Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Does the high frequency of minorities in advertising signal racism is overblown? Does the high frequency of minorities in advertising signal racism is overblown?

11-27-2023 , 01:08 PM
Has anyone pointed out that companies might still pander to minorities without actually respecting them? There's nothing inconsistent with a racist-ass company putting minorities in their ads to make money.
Does the high frequency of minorities in advertising signal racism is overblown? Quote
11-27-2023 , 01:19 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Trolly McTrollson
Has anyone pointed out that companies might still pander to minorities without actually respecting them? There's nothing inconsistent with a racist-ass company putting minorities in their ads to make money.
All advertising is pandering.

I don't think the Mars company either respects or disrespects minority customers. Mars just wants to sell as many M&Ms and cans of dog food as possible at as high a price as possible for as long as possible.
Does the high frequency of minorities in advertising signal racism is overblown? Quote
11-27-2023 , 01:25 PM
Rap is the most popular music genre

Does that mean racism is gone?

There couldn’t possibly be any other reason for this


Consider if African American porn was the top porn category in the country, does that mean racism against black people is over?


Do you know when racism is over? When people are treated equally and equitably, the same as feminism.
Does the high frequency of minorities in advertising signal racism is overblown? Quote
11-27-2023 , 01:26 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by PointlessWords
And now look at the more likely side, systemic racism is used to get lower prices for actors and to show things perhaps as a great value or where browns can serve you. Who is available 24/7 via telephone? BROWN PEOPLE

Racism promotes sales. There are many different kinds of racism , not all of them are as blantant as “I hate X race”


Racism is defined as thinking one race is superior/inferior to others


It is not defined by a made up threshold of black/brown actors
Quote:
Originally Posted by rickroll
i disagree with this hard - but am willing to have an open mind - do you have any credible studies/essays etc that would also agree with this conclusion?
You disagree with every point , hard?
Does the high frequency of minorities in advertising signal racism is overblown? Quote
11-27-2023 , 02:34 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Rococo
Your argument doesn't even work as a theoretical exercise.

Imagine a world in which 60% of people have purple skin and 40% of people have blue skin. 1/3 of the people with purple skin (i.e., 20% of the total population) are highly prejudiced against people with blue skin. If a person with blue skin advertises a product, this 20% will completely abstain from buying the product. But the other 2/3 of purple skin people (i.e., 40% of the total population) love people with blue skin. Any time a person with blue skin advertises a product, everyone in this 40% will buy the product.

The blue skin people are even more prejudiced. If a purple skin person advertises a product, only one quarter of blue skin people (i.e., 10% of the total population) will buy the product.

And both people with purple skin and people with blue skin love products that are advertised using people of their own skin color. If a purple skin person advertises a product, all purple skin people will buy the product. Ditto for the blue skin people.

In this hypothetical absurd world, advertisers would only use blue skin people to advertise their products. And you would erroneously cite this behavior as evidence of a lack of prejudice against blue-skinned people, when in fact there is a high rate of prejudice in both groups.
so you're saying the diverse casting is to get racist minorities that don't trust whitey to bundle car and home insurance?
Does the high frequency of minorities in advertising signal racism is overblown? Quote
11-27-2023 , 02:37 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Rococo
All advertising is pandering.

I don't think the Mars company either respects or disrespects minority customers. Mars just wants to sell as many M&Ms and cans of dog food as possible at as high a price as possible for as long as possible.
are the m&ms black though?
Does the high frequency of minorities in advertising signal racism is overblown? Quote
11-27-2023 , 02:37 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by rickroll
so you're saying the diverse casting is to get racist minorities that don't trust whitey to bundle car and home insurance?
Not trusting Whitney doesn’t equate to not spending money at whiteys businesses, unfortunately.

