Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Israel/Palestine thread Israel/Palestine thread

Today , 02:28 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by filthyvermin
my list is lame lol... i'm not super informed. but can come up with this list from just being mildly informed, and reasonably skeptical of media...

Daniel ellsburg
Julian Assange(Australian, and not technically in prison)
Chelsea Manning (not a journalist, but imprisoned for journalism)
Gary webb(not sure if he was imprisoned or just assassinated)




lol

are you disputing the stories I mentioned were false? WMD, incubator babies, and mass rape?

these stories don't require any methodology to be known as fake


maybe "remember the Maine" story too, that got USA into another war... but idk if that one was ever universally proven to be BS
He has been locked up in Belmarsh, a high security prison in the UK for the last 5 years.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
Today , 02:29 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by filthyvermin
Chelsea Manning (not a journalist, but imprisoned for journalism)
No. Imprisoned for stealing records of secret information and betraying them to a media source while employed by the US Army, in breach of the terms of said employment. Assange's case is different, as the non-US publisher of the stolen records, and the British courts have just given him leave to appeal against extradition, though I think this is on human-rights grounds related to his possible treatment by the US authorities, not on free-speech grounds. If he were extradited, his defence would rest on free-speech grounds and perhaps jurisdiction grounds (meaning the US can't claim jurisdiction over foreign citizens acting outside the US just because the US feels like it), but that's a way down the road.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
Today , 02:33 PM
It is in part because the usa have failed to give assurances that he will be protected by the right to free speech. That and the death penalty iirc
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
Today , 02:43 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dunyain
Dont know how true it is, but reports of live fire between Israel and Egypt troops at the Rafah border crossing. Looks like Egypt is working with Hamas to do whatever it takes to get Israel out of Rafah and take back control of the smuggling tunnels and weapons depots.

Israel might also be getting too close to something important Egypt doesn't want them to find; maybe a major smuggling tunnel network.
An Egyptian soldier has been killed, presumably by the Israelis, in an exchange of fire near Rafah. Egypt is allied to Israel by treaty since the 1970s. This is not going well. The weird conspiracy theory quoted above is obviously silly.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c51108le52xo
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
Today , 02:46 PM
Just what we KNOW the Egyptians were complicit to the last few years now looks really really bad. Gotta be some politicians in Israel who question is Egypt was just a really good frenemy.

I don't think the whole thing will unravel though. The status quo was easier for Egypt before.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
Today , 02:55 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by 57 On Red
No. Imprisoned for stealing records of secret information and betraying them to a media source while employed by the US Army, in breach of the terms of said employment.
bit of a thread derail, but...

I guess legally speaking, you're right, but...

have you seen the video she leaked?

I thought basically everyone agreed that it's a crime to keep that video hidden, not to release it

so releasing the video is journalism, imo... and basically everyone else's opinion too.


and even legally, i'd assume there is some sort of legal case to be made for whistle blowing, or covering up mass murder... which I'm sure was made in the trial, but that doesn't mean justice was served
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
Today , 02:59 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by chezlaw
He has been locked up in Belmarsh, a high security prison in the UK for the last 5 years.
oh really.. yeah that actually sounds familiar now that you mention it. I thought he was still hiding out in an embassy lol.... like I said, I'm pretty uniformed

thanks!

Quote:
Originally Posted by chezlaw
It is in part because the usa have failed to give assurances that he will be protected by the right to free speech. That and the death penalty iirc
I think there was some concern about torture too... not like waterboarding, but just general practice of USA prison to use solitary confinement and/or keep people isolated 23.5 hours a day, and constant fluorescent light

or whatever lol... just vaguely remember something about torture too
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
Today , 03:11 PM
The Israeli air strike on a tented refugee camp, an area they actually told Gazans to go to, has not worked out well. Intended to kill two supposed Hamas fighters, it actually and not surprisingly killed 45 people.

https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c0kkqkngnedo

EU leaders from France, Spain, Italy and Germany are all pretty fed up and would like Israel to obey the ICJ ruling and stop this kind of thing.

https://www.politico.eu/article/refu...-civilians-eu/
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
Today , 03:18 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by filthyvermin
bit of a thread derail, but...

I guess legally speaking, you're right, but...

have you seen the video she leaked?

I thought basically everyone agreed that it's a crime to keep that video hidden, not to release it

so releasing the video is journalism, imo... and basically everyone else's opinion too.


and even legally, i'd assume there is some sort of legal case to be made for whistle blowing, or covering up mass murder... which I'm sure was made in the trial, but that doesn't mean justice was served
A public-interest defence could have been made, if the leak had been more selective, but in this case it didn't succeed. The sheer volume of material betrayed, compromising US intelligence assets and diplomatic cables en masse, meant that Manning, as a serving US soldier, hadn't a prayer.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
Today , 03:59 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by 57 On Red
The Israeli air strike on a tented refugee camp, an area they actually told Gazans to go to, has not worked out well. Intended to kill two supposed Hamas fighters, it actually and not surprisingly killed 45 people.

https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c0kkqkngnedo

EU leaders from France, Spain, Italy and Germany are all pretty fed up and would like Israel to obey the ICJ ruling and stop this kind of thing.

https://www.politico.eu/article/refu...-civilians-eu/
So it’s just accepted that Hamas commanders are hiding among civilians and the only thing to do is to make Israel leave them alone.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
Today , 04:09 PM
It's getting that way.

Israel have eroded nearly all support and then there's the law.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
Today , 04:21 PM
That’s a preposterous outcome and for obvious reasons unacceptable to Israel.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
Today , 04:35 PM
The reality is that they are digging themselves into a deeper and deeper hole.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
Today , 05:25 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by grizy
So it’s just accepted that Hamas commanders are hiding among civilians and the only thing to do is to make Israel leave them alone.
I think Israel will find that if they want to send troops into these places to capture or kill Hamas commanders (or really any actual combatants) "by hand" they will not get much pushback, even if there are civilian casualties that result from this type of operation. It seems what the rest of the world is getting fed up with is the dozens of civilians killed by an airstrike that may or may not also kill the intended targets. If Israel cares at all about international opinion/support it will need to reduce the collateral damage to civilians even if that means greater casualties to their own forces. If they don't care at all about international opinion or support, carry on.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote
Today , 05:49 PM
There's a lot that can happen between "doing nothing" and an airstrike which will kill a lot of civilians.
Israel/Palestine thread Quote

      
m