Quote:
Originally Posted by fisherfolk
The argument that software is just the next advance and are just the same as book or talking to good players is missing a key point.
The skills learned by solvers are one thing and if people use them to learn those skills then fine, but its when they are applied beyond the ability of the human memory when the game changes. No one can remember millions of hands and exact player specific tendencies. In a live brick and mortar game this means its impossible to know how far a villian plays from equilibrium. But this software does something that no human mind can do and thus changes the game and makes it an essentially unfair game.
Take chess as an example. There is nothing wrong with master using amazing tools to simulate and learn, but when they sit down next to each other if they use anything other than their minds its cheating. Similarly it is outright cheating in poker when you use tools that do things that you could never do in your head.
this. the software is good for learning but thats how it should be kept. you use it to learn/ train yourself then at the tables you apply that learning.
problem is many using those tools dont actually learn from it and struggle to apply what they learned at the tables without it running. they simply train themselves to depend on the software tools to play. take away the tools and suddenly they cant win as much. of course some people use the tools as they were really meant and improve their game with it. they might run huds while they play at times to learn but they dont always depend on it and they use the human part to do things in which the software might not suggest/hint at which actually wins them money they wouldnt have had otherwise.
huds n other training tools/aids as a training tool i have no problem with. but those who truly want to improve their skills who break the dependancy on those aids are few and far between. because greed takes over and many simply use them to try and print money. many of them probably wouldnt even play if they couldnt use any software aids because they really arent interested in playing poker or having skills. they just want fast easy quick money