Quote:
This is incoherent. I still have no idea what you mean by a "social right". Is that the same thing as a "constitutional right"?
Well its kind of that people want to argue that its against our constitution or charters of freedoms and rights to deny a trans woman access to the woman's bathroom.....
But bathroom rights aren't really enshrined or rather women don't have specific rights different than men or rather there are not gender specific rights. People, I would call them maybe neo-marxist maybe, mean to take what is otherwise social/cultural based norms and then then ascribe legal protections to them because 'trans'.
So not letting someone play a sport is not part of the constitution (like private country clubs referenced) rights but not letting them play because they are trans is.
Thats why the dog reference was important. Of course dogs don't get human rights. But the equivalent is when a dog demands to be afforded dog rights, because they claim to be a dog.
Just like saying "I get woman rights, because I identify as a woman".