Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
RADICAL Leftists, please stand up! RADICAL Leftists, please stand up!

01-08-2023 , 02:10 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Luckbox Inc
One thing about this thread is that at least we're discussing actual Leftism.

Oftentimes when the left is discussed what is actually being discussed is "the left"-- aka the psuedo-left, and I've gotten much gruff in the past for saying that Democrats, progressives, and even the "woke", aren't actually left, and that they have nothing to do with any of the points in the OP save perhaps open borders, which is actually a right-wing position.

You are using your own political definition of 'left' though right?

As most definitions, used by bodies that define this would see Progressives fall on the left side of the spectrum.

For instance i always like to say this when it comes to Canada and US when it comes to Left | Centre | Right politics on the spectrum of the two nations when considering major parties.


NDP ................... Liberal Party/Conservative Party (Progressives if they were a party) | Centre | ............Democrat Party ............. GOP ........... (Trumpists if they split out)

i would be interested to see how others plot this and also adding in where some major European Parties fall.
RADICAL Leftists, please stand up! Quote
01-08-2023 , 02:25 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cuepee
You are using your own political definition of 'left' though right?

As most definitions, used by bodies that define this would see Progressives fall on the left side of the spectrum.

For instance i always like to say this when it comes to Canada and US when it comes to Left | Centre | Right politics on the spectrum of the two nations when considering major parties.


NDP ................... Liberal Party/Conservative Party (Progressives if they were a party) | Centre | ............Democrat Party ............. GOP ........... (Trumpists if they split out)

i would be interested to see how others plot this and also adding in where some major European Parties fall.
You forgot the Bloc and Peoples Party in Canada
RADICAL Leftists, please stand up! Quote
01-08-2023 , 06:01 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cuepee
You are using your own political definition of 'left' though right?

As most definitions, used by bodies that define this would see Progressives fall on the left side of the spectrum.

For instance i always like to say this when it comes to Canada and US when it comes to Left | Centre | Right politics on the spectrum of the two nations when considering major parties.


NDP ................... Liberal Party/Conservative Party (Progressives if they were a party) | Centre | ............Democrat Party ............. GOP ........... (Trumpists if they split out)

i would be interested to see how others plot this and also adding in where some major European Parties fall.
The most "center" party in the U.S.A. would probably be the Green Party.
RADICAL Leftists, please stand up! Quote
01-08-2023 , 06:19 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Doctor Zeus
Do you mean because of their history or also today?

Can see both
I mean today. it applies to history too but like, Im not ripping on Spain for **** they did in 1600 altho that **** still influences today to some degree.

but to be even more flippant, and cliche, there is no ethical consumption within capitalism.

and that just means that those nations benefit greatly from cheap resources from exploited nations. even if their exploitation of their own people is minimal (its surely not), they are still maintaining their lifestyle due to the world economy relying on thievery and murder within resource rich nations.
RADICAL Leftists, please stand up! Quote
01-08-2023 , 06:25 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Victor
I mean today. it applies to history too but like, Im not ripping on Spain for **** they did in 1600 altho that **** still influences today to some degree.

but to be even more flippant, and cliche, there is no ethical consumption within capitalism.

and that just means that those nations benefit greatly from cheap resources from exploited nations. even if their exploitation of their own people is minimal (its surely not), they are still maintaining their lifestyle due to the world economy relying on thievery and murder within resource rich nations.
You're not wrong.

Ironically, it's because of capitalist nations like the U.S.A. that make it possible for the Nordic countries to do so well.

There is a reason why Switzerland's two most significant contributions to mankind are the Swiss Army Knife and the Cuckoo Clock.

addendum: If Bill Gates wasn't so money-hungry, few of us would even have a computer.
RADICAL Leftists, please stand up! Quote
01-08-2023 , 07:39 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by shortstacker
You're not wrong.

Ironically, it's because of capitalist nations like the U.S.A. that make it possible for the Nordic countries to do so well.