The media and religion has done a bang up job convincing brown and black people that they need to be white. Have you see what Asian girls do to their eyes? Puhleeez
Does the high frequency of minorities in advertising signal racism is overblown? Quote
11-27-2023 , 02:38 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by PointlessWords
You disagree with every point , hard?
is this your way of confirming this is just a hunch of your own, the same person who thinks being a short male in america is the worst fate on earth?
Does the high frequency of minorities in advertising signal racism is overblown? Quote
11-27-2023 , 02:39 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by rickroll
is this your way of confirming this is just a hunch of your own, the same person who thinks being a short male in america is the worst fate on earth?

I never said anything even close to that. Please don’t make up lies


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Does the high frequency of minorities in advertising signal racism is overblown? Quote
11-27-2023 , 02:40 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by PointlessWords
Have you see what Asian girls do to their eyes? Puhleeez
didn't white people do that to them in the korean war so that more american soldiers would sleep with the prostitutes?

i feel like i read that somewhere but i'm not sure.
Does the high frequency of minorities in advertising signal racism is overblown? Quote
11-27-2023 , 03:19 PM
Tokenism is not exactly a non-racist thing, so the answer to the OP's question is no.
Does the high frequency of minorities in advertising signal racism is overblown? Quote
11-27-2023 , 03:20 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Slighted
didn't white people do that to them in the korean war so that more american soldiers would sleep with the prostitutes?

i feel like i read that somewhere but i'm not sure.


the entire asian whore/subservient sexual thing is 100% because most american "first contact" with an asian was a GI at a whorehouse in the pacific
Does the high frequency of minorities in advertising signal racism is overblown? Quote
11-27-2023 , 04:53 PM
The core problem here, and one that plagues us, is that we're treating the word 'racist' as a clearly defined technical term, when it's actually a mushy, subjective term that can refer to a wide range of things.

"Racist" is one of the worst examples of this, as it can refer to both tendencies to prejudice that I think almost every person has, and also to David Duke or Hitler and the 2 wind up conflated. And there's a lot in between or outside of that spectrum that could be called racism. I agree that adding the term 'white supremacist' to the mix only causes more confusion and conflict.

To your particular question, I think the advertising suggests that the US is not packed to the brim with vitriolic, David Duke racists. Last I saw, Obama is the most popular living president, which I think suggests that even more strongly. There could still be a relatively large number of such people. I think most whites know a couple.

Here's an example of how "racism" of one kind can exist without the other: We naturally care about things that affect us/are closest to us more. I feel bad for the people in the wars, but if Vegas was getting shelled, I would think of little else. By this mechanism, the interests of minorities take a lower priority.

The US, I think has the weakest social safety net of any wealthy country. It objectively has the highest incarceration rate of any country, by far. It's also (I think) the only rich country where the lowest class has historically been made up largely/mostly by a racial minority. It is probably not just a coincidence that we treat social ills with punishment more than assistance and that our lowest classes are mostly a minority descended from slaves.

Some whites might like this set up, as they hate blacks and want them to suffer. Others might have no particular ill will. But nobody they know will go without health care, or serve time for having a joint or a bit of cocaine on them. So it doesn't bother them that much and they don't try to improve those conditions. Or, take the easy way out and deny that these problems exist, or choose to believe that they are 100% due to poor behavior on the part of the minority. All of this might reasonably be called 'racism.'

As for Trump supporters, the fervent ones I know are mostly either mentally ill* and/or very conspiracy-oriented, and/or openly racist. These tend to be people who know little about politics outside of their devotion to Trump. I don't know why he has such a hold on them, but they certainly feel he represents their views. No other politician from either party has inspired something like QAnon. Why this is the case, is a very interesting question.

I know other people who are just normal Republicans and they tend to dislike Trump, but might vote for him rather than a Democrat.

*When I say mentally ill, I mean, like a guy who thought Trump communicated to him with coded messages in his speeches. Guys who claim to be secret agents, etc.
Does the high frequency of minorities in advertising signal racism is overblown? Quote
11-27-2023 , 05:03 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by PointlessWords
Rap is the most popular music genre

Does that mean racism is gone?

