Quote:
Originally Posted by Mat Sklansky
Piping in. If a mistake was made here, it was a mistake. I won't have anything further to say on the matter until we have more information and that will clearly take time.
I'd love to hear you elaborate on this at some point, Mat.
When you say "if a mistake
was made here," who do you think made it? And what was the mistake exactly—agreeing to publish a book without vetting the author more carefully? Or setting up this AMA without realizing it would blow up in both the author's and the publisher's faces?
The thing that disappoints me the most in all of this is that Eli is clearly no writer. He hasn't answered a single question in a thoughtful or insightful or entertaining manner. He hasn't told any stories at all, not about the world of high-stakes poker and not about his life before he entered that world. Saying "I wrote about this in the book" doesn't give us any taste of what the book is actually like. Saying something like "That's too long a story to tell; ask me sometime when you see me in person" is simply a copout.
I read the excerpt in Two Plus Two Magazine, and I wasn't impressed. It reminded me of Mike Matusow's book (what a waste of money that one was): A colorful character who was on TV a lot during the poker boom decides to cash in on his minor celebrity by telling some self-serving stories to a couple of coauthors (interesting that they both needed
two coauthors), who then compile and polish these oral reminiscences into a "book."
So, Eli, why'd you write the book? What did you hope to achieve? Was it your idea or someone else's? What was your working relationship with your coauthors? Did they interview and/or record you, or did you actually type up rough drafts or what? What about with your translator? Given that the book was originally published in Hebrew, I assume it was written with an Israeli audience in mind; did you alter the content or tone of the English version in any way to appeal more to an American audience?
Of course, on the basis of this thread, I don't expect you to answer any of these questions. But they are legitimate questions that a reader or prospective reader might ask an author.