Quote:
Originally Posted by Cooozy
It's the overwhelming consensus (by many reputable 2p2 members) itt that Lefort is not obligated to return the money, and some good points are mentioned as to why. You've done nothing to invalidate their arguments with your statement here.
It actually is quite noble to consider returning 5k when you aren't obligated to.
Then explain his reasoning for keeping the money and why it is justified. Just because his peers with similar interests say it is ok?
The main reason he isn't paying is to prevent being freerolled. Also because in any online poker game you have no idea where the money has come from that the other players are using and it is not the player's responsibility to make sure that their opponents money comes from legitimate sources. He may be right in some regards in that maybe the Poker Site should shoulder some of the responsibility in this situation (they wont) but it doesn't change the fact that he won stolen goods and now possesses stolen goods (funds). If this had been a live game and lefort was playing the scammer heads up for cash stolen from a bank the police would take Lefort's winnings and return the $ to the bank even though Lefort had no involvement or knowledge of the original crime. Online it doesn't work like that only because it is online with no regulatory agencies. The sites themselves are the closest you are going to get anyone policing these games (which leaves the existing every man for them-self environment).
Just because Lefort assumed some risk in winning the scammers 5k doesn't mean that the stolen 5k shouldn't go back to its rightful owner.
Lefort is a known high stakes player and this 5k meant the world to the low stakes grinder and although not obligated legally he could have done the morally upstanding thing and made the scamming victim whole regardless. Even charge a "recovery fee" commensurate with whatever risk you took to peel the 5k off the scammer if you really just can't stomach the idea of being freerolled or doing something for nothing. Say half the time you would win the 5k half the time you would lose the 5k if you played this scammer in a series of freezeouts. So keep 2,500 and give the victim back 2,500. Its not perfect but neither is the solution you guys decided on in which Lefort keeps 100%.
This isn't 2 random people with vague circumstances around what happened. We know Lefort. We know the victim as a regular poster here. We know the victim was spamming support and table chat as the heads up with Lefort was happening. Stars Shoulda done more. Lefort could do more.