Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Israel/Palestine thread Israel/Palestine thread

10-09-2023 , 05:22 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Trolly McTrollson
"Jews vs Muslims" is babybrain nonsense. The Muslim world is not some unified force hellbent on destroying Israel. Also, Israel is an extremely close ally of the most powerful nation that's ever existed. You don't get to chuff about how persecuted Israel is and then handwave away the Palestinians who effectively live in a prison camp.
More mental gymnastics, and I'm trying to say that as respectfully as I can. But that's what they are.

After the atrocities of the last few days, huge portions of the Muslim world CELEBRATED. I live in a mild mannered neighbourhood here in Canada. Fireworks IN MY HOOD. Can you imagine? All over Canada, Muslims driving in the streets celebrating like the world cup was just won. Pick an Arab country, chances are they celebrated with jubilation. I'm going to a rally tonight specifically to help heal some of this, because its bonkers.

There is a HUGE part of the Muslim world that wants the end of Israel for Jews (and Jews). Antisemitic attacks the last 5 years are up almost everywhere. I don't need my opinion to demonstrate this truth, I just use the data:

https://www.pbs.org/newshour/politic...s-report-finds
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-09-2023 , 05:37 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by corpus vile
It makes more sense when you realise that victor's policy is West (especially AmeriKKKa) bad, everyone else good, forever and ever Amen. Which includes, Putin's Russia, Iran and anyone else who isn't of the Evil West.
And after the first 17 million examples of this, you'll find it a lot less fascinating, trust me on that one.
if you use this as a rubric, then you will be a lot closer to the truth than all liberals.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-09-2023 , 05:42 PM
Btw would I turn the water and power off? Power for sure yes. I'm not letting them charge cell phones or any of it. Not till it's over.

Water? That's the one I probably leave on. That said there is still just enough essential water to survive (I think their main desalination plant is still in their control). I think they would rather face a starving dehydrated enemy in the ground incursion than one that is well supplied. But collective punishment isn't legal and they won't maintain global sentiment for long with it. So let's see who blinks first I guess.

Like I said in my very first post, it's awful for the Palestinians. It's been this awful since....Hamas won and became the government, and the blockades began. Imagine a version of the world where Hamas wasn't in charge over there. That instantly improves the situation for everyone.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-09-2023 , 05:49 PM
Why/how does Israel have control over their water?
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-09-2023 , 05:57 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by PointlessWords
Why/how does Israel have control over their water?
There's a mix of sources for power and water. Israel sends most of the required capacity to Gaza. Gaza does have a power plant and one or more water plants. I know there's been huge foreign investment into their water situation. But largely given how much their population has grown, they are still very reliant on Israel for a lot (and the 2-country blockades don't help that). They'll be largely safe and supplied in the UN schools for example (the children). But that's not an option for beyond a few days. But that's where you send all the very young kids. There are almost 70 such schools. It's not nearly a good enough solution though.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-09-2023 , 05:58 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by rafiki
More mental gymnastics, and I'm trying to say that as respectfully as I can. But that's what they are.

After the atrocities of the last few days, huge portions of the Muslim world CELEBRATED. I live in a mild mannered neighbourhood here in Canada. Fireworks IN MY HOOD. Can you imagine? All over Canada, Muslims driving in the streets celebrating like the world cup was just won. Pick an Arab country, chances are they celebrated with jubilation. I'm going to a rally tonight specifically to help heal some of this, because its bonkers.

There is a HUGE part of the Muslim world that wants the end of Israel for Jews (and Jews). Antisemitic attacks the last 5 years are up almost everywhere. I don't need my opinion to demonstrate this truth, I just use the data:

https://www.pbs.org/newshour/politic...s-report-finds
Yeah no ****. thanks, I thought they only celebrate everywhere in Europe like in my city here. They celebrate like they won the soccer worldcup. yeah. and police is standing by and wonders wtf they can do and they can do nothing.

Pointless, you have no Arabs in your neighbourhood, right? Then you don't see the celebrations they are having now.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-09-2023 , 06:00 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by rafiki
Btw would I turn the water and power off? Power for sure yes. I'm not letting them charge cell phones or any of it. Not till it's over.

Water? That's the one I probably leave on. That said there is still just enough essential water to survive (I think their main desalination plant is still in their control). I think they would rather face a starving dehydrated enemy in the ground incursion than one that is well supplied. But collective punishment isn't legal and they won't maintain global sentiment for long with it. So let's see who blinks first I guess.

Like I said in my very first post, it's awful for the Palestinians. It's been this awful since....Hamas won and became the government, and the blockades began. Imagine a version of the world where Hamas wasn't in charge over there. That instantly improves the situation for everyone.
Yikes
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-09-2023 , 06:03 PM
Btw the Lebanese Hamas attacked now, or did the most attacks. Not Palestine, right? not Hezbollah, right?
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-09-2023 , 06:08 PM



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-09-2023 , 06:10 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by PointlessWords
Prob illegal if you keep those people as prisoners in occupied territory
Probably illegal for Hamas to prevent civilians/non-combatants from fleeing the area too but we all know Hamas can't allow their human shields to flee.

