Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Immigrants and Refugees being held in inhumane conditions Immigrants and Refugees being held in inhumane conditions

06-24-2019 , 07:43 PM
Undeterred Misdemeanant youth consolidation areas?
Immigrants and Refugees being held in inhumane conditions Quote
06-24-2019 , 08:19 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Trolly McTrollson
You’re literally taking the position that we shouldn’t get worked up over concentration camps and that eugenics is a great idea, I’m not sure what you expect from us here.
I wouldn't claim either of those positions for myself.

For the record I'm claiming that you should be worked up over the foster system and homeless people. Probably more so. Much more so.
Immigrants and Refugees being held in inhumane conditions Quote
06-24-2019 , 08:46 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by coordi
I wouldn't claim either of those positions for myself.

For the record I'm claiming that you should be worked up over the foster system and homeless people. Probably more so. Much more so.
Yeah man I think we should take your dad's money and buy homeless people houses idk why you think you're gonna stump leftists with this ****.

Also, p.s., no you don't? Obviously you don't. You've never posted about the ****ing foster care system until you started getting a little manic when the libtards were getting high and mighty about opposing concentration camps. You're mad at us for being mad about what is objectively a human rights abuse committed by our own government!

Quote:
If you are outraged about this then there are a few issues that involve actual US citizens getting treated in a similar fashion that you can work to improve.
Shoulda used "we" here, champ, and Jesus Christ you're so blinkered into hard right rhetoric you think we give a **** about whether or not they are citizens?

Last edited by well named; 06-24-2019 at 09:08 PM.
Immigrants and Refugees being held in inhumane conditions Quote
06-24-2019 , 08:51 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Abbaddabba
I agree it blows it out of proportion. The actual scope of the problem though does warrant action and making the comparison draws enough attention to make it a relevant issue in the news, pressuring politicians to deal with the situation to appease their electorate.
Using rhetoric like "concentration camp" limits the broad spread message that's being told, and imo is the biggest issue with the democrats when it comes to election time.


Let's say that the way the immigrants are being treated is the worst atrocity in the history of the country. Is it more useful to call them "concentration camps" (an intentionally dividing word) or to actually get videos/pictures of what is going on to be circulated? One lets actions speak, the other gets half the country to turn away and say "lol liberal exaggerators"
Immigrants and Refugees being held in inhumane conditions Quote
06-24-2019 , 08:58 PM
You know what I'm tired of all this gosh-darned political correctness where we can't call something what it is because SOME people's tender feelings might get hurt
Immigrants and Refugees being held in inhumane conditions Quote
06-24-2019 , 09:05 PM
I'm talking GTO and nothing else with my post. calling something a concentration camp (especially something that isn't) isn't going to win elections
Immigrants and Refugees being held in inhumane conditions Quote
06-24-2019 , 09:08 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by FlyWf
Yeah man I think we should take your dad's money and buy homeless people houses idk why you think you're gonna stump leftists with this ****.

Also, p.s., no you don't? Obviously you don't. You've never posted about the ****ing foster care system until you started getting a little manic when the libtards were getting high and mighty about opposing concentration camps. You're mad at us for being mad about what is objectively a human rights abuse committed by our own government!



Shoulda used "we" here, champ, and Jesus Christ you're so blinkered into hard right rhetoric you think we give a **** about whether or not they are citizens?
Good lord you are a broken record

I'm just pointing out that you have no clue what to be outraged about until someone tells you how Nazi it is, or tells you a stirring story about rubber farmers having their hands chopped off, real visceral stuff that gets the blood going.

edit: the citizen stuff was just framing how we treat our actual citizens.
Immigrants and Refugees being held in inhumane conditions Quote
06-24-2019 , 09:15 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by coordi
Good lord you are a broken record

I'm just pointing out that you have no clue what to be outraged about until someone tells you how Nazi it is, or tells you a stirring story about rubber farmers having their hands chopped off, real visceral stuff that gets the blood going.
Is there a point to any of this, or are you just gonna have a long sad because fly doesn't like you? It'd be nice to get back to talking about politics instead of this weird approval-seeking behavior.
Immigrants and Refugees being held in inhumane conditions Quote
06-24-2019 , 09:18 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by xnbomb
I'm talking GTO and nothing else with my post. calling something a concentration camp (especially something that isn't) isn't going to win elections
Calling them fun-time party pits isn't going to win elections either.

