Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Covid-19 Discussion Covid-19 Discussion

07-04-2020 , 01:48 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Smudger2408
If you can prove BLM protests didn't contribute, even though the Mayor of LA said they did, I will consider it.



Always said opening doesn't mean large gatherings.
BLM protests have nothing to do with South Korea keeping their deaths under 1500 per million, a number you called inevitable in the USA.
Covid-19 Discussion Quote
07-04-2020 , 01:53 AM
Most places don't have problems.

People that are stupid and holding graduation parties, or going to massive protests, or are ready to go to baseball games are part of the problem.

Getting a haircut, is not the problem. Going to a restrurant, is not he problem.

I agree Wookie, that people doing stupid **** is the problem! Brian Kemp is not suggesting Graduation parties, or BLM protests! He is saying, get your hair cut. Wear a mask. Stay six feet away from people.

Live a life 6 feet away from other people!

I am angry that people are not acting responsibly. But, it is not the governments job to make people act responsibly.
Covid-19 Discussion Quote
07-04-2020 , 03:16 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Smudger2408
Despite BLM protests and people acting in contrary to government advice, no hospitals are yet overwhelmed.
Claiming no hospitals are overwhelmed when Houston and pretty much all of AZ hang precipitously over the edge...

Boldstrategycotton.gif
Covid-19 Discussion Quote
07-04-2020 , 03:23 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Smudger2408
He is saying, get your hair cut. Wear a mask. Stay six feet away from people.

Live a life 6 feet away from other people!
All those hairstylists with 6 foot arms.
Covid-19 Discussion Quote
07-04-2020 , 03:35 AM
Well, well, well.

Looks like the media has been lying and Trump was right after all.

Quote:
Researchers at the Henry Ford Health System in Southeast Michigan have found that early administration of the drug hydroxychloroquine makes hospitalized patients substantially less likely to die.

The study, published in the International Journal of Infectious Diseases, determined that hydroxychloroquine provided a "66% hazard ratio reduction," and hydroxychloroquine and azithromycin a 71 percent reduction, compared to neither treatment.

In-hospital mortality was 18.1 percent overall; 13.5 percent with just hydroxychloroquine, 22.4 percent with azithromycin alone, and 26.4 percent with neither drug. "Prospective trials are needed" for further review, the researchers note, even as they concluded: "In this multi-hospital assessment, when controlling for COVID-19 risk factors, treatment with hydroxychloroquine alone and in combination with azithromycin was associated with reduction in COVID-19 associated mortality."
https://www.foxnews.com/politics/hyd...onavirus-study
Covid-19 Discussion Quote
07-04-2020 , 05:26 AM
NBC left some pretty big clown shoes to fill, but Smudger appears to be doing a damn fine job stepping up to the plate as his spiritual successor.
Covid-19 Discussion Quote
07-04-2020 , 05:27 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Smudger2408
You don't think hospitals have figued out how to go above capacity?

And they aren't having problems?

LOL. You're the liar. Cases going up for sure. Hospitals are fine.

600,000 Americans are going to die of this. No one is going to die because of access to treatment.
Yes, they do it by cancelling elective surgeries/treatments and rationing access to other treatments. Its just a stone cold absolute fact that there will be incidental deaths due to some treatments being delayed or cancelled if an outlier suddenly puts a large amount of demand on health care capacity. You think capacity is so elastic that suddenly dumping numerous cases of C19 on it has no effect, that is the dumbest opinion on the internet. Also, health care professionals get sick too.

You are just outright spitting total garbage that has no basis in reality.

Last edited by O.A.F.K.1.1; 07-04-2020 at 05:33 AM.
Covid-19 Discussion Quote
07-04-2020 , 06:51 AM


July 4: 3 day moving average of COVID-19 deaths in USA is 650 per day. 7 day moving average of 537 per day.
7/03. 610
7/02 671
7/01 670
6/30 613
6/29 338
6/28 250
6/27 507

Last edited by adios; 07-04-2020 at 07:20 AM.
Covid-19 Discussion Quote
07-04-2020 , 07:11 AM
Suddenly 600 000 deaths is the number EVERYONE has been talking since the begining
Covid-19 Discussion Quote
07-04-2020 , 07:12 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mr Rick
It makes no sense for each state to be trying to determine the best way to handle this locally. They need guidance, help, resources, and expertise at a national level.
This to the nth degree.