Anyway, they just need to unconditionally surrender because Israel isn't going to let up any more than we wouldn't have insta-leveled Tehran if they took responsibility for 9/11.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-09-2023 , 06:12 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by PointlessWords



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Could be a big bargaining chip and an opportunity to broker something next. For the next week it'll be impossible to know what's what. Maybe the next month.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-09-2023 , 06:12 PM
I wonder if the Germans turned off the water and lights in the Warsaw Ghetto
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-09-2023 , 06:17 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Victor
I wonder if the Germans turned off the water and lights in the Warsaw Ghetto
In the first two years there, 100k Jews died of starvation (25% of them), before they began to deport them to the death camps of Treblinka in 1942. By 1942, 300k of them from the ghetto had been gased to death. Only 35k remained in all.

Do you think that's what will happen here? Because if not, perhaps your choice of words here isn't super. If you think 2.4M Palestinians are about to be exterminated, we better strap our helmets on. Because that will definitely lead to WW3.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-09-2023 , 06:19 PM
I think whatever happens once the West establish Iran's involvement they need to suffer the consequences. They cannot get away with this. So the US need to send fighter jets in and bomb key strategic targets.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-09-2023 , 06:21 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by bundy5
I think whatever happens once the West establish Iran's involvement they need to suffer the consequences. They cannot get away with this. So the US need to send fighter jets in and bomb key strategic targets.
Did you see the sound bites that resurfaced from Iran recently? Basically explaining how it's not just Israel they'll destroy, but the USA and the enemies of Islam.

I'll find the new articles, they're all over. This one is a year old. But this is the stuff everyone keeps brushing aside like it's nothing!

https://www.iranintl.com/en/202211270517
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-09-2023 , 06:26 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by rafiki
In the first two years there, 100k Jews died of starvation (25% of them), before they began to deport them to the death camps of Treblinka in 1942. By 1942, 300k of them from the ghetto had been gased to death. Only 35k remained in all.

Do you think that's what will happen here? Because if not, perhaps your choice of words here isn't super. If you think 2.4M Palestinians are about to be exterminated, we better strap our helmets on. Because that will definitely lead to WW3.
Israel, our concentration camps are better than the Nazis!
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-09-2023 , 06:28 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by John21
Probably illegal for Hamas to prevent civilians/non-combatants from fleeing the area too but we all know Hamas can't allow their human shields to flee.

Anyway, they just need to unconditionally surrender because Israel isn't going to let up any more than we wouldn't have insta-leveled Tehran if they took responsibility for 9/11.
Are you saying Hamas, the illegal terrorist organization should be held to the same standard as the legal Israeli govt?
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-09-2023 , 06:32 PM
It's funny I got a threatening message from someone reading this. Which makes me sad, because largely I've done absolutely everything I can day to day to try and create as much good around me as I can. Which includes donations to both sides. But that's where we are now. Too much hate. And it's impossible to de-escalate.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-09-2023 , 06:33 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by rafiki
In the first two years there, 100k Jews died of starvation (25% of them), before they began to deport them to the death camps of Treblinka in 1942. By 1942, 300k of them from the ghetto had been gased to death. Only 35k remained in all.

Do you think that's what will happen here? Because if not, perhaps your choice of words here isn't super. If you think 2.4M Palestinians are about to be exterminated, we better strap our helmets on. Because that will definitely lead to WW3.
I'm thinking it largely depends on if their own leadership allows them to evacuate.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-09-2023 , 06:37 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by rafiki
It's funny I got a threatening message from someone reading this. Which makes me sad, because largely I've done absolutely everything I can day to day to try and create as much good around me as I can. Which includes donations to both sides. But that's where we are now. Too much hate. And it's impossible to de-escalate.
I just had a Jewish friend message me and tell me I need to condemn the actual terrorist attacks that are going on.

I guess he means that Israel doesn’t do actual terrorists attacks. I just disagree.

Hamas shouldn’t have killed all of those Israelis at the concert. So sad
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-09-2023 , 06:39 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by bundy5
I think whatever happens once the West establish Iran's involvement they need to suffer the consequences. They cannot get away with this. So the US need to send fighter jets in and bomb key strategic targets.
This is my worry. Any country with the means is pretty much going to be forced by the loudest part of their population to go after the source. Israel has a capable army but they're going to want friends. What a mess
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-09-2023 , 06:44 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by 5 south
This is my worry. Any country with the means is pretty much going to be forced by the loudest part of their population to go after the source. Israel has a capable army but they're going to want friends. What a mess
Probably won't happen under Biden. Maybe under Obama. But that is the calculated risk that Iran/Hamas took. Only 12 months more of this world mess that Biden has created all starting from that terrible withdrawal from Afghanistan.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-09-2023 , 06:48 PM
Trump will clean up this mess. Never would have happened with him at the helm
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-09-2023 , 06:49 PM
Trump gave the Russians intel which they gave to Iran which Iran gave to Hamas in order for this attack to transpire.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
10-09-2023 , 06:51 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by PointlessWords
Trump gave the Russians intel which they gave to Iran which Iran gave to Hamas in order for this attack to transpire.
No
Israel/Palestine thread Quote

      
m