There is a reason why Switzerland's two most significant contributions to mankind are the Swiss Army Knife and the Cuckoo Clock.

addendum: If Bill Gates wasn't so money-hungry, few of us would even have a computer.
I absolutely agree that US hegemony gives the Nordic countries their lifestyle to a certain extent.

I vehemently disagree on the Bill Gates addendum in your post tho.
RADICAL Leftists, please stand up! Quote
01-08-2023 , 09:16 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by shortstacker
You're not wrong.

Ironically, it's because of capitalist nations like the U.S.A. that make it possible for the Nordic countries to do so well.

There is a reason why Switzerland's two most significant contributions to mankind are the Swiss Army Knife and the Cuckoo Clock.

addendum: If Bill Gates wasn't so money-hungry, few of us would even have a computer.
Switzerland is not remotely a Nordic country, lol thats a bad take.
RADICAL Leftists, please stand up! Quote
01-08-2023 , 11:17 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Rococo
How do you propose to implement the bolded on a large scale without the assistance of something that walks, talks, and looks like a government?
Caldari mega corps
RADICAL Leftists, please stand up! Quote
01-08-2023 , 11:19 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cuepee
You are using your own political definition of 'left' though right?

As most definitions, used by bodies that define this would see Progressives fall on the left side of the spectrum.
Yeah progressives are on the right. They love the state and love power.
RADICAL Leftists, please stand up! Quote
01-08-2023 , 11:29 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Luckbox Inc
Yeah progressives are on the right. They love the state and love power.
Yep, let capitalists have free reign imo. They dont care about power.

There other possible configurations, but in the state of play as it is the only available check of power to capitalists is the state, this is why progressives are in favour of it, but that is a hugely gross simplification.
RADICAL Leftists, please stand up! Quote
01-08-2023 , 11:55 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Luckbox Inc
Yeah progressives are on the right. They love the state and love power.
I think only Libertarians and Anarchists love neither the state nor power.

Which almost by itself is a good reason to support Libertarians and Anarchists.
RADICAL Leftists, please stand up! Quote
01-08-2023 , 11:59 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by shortstacker
I think only Libertarians and Anarchists love neither the state nor power.

Which almost by itself is a good reason to support Libertarians and Anarchists.
Says they guy who is prepared to let X% of innocent people die so we can have the death penalty, the ultimate expression of state power.
RADICAL Leftists, please stand up! Quote
01-09-2023 , 12:05 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by IAMTHISNOW
Switzerland is not remotely a Nordic country, lol thats a bad take.
Thanks for the correction.

Since I almost always see snow in pictures of Switzerland, I thought that made them Nordic by definition.

That said, my point that Democratic-Socialist countries benefiting from American capitalism I believe is still valid.
RADICAL Leftists, please stand up! Quote
01-09-2023 , 12:08 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by IAMTHISNOW
Says they guy who is prepared to let X% of innocent people die so we can have the death penalty, the ultimate expression of state power.
1. Many Libertarians support the death penalty.

2. Many Anarchists support the death-penalty as well. It's just not the state-authorized version of killing people.
RADICAL Leftists, please stand up! Quote
01-09-2023 , 12:10 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by shortstacker
Thanks for the correction.

Since I almost always see snow in pictures of Switzerland, I thought that made them Nordic by definition.

That said, my point that Democratic-Socialist countries benefiting from American capitalism I believe is still valid.
I dont know if I am being leveled here.

Snow = nordic wat?

Switzerland is so far from being Noridic, but snow?
RADICAL Leftists, please stand up! Quote
01-09-2023 , 12:11 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by shortstacker
1. Many Libertarians support the death penalty.

2. Many Anarchists support the death-penalty as well. It's just not the state-authorized version of killing people.
Libertarians supporting the death penalty is an oxymoron.

We did this already but you are simply a conservative without the self awareness to realise it.
RADICAL Leftists, please stand up! Quote
01-09-2023 , 12:15 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by IAMTHISNOW
Libertarians supporting the death penalty is an oxymoron.

