as somewhat of a middle finger. It's entirely possible I'm being oversensitive

https://forumserver.twoplustwo.com/s...2&postcount=64.
Chicago Joey accuses WPN (ACR) of massive botting and cheating, beware? Quote
02-13-2018 , 10:13 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by shutdown
https://forumserver.twoplustwo.com/2...-10am-1703767/

they're just fixing the real important stuff

They're giving the players what they want. Unless you've been living under a rock for the past few, you'd know that table camping is the #1 problem players have been complaining about in recent memory.
Chicago Joey accuses WPN (ACR) of massive botting and cheating, beware? Quote
02-13-2018 , 10:31 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by p2 dog, p2
so when one can get away with being unethical, they should be unethical by default?

there is always potential recourse. Carl Tropper already challenged Nagy to a cage match
Chicago Joey accuses WPN (ACR) of massive botting and cheating, beware? Quote
02-13-2018 , 11:39 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by mcc3504
It was a few years ago when there was a lot of collusion going on in DON's (double or nothing) sngs. Phil had a twitch stream and pretty much said if you think there is cheating going on in them then don't play. I don't know if anyone has the clip of that, but it pretty much summed up how seriously they take cheating and other security issues.
Good memory. I refer to that video in this post:

https://forumserver.twoplustwo.com/s...&postcount=416

Click the "Thread: Don Collusion Thread" link at the upper right on that page and you'll see some discussion of Phil's remarks at that time.

Unfortunately I didn't think to make a copy of that video, and it seems to be long gone from Twitch.

To WPN's credit, after making that ridiculous statement and taking a lot of heat in that thread, they eventually stopped offering DONs.
And at one point after that WPN made me do a captcha-type test at a table to prove that I was not a bot. So some efforts were made.

But I agree with mcc3504 that Phil's comment in that Twitch video showed WPN's general attitude toward game integrity then - and, apparently, still now.

Last edited by AlexTheOwl; 02-13-2018 at 11:56 AM.
Chicago Joey accuses WPN (ACR) of massive botting and cheating, beware? Quote
02-13-2018 , 12:36 PM
Chicago Joey accuses WPN (ACR) of massive botting and cheating, beware? Quote
02-13-2018 , 01:10 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by D1G1TALFOX

Taken from Joeys new vid What the actual ****, the cards on the mac client are actually changing in the middle of the hand (hand starts around 21:25). . .

First player flops a straight then a few bets go in and then the 7 turns into the 8 WTF . . .



In regards to this glitch...If you watch the original video that Joey posted on his Instagram you can hear the player say at the very beginning that the flop was originally K79 or Ks7h9c. The turn card (8c) then gets dealt and covers the Ks that was originally on the flop. This is where we first see the board. So we see 8c7h9c but there is actually a Ks under that 8c. Then the river (8d) is dealt over the 7h. Now we see a board of 8c8d9c when it is actually Ks7h9c8c8d. When the hand ends the entire board is briefly shown correctly which seems very shocking but they were all the cards that were actually dealt during the hand. To me this is just a glitch that needs to be fixed. I don't really see any reason to believe that it's anything more. The cards were simply landing in the wrong spots.
Don't get me wrong this is a huge glitch that needs to be fixed but the board did not change. It was covered
Chicago Joey accuses WPN (ACR) of massive botting and cheating, beware? Quote
02-13-2018 , 01:27 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by WTFisGRIMACE
In regards to this glitch...If you watch the original video that Joey posted on his Instagram you can hear the player say at the very beginning that the flop was originally K79 or Ks7h9c. The turn card (8c) then gets dealt and covers the Ks that was originally on the flop. This is where we first see the board. So we see 8c7h9c but there is actually a Ks under that 8c. Then the river (8d) is dealt over the 7h. Now we see a board of 8c8d9c when it is actually Ks7h9c8c8d. When the hand ends the entire board is briefly shown correctly which seems very shocking but they were all the cards that were actually dealt during the hand. To me this is just a glitch that needs to be fixed. I don't really see any reason to believe that it's anything more. The cards were simply landing in the wrong spots.
Don't get me wrong this is a huge glitch that needs to be fixed but the board did not change. It was covered
Even with this explanation, the turn card (8c) is still shown to the player before flop betting is completed.
Chicago Joey accuses WPN (ACR) of massive botting and cheating, beware? Quote
02-13-2018 , 01:32 PM
Remember when Phil Nagy gave us his 10 reasons why Donald Trump couldn't run America's Cardroom?

