Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
What is your definition of racism? What is your definition of racism?

12-30-2022 , 10:50 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Luckbox Inc
The wealthiest demographic in the US might surprise you.
Doesn't really surprise me. I would have guessed that Asian Americans were wealthier on the whole than people who identify as white.
What is your definition of racism? Quote
12-30-2022 , 10:59 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by chillrob
Huh? I don't understand how this would be racist, but who in the world has done this combination?

I don't think I have ever heard anyone say it was ok to riot after a sports team wins (or loses).
You don’t have to say something is ok for it to be acceptable by society.

You don’t understand how calling black protestors domestic terrorists for protesting and burning stuff down but when sports teams riots, where is the outrage? Where are the domestic terrorist chants? I hear time and time again how BLM burnt down our cities(lol) and I have never heard anything remotely similar or malicious said about sports team protests or riots or whatever you want to call them.
What is your definition of racism? Quote
12-30-2022 , 11:11 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Luckbox Inc
The wealthiest demographic in the US might surprise you.
What’s the relevance of this?
What is your definition of racism? Quote
12-30-2022 , 11:11 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by PointlessWords
You don’t have to say something is ok for it to be acceptable by society.

You don’t understand how calling black protestors domestic terrorists for protesting and burning stuff down but when sports teams riots, where is the outrage? Where are the domestic terrorist chants? I hear time and time again how BLM burnt down our cities(lol) and I have never heard anything remotely similar or malicious said about sports team protests or riots or whatever you want to call them.
I certainly have said in this forum that all sports are incentives for violence and I heartily disapprove.
I have said elsewhere that those riots lend credence to my argument.

But I still don't see the racial aspect.
I haven't studied the sports riots, but based on the photos I have seen and the neighborhoods they have been in, black people, if not a majority, are definitely over represented in sports rioters.

And I don't know what "chants" you are referring to, but most of the protestors in 2020 were white people, where I live overwhelmingly so (probably >90%).
What is your definition of racism? Quote
12-30-2022 , 11:14 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Trolly McTrollson
What’s the relevance of this?
I'm not the one who brought it up, but I would guess it could show that racism, at least with regards to immigrant communities, is not severe enough to prevent financial success.
What is your definition of racism? Quote
12-30-2022 , 11:16 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by chillrob
I'm not the one who brought it up, but I would guess it could show that racism, at least with regards to immigrant communities, is not severe enough to prevent financial success.
Seems like a pretty absurd take.
What is your definition of racism? Quote
12-30-2022 , 11:24 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Bobo Fett
And fortunately, both of those versions are extreme enough to be pretty much non-existent on this forum, and thus not of much use in this discussion.
I hope that you are right.
What is your definition of racism? Quote
12-30-2022 , 11:27 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by browser2920
What? That makes no sense. If that was meant as a joke prob best to put some emoji thing to indicate it. Or are you just setting up a straw man to attack later?
I'm 100% serious.
What is your definition of racism? Quote
12-30-2022 , 11:27 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by shortstacker

Racism: Asserting or implying that some races are in some important sense either superior or inferior to other races.

Sexism: Asserting or implying that some sexes/genders/orientations are in some important sense superior or inferior to other sexes/genders/orientations.
This is pretty obviously far too narrow. Surely we would want to include people who have a significant animus against a race or sexism but not the specific belief about inferiority.
What is your definition of racism? Quote
12-30-2022 , 11:30 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Bobo Fett
The problem with "colorblindness" is that it can be used as a way to dismiss racism. Even if you and I and other reasonable people agree that race is a social construct and we should all treat one another equally, that doesn't change the fact that there will still be racism, that there are people disadvantaged by past and present racism, and we need to deal with it. So in my view, "colorblindness" in and of itself isn't necessarily racist, but it is often used in a way that ignores or even supports racism. So yeah, sometimes "Colorblind ideology is a Form of Racism".
I don't see how it is even logically possible to be a racist and adhere to a colorblind ideology.
What is your definition of racism? Quote
12-30-2022 , 11:35 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by shortstacker
I don't see how it is even logically possible to be a racist and adhere to a colorblind ideology.
Start off as racist. You think whites are better than browns let’s say


Then someone teaches you that browns have it much much worse than white across almost all parts of life

You accept this, but instead of trying to fix the inequality, you say well I don’t see color or believe in race, and since race nor color isn’t real, brown people can’t be treated worse than white people, because brown people and white people don’t exist, because I don’t see race
What is your definition of racism? Quote
12-30-2022 , 11:37 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Trolly McTrollson
Seems like a pretty absurd take.
Would you like to explain for us why you believe that's an absurd take?
What is your definition of racism? Quote
12-30-2022 , 11:39 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by chillrob
I'm not the one who brought it up, but I would guess it could show that racism, at least with regards to immigrant communities, is not severe enough to prevent financial success.
The pool is kinda skewed to begin no? Skilled labor/people with loot already students/bright kids etc
What is your definition of racism? Quote
12-30-2022 , 11:39 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by PointlessWords
Start off as racist. You think whites are better than browns let’s say


Then someone teaches you that browns have it much much worse than white across almost all parts of life

You accept this, but instead of trying to fix the inequality, you say well I don’t see color or believe in race, and since race nor color isn’t real, brown people can’t be treated worse than white people, because brown people and white people don’t exist, because I don’t see race
If we assume the bolded, then the person in question does not actually hold to the colorblind view.