There couldn’t possibly be any other reason for this


Consider if African American porn was the top porn category in the country, does that mean racism against black people is over?


Do you know when racism is over? When people are treated equally and equitably, the same as feminism.
Whats the most popular porn category?
Does the high frequency of minorities in advertising signal racism is overblown? Quote
11-27-2023 , 05:07 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by wreckem713
Whats the most popular porn category?
MILF, and for some reason they all seem to live in my area.
Does the high frequency of minorities in advertising signal racism is overblown? Quote
11-27-2023 , 05:08 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by rickroll

so if racism was a genuine and major thing then I don't believe this would be the case
"Diversity" ads are not created for the sake of diversity. They are aiming for specific markets. If you want the black market, you hire Jake. Other ads are aimed at the white community. Some ads go after multiple audiences.

Meanwhile, racism can still be "a genuine and major thing" even though advertisers go after multiple markets.
Does the high frequency of minorities in advertising signal racism is overblown? Quote
11-27-2023 , 05:11 PM
Is Blazing Saddles racist?
Does the high frequency of minorities in advertising signal racism is overblown? Quote
11-27-2023 , 05:38 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Rococo
Your argument doesn't even work as a theoretical exercise.

Imagine a world in which 60% of people have purple skin and 40% of people have blue skin. 1/3 of the people with purple skin (i.e., 20% of the total population) are highly prejudiced against people with blue skin. If a person with blue skin advertises a product, this 20% will completely abstain from buying the product. But the other 2/3 of purple skin people (i.e., 40% of the total population) love people with blue skin. Any time a person with blue skin advertises a product, everyone in this 40% will buy the product.

The blue skin people are even more prejudiced. If a purple skin person advertises a product, only one quarter of blue skin people (i.e., 10% of the total population) will buy the product.

And both people with purple skin and people with blue skin love products that are advertised using people of their own skin color. If a purple skin person advertises a product, all purple skin people will buy the product. Ditto for the blue skin people.

In this hypothetical absurd world, advertisers would only use blue skin people to advertise their products. And you would erroneously cite this behavior as evidence of a lack of prejudice against blue-skinned people, when in fact there is a high rate of prejudice in both groups.
This.

Quote:
Originally Posted by PointlessWords
Rap is the most popular music genre

Does that mean racism is gone?

There couldn’t possibly be any other reason for this


Consider if African American porn was the top porn category in the country, does that mean racism against black people is over?


Do you know when racism is over? When people are treated equally and equitably, the same as feminism.
And this.

Now, OP isn't arguing that racism is over, but I think these posts speak to it being rather silly to think the number of minorities in advertising in any way suggests where the US is at in terms of racism. As Rococo has said in the post above and others, advertisers are targeting demographics, not trying to sell the same products/product lines to everyone with a single ad. And as PW is alluding to, the popularity in media/pop culture of a given race, gender, or any other identifiable characteristic is in no way indicative of the level of bigotry against said group.
Does the high frequency of minorities in advertising signal racism is overblown? Quote
11-27-2023 , 06:00 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Rococo
One of the underlying assumptions in the OP is that there is a huge amount of overlap between the group of people who would be uncomfortable with a black or Hispanic president, or a black or Hispanic in-law, and the group of people who would be uncomfortable buying a particular brand of dish detergent or insurance if a black or Hispanic person featured in the copany's ad campaign.