Lol @ #6



Chicago Joey accuses WPN (ACR) of massive botting and cheating, beware? Quote
02-13-2018 , 02:25 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by AllJackedUp
Even with this explanation, the turn card (8c) is still shown to the player before flop betting is completed.
No it's not. the video starts after the turn is dealt over the Ks. The opponent has already bet the turn card when the video starts. Hero then calls and the river is dealt over the 7h. The action then goes check check and the entire board is shown correctly (which is probably how his opponent was viewing the board the entire time). How are you gathering that he sees any cards before his opponent?
Chicago Joey accuses WPN (ACR) of massive botting and cheating, beware? Quote
02-13-2018 , 02:45 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by inmyrav
That's a strategy I've used, not in collusion with others but on my own. It's not a problem with cheating necesssarily, it's a group of players with a similar play style of late regging near the registration cut off, in an effort to get into a tournament where they can almost guarantee cashing, and possibly running up a big win (didn't work for me as I'm too impatient, but it could work for good players).

This is not against the rules in anyway, if you allow late registration you are effectively people can register whenever they choose. The problem is if the players are attempting to work together. I was not. But if you seat all the new players at a new table, then the players will APPEAR to be colluding.
+1.
I'm pretty sure it's +ev register as late as you can in any mtt, and it's also +ev to stall with a small stack close to the bubble (peolple do it on stars too). ACR have less players in their mtt so these 2 things are more effective and some people take advantage of it in a f***** up way but that doesnt mean they are colluding. (softplaying vs each other would be a strong indicator)
The site should clearly change the structure of some of their mtt if they massively reward stalling and colluding but the players are not necesserly at fault.( unless they collude obv)

Quote:
Originally Posted by AllJackedUp
No, you need to review the evidence that Joey revealed in his vid. The sharkscope data on these accounts is damning. There is little denying that they are bots working together in collusion (my guess would be that they are operated by one or a few players who are multi-accounting with their bots).
Their itm % doesn't prove they are cheating. It proves that they are taking advantage of the structure.

Quote:
Originally Posted by a dewd
No, I get what you are saying, but that is not what is happening here. They all enter at the exact same time under the same conditions. Then they time down and/or disconnect to stall into the money. I have crashed hundreds of games at the last minute that were close to and even in the money. I don't time out, just hope for a multi-way pot or sit with min cash maniacs that I can shove my way to some chips. Last minute entry with the hopes of min cashing via stalling is really not as much a strategy as it is a declaration of bankroll. The players I circled are always doing the same thing. At the very least, it is a group of people working together to exploit the clock, aka collusion.
If they really enter at the exact same second then it's obviously the same person, but if it's like within a minute right before registration close then it doesnt mean they collude.
Chicago Joey accuses WPN (ACR) of massive botting and cheating, beware? Quote
02-13-2018 , 03:20 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by WTFisGRIMACE
No it's not. the video starts after the turn is dealt over the Ks. The opponent has already bet the turn card when the video starts. Hero then calls and the river is dealt over the 7h. The action then goes check check and the entire board is shown correctly (which is probably how his opponent was viewing the board the entire time). How are you gathering that he sees any cards before his opponent?
The simple fact that this hand is at all hard to break down goes to the incompetence of this site . . .
Chicago Joey accuses WPN (ACR) of massive botting and cheating, beware? Quote
02-13-2018 , 03:29 PM
Posting from my phone & awful at quoting on 2+2 but 2nd post in this thread lays out WPN’s stance on security very clearly.
http://https://forumserver.twoplustw...cerns-1691997/

Winning_TD says, “Before you sit here and think security and I are useless we send a warning email when its a first offence. However we don’t sit there and look out for things unless someone reports it.”
Chicago Joey accuses WPN (ACR) of massive botting and cheating, beware? Quote
02-13-2018 , 03:29 PM
Late reg should not be anywhere close to the money. If the guarantee must be less then so be it. Reseating the entire tournament after the last reg break would help, but is an inconvenience to the players who have normal regged and have reads on their table.

This 5 hours of late reg stuff is bs. The incentive of the site to allow colluders to prop up the guarantee is too strong. The site gets no rake out of the actual gameplay in a tournament, and does not care if the prizes are awarded to colluders and super-users.

My very last fun ACR experience was a 80 percent vpip player who played QJo like the nuts, pre and post flop.

3-bet pot, hero early position with AKs
Flop is AT7
Hero C-bet, vil raises, hero calls
Turn is K
Hero bets, villain goes all in, hero calls
Fun game
Chicago Joey accuses WPN (ACR) of massive botting and cheating, beware? Quote
02-13-2018 , 03:40 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by fish_but_lucky
I'm pretty sure it's +ev register as late as you can in any mtt,
I'm very skeptical of this, but I'm interested to hear a case made for it. It is off-topic for this thread, but would you make a new thread to discuss it? (shoot me a PM with the link so I don't miss it).

I'm actually serious, not trolling here.


Quote:
Originally Posted by fish_but_lucky
Their itm % doesn't prove they are cheating. It proves that they are taking advantage of the structure.

If they really enter at the exact same second then it's obviously the same person, but if it's like within a minute right before registration close then it doesnt mean they collude.
I think those ITM numbers are impossible for large field MTTs unless you are colluding.

