Quote:
Originally Posted by Collecto
You think someone who used steroids still has the benefit of them 2 years after the fact? Ooo boy you couldn't be more wrong. I used the sauce for 15 years and 2 years off its all gone. Not even remotely close comparison to RTAs
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kebabkungen
Anecdotal evidence from some random roidmonkey trumps scientific studies, sure..
What scientific studies? From everything I've heard (or read), when a person cycles out their steroids, any effects vanish and they go back to where they were pre-PEDs. i.e. just as Collecto said.
But when it comes to PEDs (and similarly, RTA) having a lasting benefit, I think you're both right. You're just talking about two different control groups. To keep up the analogy, consider two hypothetical persons A and B. Person #1 is a non-athlete who has not lifted a weight since high school PE 15 years ago. Person #2 is active, and already lifts 3-4 days per week as part of an overall training regimen.
#1 starts pumping iron and uses PEDs to aid his routine. Simultaneously, #2 also begins introducing PEDs to his existing workout. Call that point Year 0. Both people use the same course for two years, then stop at the same time (Year 2). Then they continue to lift without steroids for two more years (Year 4).
Kebabkungen, your hypothetical poker player is the equivalent of Person #1. His transformation from Year 0 to Year 4 will be night-and-day different. However, you can't fully credit PEDs for that, because a lot of the credit for that goes to the weight room regimen.
Collecto's guy (himself) is more like #2, and the difference between specimens from Year 0 to year 4 will be minimal. He was already at a different starting point than #1, and once everything cycles out, he'll largely return to that starting point. From Year 0 to Year 2, he transformed because of the PEDs. From Year 2 to Year 4, he went back to his Year 0 state, as the effects of the PEDs wore off.
So now go back to poker players using RTA. A solver is like the weight training. Perfectly legit resource that makes you better. The RT is like the roids, it's the component of RTA that is considered cheating. Kebabkungen, your player is better in the long run because of the legit A, not because of the forbidden RT.