Quote:
Originally Posted by Montrealcorp
All I see in your chart is bottom 50% losing around 25/30% of income and almost half in wealth since 1950 .
And 1950s middle class , we’re getting wealthy again .
It’s even worst when you take a more comparable data set like the end of the 1920 early 1930 ..
Yes.
It is what I refer to as taking real data, taking a selective knife cut that best makes the case you want to present while excluding the wider data set that far more clearly shows the position is wrong.
TS was famous for that in the Covid BFI thread.
There simply is no denying that the MC have lost substantial ground as the uber wealthy have gained. Much of that was what was gutted in the 2008/9 Mortgage debacle, which some here pretend hurt the uber rich too as they point to 'some' firms that did badly but the fact is Investment banking sector overall and the uber rich overall reaped massive benefits from this crash and then the bounce back.
The main reasons where that they got the mass amount of gov't bailout money (IB firms) and were the buyers of all the 'on sale' assets.
I recently saw Janet Yellen on John Stewards new show defending the bail out cash to the giant Investment Banks saying that if that money was not injected and the Investment Banks allowed to crash it would have caused a massive liquidity crisis that would have spiralled the US into a great recession or Depression.
I wish Jon fired back with, most US citizens do not hold their mortgages with Wall Street Investment Banks. Most hold with smaller Community Banks. If instead of giving all that money Top Down through the giant banks, which triggered a foreclosure spree at the community level bank level with Wall Street firms then swooping in to buy them up and you celebrating that as REQUIRED LIQUIDITY for the market...
... If instead of that the same amount of money was given as a Mortgage credit to each and every Mortgage holder that they had to pay to their community bank to reduce their mortgage obligation then that would have created the market liquidity you say was needed but at the Mid Tier level. It would have elevated the Community banks while helping rid society of these 'Too Big To Fail Banks' or forcing them to consolidate and realize they could not gamble counting on bailouts in the future.
Instead we got the worst of both worlds. Local homeowners booted out as discount prices and firm like Steve Mnuchin's provided gov't guarantees on down side risk if they would race into the market and buy up these fire sale homes for his firms Investors. And once Mnuchin has those downside guarantees he was able to raise a ton of money to do so.