This really akin to a war on our turf. Killing us at the same rate as a big foreign war. It absolutely requires unity to fight this battle.

Instead, we have the Federal government delegating it to 50 different people.

All chaotic. Wildly inconsistent communication. Highly political.

You have California being the sole determent of Disneyland’s fate even though that undoubtedly impacts the entire country.

This feels completely rudderless.
Covid-19 Discussion Quote
07-04-2020 , 07:18 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by weeeez
Suddenly 600 000 deaths is the number EVERYONE has been talking since the begining
Yeah this seems totally perverse. I remember upping my estimate to 250,000(since upped to 500,000) and I don't recall anyone agreeing with a quarter mill at the time. I guess it's natural to want to minimise your collective responsibility for the sake of your own conscience, and the easiest way to do that is to assert that the higher count was unavoidable and it would have been this many regardless of what was done, despite the original estimate being what, 25,000?

I suppose the counter argument will be that it was always a moving target.
Covid-19 Discussion Quote
07-04-2020 , 07:19 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by weeeez
Suddenly 600 000 deaths is the number EVERYONE has been talking since the begining
I'm old enough to remember 6 weeks ago, when Smudger's bold prediction was half that number:

Quote:
Originally Posted by Smudger2408
My whole read of the situation is that 300,000 Americans are going to die short of a vaccination. No matter what we do, how long we distance, the disease is going to spread.

The whole point of shelter/stay at home, I believed, was so that the hospital system did not get overwhelmed and everybody who needed treatment would get it. Worse case scenario, 600,000 people would have died due to lack of treatment.

It's a stark reality. But, we are passed the point of health care systems being overwhelmed. Why can't I open my office yet? Why can't I go have a drink at a bar? Why can't I go to the movies (I like 11 AM shows where there is no crowd anyway)?

I know there was good news on the vaccination front and Trump wants to use the army to distribute it really fast. But, it is not a guarantee. We haven't developed a vaccination for the common cold yet! Now, if a vaccination was developed and they give guidance it will take 8-12 weeks to distribute it, I would understand everyone staying home, but minimum time frame that the scientists are saying is early next year. What if we all stay home till early next year, and they say, OOPS, be the end of next year! And then at the end of next year, they say, OOPS, it mutates more than we thought. Sorry, no vaccination if forthcoming!

Curve has been flattened. Let's get back to work.
Should have pushed for this at the time, doubt anyone will take it now:

Quote:
Originally Posted by d2_e4
My first instinct after seeing those numbers was to offer to take the over on 800,000 by Dec 31st at evens, but then I realised that it was going to be a total head**** arguing about which sources to use, lyin' media over-counting to make daddy look bad, hopitals gettin' paid 10 gazillion per death they classify as Covid, etc. etc.
Covid-19 Discussion Quote
07-04-2020 , 07:21 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by golfnutt

This feels completely rudderless.
It is. Your president was out last night acting as if this wasn't an ongoing emergency, shouting down "radical leftists" and denouncing "cancel culture". He has moved on already, and he's counting on you to move on too. Or at least distract you enough with looming threats to your person from imagined quarters that only he can save you from. Rather than focusing on the actual threat coming from all quarters that he has been utterly useless at saving you from.
Covid-19 Discussion Quote
07-04-2020 , 07:23 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by d2_e4
I'm old enough to remember 6 weeks ago, when Smudger's bold prediction was half that number:



Should have pushed for this at the time, doubt anyone will take it now:
Nah I think your second instinct is correct here still, establishing the actual figure is going to be a total shitshow due to the reasons mentioned.
Covid-19 Discussion Quote
07-04-2020 , 07:40 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by golfnutt
This to the nth degree.

This really akin to a war on our turf. Killing us at the same rate as a big foreign war. It absolutely requires unity to fight this battle.

Instead, we have the Federal government delegating it to 50 different people.

All chaotic. Wildly inconsistent communication. Highly political.

You have California being the sole determent of Disneyland’s fate even though that undoubtedly impacts the entire country.

This feels completely rudderless.
If Disneyland was open to the public how much would the infection rate increase in your view?
Covid-19 Discussion Quote
07-04-2020 , 11:48 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by joe6pack
Well, well, well.