Like, we get that you don't enjoy it when we call them "concentration camps," that was sort of the whole point.
Immigrants and Refugees being held in inhumane conditions Quote
06-24-2019 , 09:20 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by juan valdez
I think his questions highlight how interested and committed people are to actually dealing with and resolving the issue vs finger pointing and outrage. You can go over to the reparations thread and see the same thing. The people there have failed to articulate any sort of plan to calculate and distribute reparations and have been asked repeatedly. I think you went the furthest and iirc it was about 3 paragraphs, the first being on point and the rest being very vague and inadequate. Thats far better than what we've seen from anyone else that claims to care but its still extremely underwhelming.

People are claiming outrage and pointing fingers. when asked what they propose as a solution they respond but with zero attempt to address the very real logistical problems. If you are going to scream about the current situation, its only logical to ask what alternative people are proposing. perhaps we could also look at the recent surge of rage on this issue and speculate on peoples secondary motives considering the actual issue itself isn't new.

i can't speak for him but perhaps hes interested in different solutions to a problem at face value. perhaps he's wondering if this is people just finger pointing and being outraged with very little interest in dealing with the logistics of a very difficult situation. so far he's had a very spirited response, none of it actually even attempt to answer any questions relating to all the very real logistical challenges. Housing a growing an unknown number of people humanely with the understanding that money isn't unlimited, is a serious issue. in my world, if you actually cared, you would be willing to think about that. everyones different though
Post #19 ITT:

Quote:
Originally Posted by FlyWf
These guys appear to have bit so hard on the "it's an Obama policy" thing that they don't realize that we could just... let them out. What's the issue there? Just not detain them at all, seeking asylum isn't a crime, just let them out, give them a court date to come back to.

You can't have voted for Daddy because he was gonna get tough on the border if as soon as you see what getting tough looks like you immediately fall apart. This is what you voted for. This is what you wanted. This is who you are.
Immigrants and Refugees being held in inhumane conditions Quote
06-24-2019 , 09:26 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by coordi
The liberal use of concentration camp certainly isn't meant to incite a rational response. Its likely the issues are being blown way out of proportion so people will be outraged about it. If you are outraged about this then there are a few issues that involve actual US citizens getting treated in a similar fashion that you can work to improve.

Most likely a few responses will try to frame me as a terrible person for even suggesting the idea.
1. Passionate people is how things get done in politics.
2. Conservatives oppose improving homelessness, the foster care system, and the conditions of asylum seekers. Why are liberals being most vocal about one of these the target of your opprobrium?
3. Which reports are exaggerated, or is that something you just wish to be true?
Immigrants and Refugees being held in inhumane conditions Quote
06-24-2019 , 09:27 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by xnbomb
Using rhetoric like "concentration camp" limits the broad spread message that's being told, and imo is the biggest issue with the democrats when it comes to election time.


Let's say that the way the immigrants are being treated is the worst atrocity in the history of the country. Is it more useful to call them "concentration camps" (an intentionally dividing word) or to actually get videos/pictures of what is going on to be circulated? One lets actions speak, the other gets half the country to turn away and say "lol liberal exaggerators"
Por que no los dos?
Immigrants and Refugees being held in inhumane conditions Quote
06-24-2019 , 09:30 PM
People are observable concentrated in camps and some other people say it’s rhetoric to call those places concentration camps. That’s called denial. They know they are concentration camps, but want to avoid having responsibility for them. The easiest and most feckless denialism available.
Immigrants and Refugees being held in inhumane conditions Quote
06-24-2019 , 09:31 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Trolly McTrollson
Is there a point to any of this, or are you just gonna have a long sad because fly doesn't like you? It'd be nice to get back to talking about politics instead of this weird approval-seeking behavior.
This is the pot calling the kettle black