But, it's not just their ITM % that is damning. Did you watch the vid?
Chicago Joey accuses WPN (ACR) of massive botting and cheating, beware? Quote
02-13-2018 , 03:47 PM
Joey Real talk I don't know how much You would like the 9-5 anymore (I could never go back) but I just fell like hearing all Your ideas on how to catch cheating, why not talk to Galfond to make a better site with him . . .

Chicago Joey accuses WPN (ACR) of massive botting and cheating, beware? Quote
02-13-2018 , 03:47 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by AllJackedUp
I'm very skeptical of this, but I'm interested to hear a case made for it. It is off-topic for this thread, but would you make a new thread to discuss it? (shoot me a PM with the link so I don't miss it).

I'm actually serious, not trolling here.
Not much to discuss about it. It's basically ICM, the closer to a payjump you get the more a short stack is worth. Your starting stack is worth more 1 player from the money than 1000 players from the money.
Chicago Joey accuses WPN (ACR) of massive botting and cheating, beware? Quote
02-13-2018 , 03:47 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by WTFisGRIMACE
No it's not. the video starts after the turn is dealt over the Ks. The opponent has already bet the turn card when the video starts. Hero then calls and the river is dealt over the 7h. The action then goes check check and the entire board is shown correctly (which is probably how his opponent was viewing the board the entire time). How are you gathering that he sees any cards before his opponent?
The first frame of this in Joey's vid shows three cards (8c7h9c). Then, the 8d is dealt over or in place of the 7h. In Joey's vid, we don't see the Ks until showdown.

What makes you say that this starts with turn action or that the Ks was visible to the user before we see the showdown? Am I just missing it? Is there another version of this somewhere? Is there audio that I'm not hearing? TIA
Chicago Joey accuses WPN (ACR) of massive botting and cheating, beware? Quote
02-13-2018 , 04:07 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kelvis
Not much to discuss about it. It's basically ICM, the closer to a payjump you get the more a short stack is worth. Your starting stack is worth more 1 player from the money than 1000 players from the money.
What if you are a much better player than most of the field? Wouldn't it make sense to play as much as possible with as many weak players as possible?
Chicago Joey accuses WPN (ACR) of massive botting and cheating, beware? Quote
02-13-2018 , 04:07 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by AllJackedUp
The first frame of this in Joey's vid shows three cards (8c7h9c). Then, the 8d is dealt over or in place of the 7h. In Joey's vid, we don't see the Ks until showdown.

What makes you say that this starts with turn action or that the Ks was visible to the user before we see the showdown? Am I just missing it? Is there another version of this somewhere? Is there audio that I'm not hearing? TIA
Can’t confirm what happened with the K but +1 to round of betting being completed before the 8d was dealt. So video shows glitch and potentially vulnerable software but no smoking gun of ability to superuse.
Chicago Joey accuses WPN (ACR) of massive botting and cheating, beware? Quote
02-13-2018 , 04:12 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Boyle Mrunson
What if you are a much better player than most of the field? Wouldn't it make sense to play as much as possible with as many weak players as possible?
ICM is obviously based on equally skilled players.
Chicago Joey accuses WPN (ACR) of massive botting and cheating, beware? Quote
02-13-2018 , 04:13 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kidman411
Posting from my phone & awful at quoting on 2+2 but 2nd post in this thread lays out WPN’s stance on security very clearly.
http://https://forumserver.twoplustw...cerns-1691997/

Winning_TD says, “Before you sit here and think security and I are useless we send a warning email when its a first offence. However we don’t sit there and look out for things unless someone reports it.”
AKA, we have zero security.
Chicago Joey accuses WPN (ACR) of massive botting and cheating, beware? Quote
02-13-2018 , 04:22 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kelvis
ICM is obviously based on equally skilled players.
If you're late regging with levels still to play before the bubble and you're only getting 2 or 3 big blinds... I would think the fact that you have such a small percentage of the chips in play would make your ICM prize equity well below your buyin cost in most models.

This really needs it's own thread.
Chicago Joey accuses WPN (ACR) of massive botting and cheating, beware? Quote
02-13-2018 , 04:31 PM
Unless you are at a table with 5 buddies/bots who can stall and disconnect all the way until the money bursts nearly every time This also lets you combine stacks to get to above average afterwords.
Chicago Joey accuses WPN (ACR) of massive botting and cheating, beware? Quote
02-13-2018 , 04:41 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by asdf123456
these accounts give me the heebee jeebees

binvladin
bcmclawh
nitwoutborders (or some variation)
christinepoker
44bars
scoopjackson5
createmyownenergy
duuudelove69
Isn't bcmclawh a 2+2er?
Chicago Joey accuses WPN (ACR) of massive botting and cheating, beware? Quote
02-13-2018 , 04:46 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by fish_but_lucky View Post
I'm pretty sure it's +ev register as late as you can in any mtt
NO it is advantageous to start at beginning bc you have a bigger stack (more BBs) at the beginning !
+ u have more small fishes around you
+ u have more time to play more hands to build a big stack
Chicago Joey accuses WPN (ACR) of massive botting and cheating, beware? Quote

      
m