Looks like the media has been lying and Trump was right after all.



https://www.foxnews.com/politics/hyd...onavirus-study
A fair-minded reading of the actual study here would reveal that it's utter crap. It's not remotely a controlled trial. They aren't even controlling for a single variable! Many of the patients that recovered after having taken HCQ were ALSO given the steroid dexamethasone, a drug that has been proven to reduce deaths in more rigorous studies. It is silly to think administering both snake oil and a proven drug and then having the patient recover is proof that the snake oil is effective.
Covid-19 Discussion Quote
07-04-2020 , 11:55 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kelhus100
I am trying to have an adult conversation.
This is the guy whose adult conversation includes things like saying ToothSayer is *much* better than *any* epidemiologist.
Covid-19 Discussion Quote
07-04-2020 , 12:01 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by adios


July 4: 3 day moving average of COVID-19 deaths in USA is 650 per day. 7 day moving average of 537 per day.
7/03. 610
7/02 671
7/01 670
6/30 613
6/29 338
6/28 250
6/27 507
In which adios fails aggressively at Simpson's Paradox, despite having tried to explain it to him earlier.

Here's the 7 day rolling average of new deaths in Arizona:



And Florida:



Arizona is already at all time highs for new daily deaths. Florida may get there by the end of next week. Looking at national numbers hides the fact that deaths are blowing up in the same states where cases are blowing up, because deaths are still trending down in the states that were hit early and that are still making progress.
Covid-19 Discussion Quote
07-04-2020 , 12:08 PM
What website are those stats from?
Covid-19 Discussion Quote
07-04-2020 , 12:12 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by MrWookie
In which adios fails aggressively at Simpson's Paradox, despite having tried to explain it to him earlier.

Here's the 7 day rolling average of new deaths in Arizona:



And Florida:



Arizona is already at all time highs for new daily deaths. Florida may get there by the end of next week. Looking at national numbers hides the fact that deaths are blowing up in the same states where cases are blowing up, because deaths are still trending down in the states that were hit early and that are still making progress.
I am sure deaths will trend down in Az and Fl too when they get close to the death rates of North Eastern states. Deaths trending down from extreme highs is not an indication these states are doing anything good per se.

Do you think Az or Florida will ever catch up to the top tier of states (all NE blue states) as far as absolute death rate? I don't and if anyone thinks they will, I would be willing to set up a wager.
Covid-19 Discussion Quote
07-04-2020 , 12:48 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by adios
If Disneyland was open to the public how much would the infection rate increase in your view?

No clue. I am assume it would be worse. Much worse? Maybe. Couldn’t help.

And travelers may (will) get it at the park and bring it to their state.
Covid-19 Discussion Quote
07-04-2020 , 12:57 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kelhus100
What website are those stats from?
Raw data from covidtracking.com, 7DRA calc and figures my own.
Covid-19 Discussion Quote
07-04-2020 , 01:00 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kelhus100
I am sure deaths will trend down in Az and Fl too when they get close to the death rates of North Eastern states. Deaths trending down from extreme highs is not an indication these states are doing anything good per se.

Do you think Az or Florida will ever catch up to the top tier of states (all NE blue states) as far as absolute death rate? I don't and if anyone thinks they will, I would be willing to set up a wager.
I think wagering on deaths like this is unseemly, but is your prediction for total deaths per capita, or one instance of a day or the 7DRA of new deaths per capita?
Covid-19 Discussion Quote
07-04-2020 , 01:23 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by MrWookie
In which adios fails aggressively at Simpson's Paradox, despite having tried to explain it to him earlier.

Here's the 7 day rolling average of new deaths in Arizona:



And Florida:



Arizona is already at all time highs for new daily deaths. Florida may get there by the end of next week. Looking at national numbers hides the fact that deaths are blowing up in the same states where cases are blowing up, because deaths are still trending down in the states that were hit early and that are still making progress.
Posting data is failing, aggressively no less!!!

Last edited by adios; 07-04-2020 at 01:39 PM.
Covid-19 Discussion Quote
07-04-2020 , 01:29 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by golfnutt
No clue. I am assume it would be worse. Much worse? Maybe. Couldn’t help.

And travelers may (will) get it at the park and bring it to their state.
Thanks for the response. Good point about out of town visitors. I don’t agree with you that a one size fits all approach is the right approach.
Covid-19 Discussion Quote

      
m