The colorblind view is that all races are equal.

In your example, the person does see race from the get-go.
What is your definition of racism? Quote
12-30-2022 , 11:40 PM
They didn’t start off as color blind but a combination of their racism and denial led them there
What is your definition of racism? Quote
12-30-2022 , 11:46 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by PointlessWords
They didn’t start off as color blind but a combination of their racism and denial led them there
Okay. Thanks for clarifying.
What is your definition of racism? Quote
12-30-2022 , 11:56 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by wet work
The pool is kinda skewed to begin no? Skilled labor/people with loot already students/bright kids etc
Yup. It ignores lots of starting facts about various people and their other to the US. To say nothing of the weird transactional way it framed racism.
What is your definition of racism? Quote
12-31-2022 , 12:14 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Trolly McTrollson
What’s the relevance of this?
If you go back and read the post that I was responding to it should be pretty obvious.
What is your definition of racism? Quote
12-31-2022 , 12:39 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by uke_master
This is pretty obviously far too narrow. Surely we would want to include people who have a significant animus against a race or sexism but not the specific belief about inferiority.
Actually, it is this category you mention, and not the other, that is racism.
What is your definition of racism? Quote
12-31-2022 , 12:44 AM
Racism is like pornography, you’ll know it when you see it.
What is your definition of racism? Quote
12-31-2022 , 01:50 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by PointlessWords
They didn’t start off as color blind but a combination of their racism and denial led them there
It led them to claim to be color blind, not to actually be.
Obviously someone who is racist isn't going to actually become color blind.
What is your definition of racism? Quote
12-31-2022 , 01:51 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by PointlessWords
Start off as racist. You think whites are better than browns let’s say


Then someone teaches you that browns have it much much worse than white across almost all parts of life

You accept this, but instead of trying to fix the inequality, you say well I don’t see color or believe in race, and since race nor color isn’t real, brown people can’t be treated worse than white people, because brown people and white people don’t exist, because I don’t see race
You're still not explaining how this makes a person racist fwiw. It's not enough to treat people the same, instead you have to be actively working to fix inequality to not be a racist? Don't you think that's a pretty high bar?
What is your definition of racism? Quote
12-31-2022 , 03:52 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Rococo
There are a lot of white people in the American South who espouse the following ideology: "I don't see color. My children go to school with kids of different races. I work with people of different races. For at least the last forty years, racism hasn't been a significant factor in society or a significant impediment to the advancement of non-white people in the United States."
Exactly.

Quote:
Originally Posted by shortstacker
I don't see how it is even logically possible to be a racist and adhere to a colorblind ideology.
I think PW has done a good job of addressing this, but I'll add some points of my own.

First off, I'll note that I didn't suggest that adhering to a colourblind ideology makes someone racist (nor did you suggest I did). I would think most, and maybe all, people who sincerely believe in a colourblind world (and truly walk the walk), do not have hatred for people of other skin colours. I'm leaving aside inherent biases they may be unaware of. So to that extent, I might agree that one can not be a true racist and sincerely adhere to a colourblind ideology. Not just because said ideology would mean no races, thus they can't be racist, but also because said sincere adherence means they hold no such hatred.

But that still leaves us with an important issue that Rococo has alluded to. True racists will use "colourblindness" as cover to avoid righting any wrongs, while well-meaning people can be blinded by their "colourblindness", as in Rococo's quote. And there are lots of people in between, who are quite willfully ignorant - they know or suspect things aren't right, but would prefer to just brush that aside and say it's all OK as long as they treat people equally now. Are all of these people racist? I believe most people would say no. But I'm not unsympathetic to those who would argue otherwise, because it's ****ing 2022 and how the hell can you possibly be ignorant of the impact of past racism and the racist policies and attitudes that still exist today?
What is your definition of racism? Quote
12-31-2022 , 10:12 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by wet work
The pool is kinda skewed to begin no? Skilled labor/people with loot already students/bright kids etc
Obviously this is a significant factor.
What is your definition of racism? Quote
12-31-2022 , 10:14 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by David Sklansky
Actually, it is this category you mention, and not the other, that is racism.
Elaborate please.
What is your definition of racism? Quote

      
m