Quote:
Originally Posted by spanktehbadwookie
People are observable concentrated in camps and some other people say it’s rhetoric to call those places concentration camps. That’s called denial. They know they are concentration camps, but want to avoid having responsibility for them. The easiest and most feckless denialism available.
Yeah man, no rhetoric at all. Trump concentration camps, and Nazi concentration camps. Totally comparable.

Spoiler:

Last edited by coordi; 06-24-2019 at 09:38 PM.
Immigrants and Refugees being held in inhumane conditions Quote
06-24-2019 , 09:34 PM


coordi, I don't need anyone to tell me to get mad about this ****. Everyone should be mad! It's horrific!

But if you wanted to play above it all cool guy who doesn't get mad, you had a manic fit over people calling Charles ****ing Murray racist. That made you so mad you lost the ability to read or write coherently you were so irate at how Trolly and I were doing gaslighting and dogwhistling to hurt your feelings.

You get incredibly emotional over ****ing nothing and have the gall to accuse us of being insincere and/or sheep for this ****?
Immigrants and Refugees being held in inhumane conditions Quote
06-24-2019 , 09:42 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by xnbomb
Using rhetoric like "concentration camp" limits the broad spread message that's being told, and imo is the biggest issue with the democrats when it comes to election time.


Let's say that the way the immigrants are being treated is the worst atrocity in the history of the country. Is it more useful to call them "concentration camps" (an intentionally dividing word) or to actually get videos/pictures of what is going on to be circulated? One lets actions speak, the other gets half the country to turn away and say "lol liberal exaggerators"
Who are these people who would, but for people calling the child separation prisons “concentration camps” would be ready to pull the lever for Bernie or Biden or whoever? Like, the Lapidator and JV and Kelhuses of the world aren’t ever voting for a democrat, regardless of how much Schindler’s List-esque footage from the Trump administration you play them.
Immigrants and Refugees being held in inhumane conditions Quote
06-24-2019 , 09:43 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by MrWookie
Por que no los dos?
Do you disagree that doing one of these things will probably turn away a portion of the electorate but the other doesn't?
Immigrants and Refugees being held in inhumane conditions Quote
06-24-2019 , 09:44 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by coordi
This is the pot calling the kettle black
Can we move on here? You call them party pits or whatever and I'll call them concentration camps and we can both move on and revel in the wonders of free expression.
Immigrants and Refugees being held in inhumane conditions Quote
06-24-2019 , 09:59 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Trolly McTrollson
Can we move on here? You call them party pits or whatever and I'll call them concentration camps and we can both move on and revel in the wonders of free expression.
Let me tell you how this goes. I post something, you and fly respond to me, I then respond to you guys. I'm not seeking out either of your posts. I realize neither of you like me, and that is fair. I say some brash and outright inflammatory stuff, and sometimes I might be poking or prodding (as in, maybe not fully good faith).

I personally feel like this story is deeply in line with identity politics and pitting one side against the other. I actually feel like its a really ****ty situation, but I guess people weren't mad enough about it because now we are making sure to associate the story with Nazi imagery. Maybe we are on that path and that is where my ignorance lies.

