Quote:
Originally Posted by tame_deuces
A large part of your minority community (and many others) have told you for a century and half about this problem, they have never been silent about it and they have told you that the problem still goes deep. Many of the leaders of this movement have been deeply respected men and women.
Don't pretend that it just suddenly cropped up in the heads of an irrational mob incapable of perspective and introspection. That is just a convenient excuse. People have been telling you about this for years, and they have done so when there were no mass demonstrations in the streets as well. In fact many of the leaders of these movements have warned about the dangers of doing nothing and reaching a boiling point.
That there are also factors such as poverty and disadvantage has not been omitted either. Again, this sounds like a very convenient excuse to ignore the problem and pretend it is about some raging mob.
A problem was left to fester. People have been talking about it for a long time, not enough happened and a lot of people got angry. It's a story about as old as civilization.
Nobody is arguing that racism and bigotry don't exist in America.I personally haven't said anything about raging mobs either. But you're being way too simplistic. Americans are incapable of having a frank honest productive discussion about race and the socio/economic/cultural factors which fuels racism,preferring currently to adhere to narratives instead.
Anti Irish sentiments was mentioned earlier itt and as an Irish person I can certainly identify with bigotry directed at others be they black Jewish Muslim gay or whoever. But leftist American perceptions of racism appears to be whitey bad and all cops bad and all black people killed by cops is due to racism that's all she wrote and that's bs as there are far more factors at play here.
I inked earlier a "NO IRISH need apply" job advert from 2012 in Australia. As an Irish person I also recognise the context- the employer was probably pissed off at Irish people bs'ng they could do a skilled job when they couldn't hence his exasperation as well as the economic reasons my fellow Irish felt the need to bs to gain employment. Those are the issues which need to be examined instead of me decrying prejudice and leaving it at that.
I also linked anti Irish sentiment in England which was partially due to the IRA committing acts of mass murder. So such context needs to be examined instead of simply decrying such sentiments and leaving it at that.
When I was researching the CP5 case mentioned on another thread I saw nothing but tribalism from the majority of Americans arguing for either innocence or guilt, most of it being based on race. White racists referring to them as "thugs", "subhumans" or "dindoonuffins" and black racists referring to the prosecution and anyone who opined guilt as "devils" which seems to be just as much a "racist dog whistle" as "thugs" as well as denigrating the victim for her arrogance of jogging in a park thinking she was untouchable. Was the actual evidence discussed? Hellz no cuz it's all about which racial camp you're in.
You have white racists thinking every police shooting is justified if the victim is black and leftist commentators ignoring white people killed by the cops and lumping in the likes of Michael Brown shot after trying to snatch a gun from a cop with George Floyd. Basically context is thrown out the window in favour of narratives.
The fact that the majority of black people shot by the cops seem to be primarily young black males from low income areas is ignored also. Or that some of them have had criminal records which certainly doesn't justify shootings or police brutality but gives a sense of context as to why some people- black and white- come into contact with the police to begin with as I've never heard of black pensioners being killed by the cops for example or squeaky clean young black men. (and I'm not saying that's
never happened either but consistent patterns are ignored, the same patterns I've see in my own original mainly white neighbourhood)
You all also seem to see black people by their colour first whether you're a racist who sees them as crims or a leftist who sees them all as victims.
Which I've been subjected to. When I was growing up I never wanted to be seen as a "deprived area" person by simpering liberal do gooders just so they could feel good about themselves and superior to me. Nor did I want to be seen as a criminal, a thug a thief or a drug dealer due to my "deprived area" status.
I wanted to be seen as a person and judged on my merits and flaws just like those from nicer areas. Rather than by my class and the same thing is happening with black people over your way. But for this to happen I have to have a sense of personal responsibility and recognise that individual members of my community made things bad for me and led to such attitudes as well as recognising the context- the sense of being disenfranchised and futility and hopelessness- that led to members of my community making it bad for the rest of us.
I am
not an inherent victim because of my class and I'm sure there's lots of black people who don't wish to be see as inherent victims or criminals due to their race. Because it's patronizing condescending bs And it's dangerously counterproductive because it's led to policies from the American "left" that seem designed to keep minorities from having self determination as well as a one sided narrative leading to the growth of the alt right.
I actually understand and can identify with these issues more than you might think. But if you guys can't have open honest discussions about the myriad of issues which has led you to this juncture then you're doomed to forever be in a vicious circle. And that won't help any of you or your society or successive generations.