Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Israel/Palestine thread Israel/Palestine thread

01-28-2024 , 05:59 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Luciom
I believe this if you link to me your well thought, well rehearsed posts against the brutality of Saudi Arabia government, another ally of america

Over the years in this thread I've referred to the despotic nature of the House of Saud.

But here's the thing. There are no Saudi truthers here arguing the contrary. Find some truthers claiming the virtuous nature of SA and I'll start singing the praises of the murdered journalist Jamal Khashoggi and talk about beheadings and not allowing women to drive, etc. I know a thing or two about Vietnam, Central America, and Korean wars also. I actually know more about them than the Mideast. But those will be very short conversations because no one defends them. Israel/Palestine is current and controversial. It has plenty of Israel truthers to argue with. Hence, one subject gets most of the vim and vigor.

Note also the inherent weakness of your argument. You are suggesting critics of Israel are antisemetic because they talk more about Israel than other places. But even if true, it in no way denies the genocidal facts of the current campaign. It's just a smear.

Last edited by Bill Haywood; 01-28-2024 at 06:07 PM.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
01-28-2024 , 06:15 PM


Chilling stuff

Is it anti-semitic to be sickened by this?
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
01-28-2024 , 06:36 PM
Yes, it’s fairly anti-semetic to take QNN at face value but not the NYTimes.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
01-28-2024 , 06:44 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by gs3737
Yes, it’s fairly anti-semetic to take QNN at face value but not the NYTimes.
what about cnn?

Israel/Palestine thread Quote
01-28-2024 , 06:45 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by gs3737
Yes, it’s fairly anti-semetic to take QNN at face value but not the NYTimes.
Checked this out and CNN reported on it.

https://www.cnn.com/middleeast/live-...d945a92ad4a2ed
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
01-28-2024 , 06:47 PM
It's a different bus though. And some parts of that bus are grayed out. Picture is sus.

Kinda funny. The thing seems to be real, but that pic seems to be doctored. The license plate is erased because it's probably a bus from another country.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
01-28-2024 , 06:53 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by microbet
It's a different bus though. And some parts of that bus are grayed out. Picture is sus.

Kinda funny. The thing seems to be real, but that pic seems to be doctored. The license plate is erased because it's probably a bus from another country.
Israeli crimes require extensive documentation and affirmation. but if an employee of UNRWA posts something on a private channel that is suspect, then it is enough to justify starving thousands of people and to prove that Palestinians will do the holocaust if left unchecked.

its bullshit. I notice that you havent been back to eat crow about being wrong about the Columbia University chemical hate crime. maybe you should have learned your lesson on siding with corpus vile and the rest of these clowns over me.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
01-28-2024 , 06:55 PM
Looks like detaining Hamas members.

Zero wrong with that, legit the point of this war.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
01-28-2024 , 06:57 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Victor
Israeli crimes require extensive documentation and affirmation. but if an employee of UNRWA posts something on a private channel that is suspect, then it is enough to justify starving thousands of people and to prove that Palestinians will do the holocaust if left unchecked.

its bullshit. I notice that you havent been back to eat crow about being wrong about the Columbia University chemical hate crime. maybe you should have learned your lesson on siding with corpus vile and the rest of these clowns over me.
I didn't take anyone's side in that, I just don't blindly put my faith in reporting from you or those Twitter accounts or corpus vile or the rest of the clowns and you did just post a picture with grey swipes all over stuff that identifies that bus.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
01-28-2024 , 07:01 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by gs3737
Looks like detaining Hamas members.

Zero wrong with that, legit the point of this war.
It's really the obvious things that look the worst. Arguing about what happened in the few incidents which get talked about just distracts from that.

Stuff like this:

Quote:
Originally Posted by Tien
No the intent is to destroy as much as Gaza as possible parallel with destroying Hamas. And doing it in such a manner that still gets the money flowing from the USA to continue the destruction.