But, where does the fault lie? Is Trump going to these centers and telling them explicitly to treat people like this? Is it Republicans as a whole? Where is the systematic breakdown here. I guess I don't see a clear line of blame, so when news (that we've established elsewhere that I don't trust) wants to force the Nazi concentration camp pill down my throat, its a bit tough to swallow.
Immigrants and Refugees being held in inhumane conditions Quote
06-24-2019 , 09:59 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by xnbomb
Do you disagree that doing one of these things will probably turn away a portion of the electorate but the other doesn't?
Quote:
Originally Posted by Trolly McTrollson
Can we move on here? You call them party pits or whatever and I'll call them concentration camps and we can both move on and revel in the wonders of free expression.
We could call them tax shelters, might trick a few Republicans. “Bernie wants to double the number of tax shelters within the first month of his presidency!”
Immigrants and Refugees being held in inhumane conditions Quote
06-24-2019 , 10:14 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by coordi
I wouldn't claim either of those positions for myself.

For the record I'm claiming that you should be worked up over the foster system and homeless people. Probably more so. Much more so.
It's fine to step back as you are from the substance of the actual issue being discussed - the conditions in the detainment camps are inhumane and should be changed - and speculate about the rhetorical purpose of the language being used about the issue. And no doubt you are correct - when people refer to it as a concentration camp, they are using language that they know will provoke a strong emotional response, both positively and negatively.

However, what's good for the goose...look, your comments are not rhetorically innocent either. It is a standard demotivating move to pivot away from a relatively smaller, but fixable problem to claim we should instead focus on a much bigger and less tractable problem (like fixing foster care) - which then causes people to just give up because it's too hard and not do anything. Doesn't that seem like a worse purpose towards which to aim your rhetoric?
Immigrants and Refugees being held in inhumane conditions Quote
06-24-2019 , 10:23 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by FlyWf
You know what I'm tired of all this gosh-darned political correctness where we can't call something what it is because SOME people's tender feelings might get hurt
It's hard to take your complaints seriously when you and a few others throw 'nazi' abut so much - what do you expect when you then start talkign about concentration camps?. It ain't about you so sorry if you get tired about it. I get tired of politics wasting so much effort on name calling instead of focusing on the issues but we will cope wont we?

I agree on closing them. If not then humane conditions is an absolute minimum for all prisons/detention centres/etc
Immigrants and Refugees being held in inhumane conditions Quote
06-24-2019 , 10:27 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by xnbomb
Do you disagree that doing one of these things will probably turn away a portion of the electorate but the other doesn't?
I expect Trump voters to be upset by the notion that we shouldn't lock brown children in inhumane concentration camps regardless of what they are called. The outrage over "concentration camp" rhetoric is just trolling. Virtually anyone arguing it is just making up whatever **** is convenient to deflect from the fact that we are keeping and killing kids in horrific conditions.
Immigrants and Refugees being held in inhumane conditions Quote
06-24-2019 , 10:33 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by coordi
But, where does the fault lie? Is Trump going to these centers and telling them explicitly to treat people like this? Is it Republicans as a whole? Where is the systematic breakdown here. I guess I don't see a clear line of blame, so when news (that we've established elsewhere that I don't trust) wants to force the Nazi concentration camp pill down my throat, its a bit tough to swallow.
Leaders are responsible for their underlings. Why the **** is that some farfetched concept when it comes to torturing kids? Like, even if Trump didn't personally order the torture of each and every kid at each and every torturous instance, he has it in his authority to fire every last mother****er who was remotely complicit or complacent in it. It's his ****ing catch phrase! He has not.

Would you like to wager on how many people he fires for torturing kids? Firing people for not being tough enough doesn't count, obv. I'll spot you, say, 10 for each prosecution brought by the Trump DOJ for the abuse of these kids on top of the people actually fired.

Last edited by MrWookie; 06-24-2019 at 10:42 PM.
Immigrants and Refugees being held in inhumane conditions Quote
06-24-2019 , 10:44 PM
Would you like to wager on when Mitch McConnell brings to a vote a bill to defund ICE in its entirety to ensure that every single one of the mother****ers responsible for this is out of a job? Or even just to mandate that funding is conditional on the presence of soap and toothbrushes and hot meals and adequate beds and lights out time?
Immigrants and Refugees being held in inhumane conditions Quote

      
m