We did this already but you are simply a conservative without the self awareness to realise it.
Of course I'm a conservative. I've never said otherwise. I'm a tad to the right of the border of Libertopia and Conservatopia. (I think those are both Nordic countries. )
RADICAL Leftists, please stand up! Quote
01-09-2023 , 12:17 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by IAMTHISNOW
I dont know if I am being leveled here.

Snow = nordic wat?

Switzerland is so far from being Noridic, but snow?
I think you missed the smiley.

Say 'hi' to my friend Smiley:

RADICAL Leftists, please stand up! Quote
01-09-2023 , 12:22 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by IAMTHISNOW
Libertarians supporting the death penalty is an oxymoron.

We did this already but you are simply a conservative without the self awareness to realise it.
Really?


From wikipedia:
Quote:
Most libertarians oppose capital punishment. They argue that capital punishment is an extreme exertion of state power, it is contrary to the values of a free society, authoritarian countries tend to be retentionist, and liberal-democratic societies generally abolitionist.
RADICAL Leftists, please stand up! Quote
01-09-2023 , 12:23 AM
You are someone who wants the state to be as small as possible when it comes to issues you dont care about but as large and as powerful as possible over issues you do care about.

You dont have any ideological commitment to a small state in and of itself, as good in and of itself, because if you did, you could never support the death penalty without holding a contradictory position.

Above you claim:
Quote:
I think only Libertarians and Anarchists love neither the state nor power.

Which almost by itself is a good reason to support Libertarians and Anarchists.
However you dont support a lack/absence of state power, because you support the death penalty, which is the ultimate presence of state power.
RADICAL Leftists, please stand up! Quote
01-09-2023 , 12:25 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by shortstacker
Really?


From wikipedia:
Eh?

Me : Libertarians supporting the death penalty is an oxymoron.

You: Wiki saying most libertarians oppose the death penalty.

What are you arguing here?
RADICAL Leftists, please stand up! Quote
01-09-2023 , 01:21 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by IAMTHISNOW
You are someone who wants the state to be as small as possible when it comes to issues you dont care about but as large and as powerful as possible over issues you do care about.
Nailed it !
Pretty much the majority of republicans ….

The contradictions they hold without them even seeing it is insanely high .

Last edited by Montrealcorp; 01-09-2023 at 01:29 AM.
RADICAL Leftists, please stand up! Quote
01-09-2023 , 01:27 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by shortstacker

That said, my point that Democratic-Socialist countries benefiting from American capitalism I believe is still valid.
U probably under appreciate how fortunate you are to have the world reserve currency as your domestic currency.
Don’t worry majority of Americans have no idea …..

U seem to claim USA just gives away without gaining anything in return !
There is nothing more easier to print paper currency that has no value (debts) and ship them overseas to have real cheap stuff in exchanges …..
As long people believe the US can pay down its debt it’s fine but that game is coming to an end soon and many Americans eyes will realize a lot of things afterwards.

All successful empire/superpower ends the same way historically.
RADICAL Leftists, please stand up! Quote
01-09-2023 , 03:02 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by IAMTHISNOW
You are someone who wants the state to be as small as possible when it comes to issues you dont care about but as large and as powerful as possible over issues you do care about.

You dont have any ideological commitment to a small state in and of itself, as good in and of itself, because if you did, you could never support the death penalty without holding a contradictory position.

Above you claim:


However you dont support a lack/absence of state power, because you support the death penalty, which is the ultimate presence of state power.
How many more times do I have to tell you that I am neither a libertarian nor an anarchist?
RADICAL Leftists, please stand up! Quote
01-09-2023 , 03:06 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by IAMTHISNOW
Eh?

Me : Libertarians supporting the death penalty is an oxymoron.

You: Wiki saying most libertarians oppose the death penalty.

What are you arguing here?
That being a libertarian and being in favor of capital punishment is not an oxymoron.

Just like there are libertarians who support abortion rights and libertarians who don't.
RADICAL Leftists, please stand up! Quote

      
m