Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
[US Politics] Why do people support liberal policy when the results are poor? [US Politics] Why do people support liberal policy when the results are poor?

09-26-2023 , 10:45 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by lozen
Hold it did you guys not say Obama could not codify roe v wade because some Democrats would vote for it ?
I am not sure I am reading this correctly.

But we know that the democrats did not have the votes in the senate to codify roe. I don't think it's the case anymore, but there were pro-life dems at the time.
[US Politics] Why do people support liberal policy when the results are poor? Quote
09-26-2023 , 10:47 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by caseIIclosed
This is some wild stuff to say. Do you have friends in your life who are women who are into politics? Can you please tell them that the left and right both mostly agree on abortion and see what they say. Do so in person, I think you should deal with getting laughed at in person.
sorry, democrat/leftist politicians. almost all reasonable people believe in abortion rights, its the politicians who do not. Or rather, the leftist politicians do not believe in abortion enough to make it into law. The left has never ran on a platform of making abortion a stated right. Are they running on that platform rn?
[US Politics] Why do people support liberal policy when the results are poor? Quote
09-26-2023 , 11:16 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by caseIIclosed
No, I don't think that's it.


I generally see foreign policy very differently that domestic policy. It's easy to see the difference in ideology between dems and republicans when you look at their domestic policy.
Domestic policy is allowed to be different because it doesn't matter as much, and it helps to differentiate the two parties. People like you can look at stuff like abortion and say "I have to vote Democrat", and vice-versa. This helps to uphold the status quo-- which is entrenched corporate power, militarism, and the general explotation of humanity

People like PW, Victor, myself see that corporate power as the bigger problem and understand that that will never go away with Democrats or Republicans in charge. It doesn't mean that all of the domestic issues that differentiate the two parties are unimportant-- but they do ultimately take a back seat to the fact that Democrats are team Citi and Republicans team GS. You can still care about abortion and acknowledge that.
[US Politics] Why do people support liberal policy when the results are poor? Quote
09-26-2023 , 11:19 AM
Who allows it to be different? I am not sure what you mean there.
[US Politics] Why do people support liberal policy when the results are poor? Quote
09-26-2023 , 11:22 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by caseIIclosed
I am not sure I am reading this correctly.

But we know that the democrats did not have the votes in the senate to codify roe. I don't think it's the case anymore, but there were pro-life dems at the time.
Yup I missed a not
[US Politics] Why do people support liberal policy when the results are poor? Quote
09-26-2023 , 11:32 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by caseIIclosed
Who allows it to be different?
You know, the (((bankers))).
[US Politics] Why do people support liberal policy when the results are poor? Quote
09-26-2023 , 11:39 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Trolly McTrollson
You know, the (((bankers))).
Why are you spreading anti-semitic tropes?
[US Politics] Why do people support liberal policy when the results are poor? Quote
09-26-2023 , 11:45 AM
Trolly is filling in the blanks where you left them in your post. I am curious what corporations have the ability to control domestic policy. Do they have meetings? Is anything in writing?
[US Politics] Why do people support liberal policy when the results are poor? Quote
09-26-2023 , 11:46 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by PointlessWords
sorry, democrat/leftist politicians. almost all reasonable people believe in abortion rights, its the politicians who do not.
I don't think I've seen many "Politician Wanted" ads lately in the classifieds.

How do politicians get to be, you know, politicians?
[US Politics] Why do people support liberal policy when the results are poor? Quote
09-26-2023 , 11:53 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by d2_e4
I don't think I've seen many "Politician Wanted" ads lately in the classifieds.

How do politicians get to be, you know, politicians?
They pander for money from the rich and tell them they will change the laws to make them more wealth
[US Politics] Why do people support liberal policy when the results are poor? Quote
09-26-2023 , 11:53 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Luckbox Inc
Domestic policy is allowed to be different because it doesn't matter as much, and it helps to differentiate the two parties. People like you can look at stuff like abortion and say "I have to vote Democrat", and vice-versa. This helps to uphold the status quo-- which is entrenched corporate power, militarism, and the general explotation of humanity

People like PW, Victor, myself see that corporate power as the bigger problem and understand that that will never go away with Democrats or Republicans in charge. It doesn't mean that all of the domestic issues that differentiate the two parties are unimportant-- but they do ultimately take a back seat to the fact that Democrats are team Citi and Republicans team GS. You can still care about abortion and acknowledge that.
Mods should sticky this
[US Politics] Why do people support liberal policy when the results are poor? Quote
09-26-2023 , 11:56 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by PointlessWords
They pander for money from the rich and tell them they will change the laws to make them more wealth
Ok, now we're motoring. Presumably they pander to the rich because they want money. What do they want this money for?
[US Politics] Why do people support liberal policy when the results are poor? Quote
09-26-2023 , 12:02 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by PointlessWords
Mods should sticky this
It does show that some points substitute their own reality when they don't like the results of what is actually happening. It might reduce conflict if people know about this before getting into arguments.
[US Politics] Why do people support liberal policy when the results are poor? Quote
09-26-2023 , 12:05 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by d2_e4
I don't think I've seen many "Politician Wanted" ads lately in the classifieds.

How do politicians get to be, you know, politicians?
My explanation is much more honest and real.

People decide on their own they want to run for office or they're talked into it by people they know. From there they decide what office they're looking for, if they did not already have one in mind.

From that people the path of a politician can go a variety of different ways. You can run in a primary for a seat or you can go into an open election. You have to learn about the local rules and assemble a team to support you in your bid. Raising money is definitely part of it. But there is so much more than just money.
[US Politics] Why do people support liberal policy when the results are poor? Quote
09-26-2023 , 12:23 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by caseIIclosed
Trolly is filling in the blanks where you left them in your post. I am curious what corporations have the ability to control domestic policy. Do they have meetings? Is anything in writing?
Trolly thinks that corporations are controlled by Jews? Do you think that as well? It would seem you do.

