Quote:
Originally Posted by Used2Play
Why do you dismiss the fact that a drunk and suicidal man is pointing a gun at police that may have a bullet in the chamber as being no big deal? I don’t mind the first cop making a judgment call that it’s unlikely to have a round and I don’t mind the judgment call by a cop that the gun could be loaded, the guy is erratic and many people have committed suicide by cop not just by pointing a gun at police but actually shooting at them.
I don't dismiss anything but full context should always matter.
The women called in that the guy was trying to commit suicide by cop and had a gun with no clip in it.
The cop arriving on scene is faced with a guy just saying over and over 'Just shoot me' which is both an appeal to put him out of his misery but also a call for help. It is similar to the guy on the ledge who is willing to talk to any one before actually jumping.
If this guy was totally committed to suicide he could have killed himself or better yet just remained silent, walked directly towards the cops, gun in hand and forced them to shoot. Instead he kept vocally saying 'just shoot me'.
So all of this calls for caution and understanding. The police, imo, owe this man a chance to be talked down and surrender and not an execution as he won't immediately follow every command.
You seem to be one of those people who believe police should have zero risk in their job and if they face anything greater than 0 they are fine to shoot. So that leads you to believe a series of POTENTIAL dangers are always enough to shoot.
- Sure he has no clip but POTENTIALLY there is a single round in chamber ...so shoot
- sure it is unlikely with a single round he is going to hit at all, let alone a lethal shot on officers almost certainly wearing vests, but still 'I've watched Westerns and seen guys trick shot kill 3 guys with one bullet', ...so shoot.
I guess i would put another way because America is the most likely jurisdiction where the police would act so quickly and callously when faced with someone clearly suicidal. I've prior seen some stats showing 'suicide call engagement by cops end in death' far more in America. Why do you think other police, in other countries often handle this without killing?