That doesn't sound intuitively correct to me at all.
Identity and all it entails including race and other demo breaks are a major factor in direct-response and targeted marketing. For instance, you just won't see many men seeing or in feminine hygiene ads. But with mass-market branding campaigns per the OP, all they're doing is entertaining you while they're repetitively tapping a thin little needle through your thick skull so that when you hear "fourteen, fourteen, fourteen, etc." and are then asked to name a vegetable you say "carrot." Like a good neighbor....
Does the high frequency of minorities in advertising signal racism is overblown? Quote
11-27-2023 , 06:04 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by rickroll
so you're saying the diverse casting is to get racist minorities that don't trust whitey to bundle car and home insurance?
My hypothetical world doesn't exist. I was using it to point out a flaw in your logic.
Does the high frequency of minorities in advertising signal racism is overblown? Quote
11-27-2023 , 06:15 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ES2
The core problem here, and one that plagues us, is that we're treating the word 'racist' as a clearly defined technical term, when it's actually a mushy, subjective term that can refer to a wide range of things.

"Racist" is one of the worst examples of this, as it can refer to both tendencies to prejudice that I think almost every person has, and also to David Duke or Hitler and the 2 wind up conflated. And there's a lot in between or outside of that spectrum that could be called racism. I agree that adding the term 'white supremacist' to the mix only causes more confusion and conflict.

To your particular question, I think the advertising suggests that the US is not packed to the brim with vitriolic, David Duke racists. Last I saw, Obama is the most popular living president, which I think suggests that even more strongly. There could still be a relatively large number of such people. I think most whites know a couple.

Here's an example of how "racism" of one kind can exist without the other: We naturally care about things that affect us/are closest to us more. I feel bad for the people in the wars, but if Vegas was getting shelled, I would think of little else. By this mechanism, the interests of minorities take a lower priority.

The US, I think has the weakest social safety net of any wealthy country. It objectively has the highest incarceration rate of any country, by far. It's also (I think) the only rich country where the lowest class has historically been made up largely/mostly by a racial minority. It is probably not just a coincidence that we treat social ills with punishment more than assistance and that our lowest classes are mostly a minority descended from slaves.

Some whites might like this set up, as they hate blacks and want them to suffer. Others might have no particular ill will. But nobody they know will go without health care, or serve time for having a joint or a bit of cocaine on them. So it doesn't bother them that much and they don't try to improve those conditions. Or, take the easy way out and deny that these problems exist, or choose to believe that they are 100% due to poor behavior on the part of the minority. All of this might reasonably be called 'racism.'

As for Trump supporters, the fervent ones I know are mostly either mentally ill* and/or very conspiracy-oriented, and/or openly racist. These tend to be people who know little about politics outside of their devotion to Trump. I don't know why he has such a hold on them, but they certainly feel he represents their views. No other politician from either party has inspired something like QAnon. Why this is the case, is a very interesting question.

I know other people who are just normal Republicans and they tend to dislike Trump, but might vote for him rather than a Democrat.

*When I say mentally ill, I mean, like a guy who thought Trump communicated to him with coded messages in his speeches. Guys who claim to be secret agents, etc.
This is a thoughtful post. I agree that answers to questions like the one rickroll posed depend quite a bit on broadly you are defining the "-ism" in question.
Does the high frequency of minorities in advertising signal racism is overblown? Quote
11-27-2023 , 06:19 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Rococo
My hypothetical world doesn't exist. I was using it to point out a flaw in your logic.
i guess the joke wasn't obvious enough
Does the high frequency of minorities in advertising signal racism is overblown? Quote
11-27-2023 , 06:23 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by rickroll
i guess the joke wasn't obvious enough
All good. I knew you were joking.
Does the high frequency of minorities in advertising signal racism is overblown? Quote
11-28-2023 , 12:01 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by wreckem713
Whats the most popular porn category?
Apparently, in 2022 it was 'ebony'. I guess that explains all the minorities in advertising. 'Transgender' coming in with a strong showing could also explain the Bud Light campaign.

https://nypost.com/2022/12/13/pornhu...2022-searches/

Does the high frequency of minorities in advertising signal racism is overblown? Quote
11-28-2023 , 01:06 AM
how does reverse cuckold work? asking for a friend
Does the high frequency of minorities in advertising signal racism is overblown? Quote

      
m