I'm happy to report to you that people of all stripes run corporations and banks. You should probably look into it.

Corporations control all sorts of domestic policy though. You don't think healthcare, or agriculture, or power, or the policies of numerous industries aren't corporate controlled?

And yes sometimes they have meetings. Have you ever heard of corporate lobbyists?
[US Politics] Why do people support liberal policy when the results are poor? Quote
09-26-2023 , 12:27 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Luckbox Inc
Trolly thinks that corporations are controlled by Jews? Do you think that as well? It would seem you do.

I'm happy to report to you that people of all stripes run corporations and banks. You should probably look into it.

Corporations control all sorts of domestic policy though. You don't think healthcare, or agriculture, or power, or the policies of numerous industries aren't corporate controlled?

And yes sometimes they have meetings. Have you ever heard of corporate lobbyists?
I think trolly intended his post as a joke. Hopefully he can clear up the rest.

I do not think that jewish people control corporations. That's the antithesis to my views.

So what happens when two corporate lobbyist disagree? Which one of them gets to decide policy?
[US Politics] Why do people support liberal policy when the results are poor? Quote
09-26-2023 , 12:36 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by caseIIclosed
My explanation is much more honest and real.

People decide on their own they want to run for office or they're talked into it by people they know. From there they decide what office they're looking for, if they did not already have one in mind.

From that people the path of a politician can go a variety of different ways. You can run in a primary for a seat or you can go into an open election. You have to learn about the local rules and assemble a team to support you in your bid. Raising money is definitely part of it. But there is so much more than just money.
You're making this a lot more complicated than it needs to be.

Politicians get voted in based on their policy promises. PW seems to think that what politicians want differs from what ordinary people (i.e. voters) want. While I can see this being the case in some areas of policy/legislation, I find it hard to believe that the will of the people differs significantly from the will of their elected representatives when it comes to abortion.
[US Politics] Why do people support liberal policy when the results are poor? Quote
09-26-2023 , 12:37 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by caseIIclosed
I think trolly intended his post as a joke. Hopefully he can clear up the rest.

I do not think that jewish people control corporations. That's the antithesis to my views.

So what happens when two corporate lobbyist disagree? Which one of them gets to decide policy?


Lucky's conspiracies about how the banks secretly run the government totally aren't at all like generations of ugly conspiracies about banks secretly running the government. Silly me for drawing the comparison!
[US Politics] Why do people support liberal policy when the results are poor? Quote
09-26-2023 , 12:38 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by caseIIclosed
So what happens when two corporate lobbyist disagree? Which one of them gets to decide policy?
It's not really a serious question but before I address it, you do acknowledge that there are plenty of industries that are corporate controlled, but you just are interested in how the sausage is made?
[US Politics] Why do people support liberal policy when the results are poor? Quote
09-26-2023 , 12:41 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Trolly McTrollson
Lucky's conspiracies about how the banks secretly run the government totally aren't at all like generations of ugly conspiracies about banks secretly running the government. Silly me for drawing the comparison!
https://newrepublic.com/article/1377...illary-clinton

Citibank literally picked Obama's cabinet. You act like I just make this stuff up...I do not.
[US Politics] Why do people support liberal policy when the results are poor? Quote
09-26-2023 , 12:43 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Luckbox Inc
It's not really a serious question but before I address it, you do acknowledge that there are plenty of industries that are corporate controlled, but you just are interested in how the sausage is made?
Yes, there are private industries controlled by corporations.

I know how the sausage is made in reality. I have experience with campaigns and elected officials. I know value of money in politics and the influence of lobbyists.

What I know is that the voters matter most of all. Corporations, lobbyists, and the wealthy have influence. but the voters have control.
[US Politics] Why do people support liberal policy when the results are poor? Quote
09-26-2023 , 01:32 PM
What are the u.s. industries not controlled by corporate interests?
[US Politics] Why do people support liberal policy when the results are poor? Quote
09-26-2023 , 01:48 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by jjjou812
What are the u.s. industries not controlled by corporate interests?
Since incorporating is so easy and useful I would imagine no industry is outside corporate control or influence. The government sits on top of all corporations so I guess it's a matter of semantics.
[US Politics] Why do people support liberal policy when the results are poor? Quote
09-26-2023 , 02:10 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Victor
books have been written on the subject and you think I would be capable of summarizing it to something he find acceptable?
That's the very reason why it's helpful to hear your definition of it - it's a term that's used a lot of different ways by different people.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Victor
you actually think his question was in good faith and not an attempt to find something to criticize and nitpick?
I can't speak for d2, but I certainly wanted to hear your answer to better understand your posts. You wield the term as something of a cudgel most of the time, so I've never been clear on your understanding of it.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Victor
regardless, I answered it 3 times.
Yes, but never once in a way that helped with an understanding...until now.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Victor
I agree with the wikipedia definition of liberal.

for example, both USA parties are liberal. the entire Dem party and about 90% of the Repubs are liberals.
Thanks! Sincerely.

It's not like this is some grand revelation that I never could have come close to guessing, but I prefer to hear it from you and know rather than assume. And yours and other's answers have actually led to some interesting discussion today.
[US Politics] Why do people support liberal policy when the results are poor? Quote
09-26-2023 , 02:20 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Bobo Fett
Ah, so it's OK to lock innocent people up in a mental health facility. OK then. Good thing there's no potential problems with giving people that kind of power.
gotta have a positive, healthy, legal ,ethical solution for when people are going crazy and are a threat to themselves or others.
[US Politics] Why do people support liberal policy when the results are poor? Quote

      
m