No intent? Who believes this besides Netanyahu supporters?
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
01-28-2024 , 07:08 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by microbet
I didn't take anyone's side in that, I just don't blindly put my faith in reporting from you or those Twitter accounts or corpus vile or the rest of the clowns and you did just post a picture with grey swipes all over stuff that identifies that bus.
like I said, Israeli crimes require a lot of documentation and any alternate viewpoint must be thoroughly debunked before it is accepted. you are defaulting to the people who do no research and are never correct. you are defaulting to the position that I post misinformation when all of my cites have been proven correct.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
01-28-2024 , 07:11 PM
I'm not keeping score so I don't know that that is true. And I don't default to people who don't do research. I don't expect you to have noticed how many times I've told mets that his NY Post is trash, but if you aren't going to follow posts that aren't about you, then you shouldn't generalize about them. I look up and try to verify or not stuff that people post all the time, not just stuff from you.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
01-28-2024 , 07:12 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by gs3737
Looks like detaining Hamas members.

Zero wrong with that, legit the point of this war.
microbet, why are you not pushing back on this claim that those are Hamas members? like you pushed back on the claim that the Columbia terrorists were IDF members?

we have seen many incidences where civilians were arrested and tied up like this.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
01-28-2024 , 07:16 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Victor
microbet, why are you not pushing back on this claim that those are Hamas members? like you pushed back on the claim that the Columbia terrorists were IDF members?

we have seen many incidences where civilians were arrested and tied up like this.
I've never even noticed gs3737, so I'm not really looking to get into a big conversation with him. But yeah, he has no idea who those people are. With the bus thing going on I don't even know if they are the same people in both pictures. Maybe some of them are in Ukraine.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
01-28-2024 , 07:18 PM
gs, if you dont like Quds or cnn, how about an Israeli source?

Israel/Palestine thread Quote
01-28-2024 , 07:19 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by microbet
I've never even noticed gs3737, so I'm not really looking to get into a big conversation with him. But yeah, he has no idea who those people are. With the bus thing going on I don't even know if they are the same people in both pictures. Maybe some of them are in Ukraine.
You’re arguing with someone who claims there was no rape on 10/7.

We can all just make up whatever we want apparently.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
01-28-2024 , 07:21 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by microbet
I've never even noticed gs3737, so I'm not really looking to get into a big conversation with him. But yeah, he has no idea who those people are. With the bus thing going on I don't even know if they are the same people in both pictures. Maybe some of them are in Ukraine.
ok fair enough. but they arent in Ukraine. I know that was a joke tho.

those look a lot like burial shrouds fwiw. Palestinian have been wearing them in recent days as that is the only clothing available and they are freezing. macabre if the same. well, macabre regardless.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
01-28-2024 , 07:25 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Victor
gs, if you dont like Quds or cnn, how about an Israeli source?

This isn’t proof at all. It’s (allegedly) a couple of people saying stuff.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
01-28-2024 , 07:27 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by gs3737
You’re arguing with someone who claims there was no rape on 10/7.

We can all just make up whatever we want apparently.
rape might have occurred. but not in the way the NYT reported it. and I think it was very unlikely that it was a coordinated part of the attack or a goal.

as crossnerd said, rape always occurs at war. so I am not going to disqualify that some it happened in isolated situations.

but even on that level there has been no credible evidence.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
01-28-2024 , 07:28 PM
I know the picture of all the buildings bombed isn't sensational enough to post about back and forth for people, but it really tells a much better story than this other stuff. Gaza is being annihilated. It can be seen from space.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
01-28-2024 , 07:29 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by gs3737
This isn’t proof at all. It’s (allegedly) a couple of people saying stuff.
seems pretty conclusive that powerful people in the Israeli political establishment want settlements in Gaza. theres even videos!
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
01-28-2024 , 07:33 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Victor
seems pretty conclusive that powerful people in the Israeli political establishment want settlements in Gaza. theres even videos!
A tiny group. Most don’t.

Of course since Hamas is committing genocide on the Jews, it’s totally reasonable to feel this way.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
01-28-2024 , 07:37 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by gs3737
A tiny group. Most don’t.

Of course since Hamas is committing genocide on the Jews, it’s totally reasonable to feel this way.

Hamas is not credible accused in the international court of committing genocide. Israel, however is on trial after the courts decided their action plausible constituted genocide.

facts simply dont agree with you.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
01-28-2024 , 07:40 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by gs3737
A tiny group. Most don’t.
This "tiny" group is what's in power. Not so tiny.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
01-28-2024 , 07:41 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Victor
Hamas is not credible accused in the international court of committing genocide. Israel, however is on trial after the courts decided their action plausible constituted genocide.

facts simply dont agree with you.
lol international court.

Hamas has said over and over and over again they want to wipe the Jews off the face of the earth.

That’s actual genocide, not your distorted version.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote

      
m