Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Communism and capitalism (formerly Re: Gulags vs Mass Incarceration) Communism and capitalism (formerly Re: Gulags vs Mass Incarceration)

07-15-2021 , 01:12 PM
https://www.credit-suisse.com/about-...th-report.html

Quote:
Above them, the top tier of high net worth (HNW) individuals (i.e. USD millionaires) remains relatively small in size, but has expanded rapidly in recent years. It now numbers 56 million, or 1.1% of all adults. Adults now need more than USD 1 million to qualify for the top 1% in the global distribution
Communism and capitalism (formerly Re: Gulags vs Mass Incarceration) Quote
07-15-2021 , 02:17 PM
I was talking income. And my point was that I generate a lot more wealth for my employer, just as the fast food worker does, and thus the corporate cartels can pay much higher salaries.

Ancillary point was that taxes, health care, and rent are way too high.
Communism and capitalism (formerly Re: Gulags vs Mass Incarceration) Quote
07-15-2021 , 06:57 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Victor
Castro visited Harlem in the 60s btw and it really pissed off ppl like you.
Too bad he didn’t pick up on the ‘freedom to vote the way you want’ vibe.
Communism and capitalism (formerly Re: Gulags vs Mass Incarceration) Quote
07-15-2021 , 07:30 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by PokerPlayingGamble
That is really the inherent problem with the state. When the government takes your money and then spends it ostensibly on your behalf, there is a massive loss in utility vs when you spend it on yourself. When you spend your own money on yourself, it goes to your most highly valued ends and achieves the greatest utility. But when a government bureaucrat spends your money on you, they are fully unaware of your value scale, and ambivalent to it as well. So the money goes to whatever is politically expedient, which is no doubt very far down on your value scale. You would rather spend the money on your mortgage, or groceries, or a video game or whatever, instead of blowing up poor people in the third world or padding the pockets of some special interest group.
You seem to speak as if poor people or low middle class are paying lot of tax…..

It’s rather the contrary.
They benefit from tax since they pay lower than what they receive in exchange .
The rich shouldn’t care anymore about tax for the last 20 years .
They get bail out by the fed every time .
That is why they pay tax for mainly anymore …

It’s kinda hilarious you still think tax are a problem when they are at the lowest since before ww2 (corporate and high income ) and you got crazy bubble in the financial market never sen before !

What you think it’s a bubble if it’s not too much allocated capital in an asset ?
You really thing tax matter anymore with so many gigantic bubble in financial assets while the lack of capital in the real economy is killing it little by little ?

Your discourse is as out of dated as much as the Old Testament …

Last edited by Montrealcorp; 07-15-2021 at 07:42 PM.
Communism and capitalism (formerly Re: Gulags vs Mass Incarceration) Quote
07-15-2021 , 07:33 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by lagtight
I thought that the bolded was the reason why inflation was the worse tax. I thought the idea is to lessen the tax burden on the poor. By that standard, how is inflation the "best tax."?

Thanks.
Because the rich can side step the government tax but not inflation.
Instead of fighting inflation , government should help those that inflation hurts the most and do nothing for those that even with high inflation , they aren’t affected by it much .

Hence UBI seem great for that and keep free market alive by not imposing minimum wages .
Communism and capitalism (formerly Re: Gulags vs Mass Incarceration) Quote
07-15-2021 , 07:35 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ment52
It's only a problem if you are governed by psychotic dictators or in your case, plutocrats.

In Northern Europe people get how important strong unions / paying living wage, extensive social programs etc are. Happy productive intelligent workforce eventually leads to greater wealth and a safe environment. Couldn't imagine having to sleep with a gun under my pillow and driving through massive ghettos, no damn video game is going to make up for that.

And apparently no freedom is being infringed on, the USA is way behind of both civil liberties https://freedomhouse.org/countries/f...20and%20Status and economical https://www.heritage.org/index/ranking of even us, who were annexed by a murderous regime for half a century.
+1
Communism and capitalism (formerly Re: Gulags vs Mass Incarceration) Quote
07-17-2021 , 04:12 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Victor
I am in the top 1% of the world overall. But I don't have a lot left over after taxes, rent, and health care. I provide specialized work for a 40B company that millions of ppl use a day.

Over the last five years profits have risen approx 2.5x. (not including stock price which has risen too but I'm not sure exactly how much). My salary has not gone up 2.5x lol.

My skillset may be more specialized and more challenging than a mcd or Walgreens worker bit it's not more important. Nor is it all that much more profitable to the company. None of us make what we deserve.
Are you miserable?
Communism and capitalism (formerly Re: Gulags vs Mass Incarceration) Quote
07-17-2021 , 09:46 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by lagtight
Are you miserable?
For communists it’s a requirement to be miserable.
Communism and capitalism (formerly Re: Gulags vs Mass Incarceration) Quote
07-17-2021 , 12:58 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by lagtight
Are you miserable?
I understand that you are on the spectrum and dont understand themes and conveyance.

To be explicit, I am not miserable (well sometimes but arent we all) but I am a few months away from it if I lost my job or something catastrophic happened and I am comparatively very well compensated.

so while I am in the 1% or 5% or whatever, you can be sure that much of the world is struggling.

and that is by design. bc capitalism destroys wealth and resources and creates an subsistence underclass to be exploited so that a few at the top can amass insane fortunes.

you should be against that. but you have been indoctrinated since birth and are now set in your ways. and tbf, it took me awhile to change.
Communism and capitalism (formerly Re: Gulags vs Mass Incarceration) Quote
07-17-2021 , 04:37 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Victor
I understand that you are on the spectrum and dont understand themes and conveyance.

To be explicit, I am not miserable (well sometimes but arent we all) but I am a few months away from it if I lost my job or something catastrophic happened and I am comparatively very well compensated.

so while I am in the 1% or 5% or whatever, you can be sure that much of the world is struggling.

and that is by design. bc capitalism destroys wealth and resources and creates an subsistence underclass to be exploited so that a few at the top can amass insane fortunes.

you should be against that. but you have been indoctrinated since birth and are now set in your ways. and tbf, it took me awhile to change.
Imo there is different degrees of capitalism like there is degrees in socialism economy …..

Capitalism is still the best foundation yet human as found to exchange goods and prosper .
The problem of capitalism today is that isn’t capitalism anymore or in another word , it’s cronyism capitalism .

Any extremes in any field are bad , regardless if it is communism , capitalism , socialism , etc .

At its base capitalism is great , just need a bit of framing to make sure capitalism isn’t just profitable for just a few but for the majority of people .
Communism and capitalism (formerly Re: Gulags vs Mass Incarceration) Quote
07-17-2021 , 05:55 PM
Crony capitalism is capitalism. The pursuit of profit and accumulation of wealth will always create this situation.
Communism and capitalism (formerly Re: Gulags vs Mass Incarceration) Quote
07-17-2021 , 06:44 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Victor
Crony capitalism is capitalism. The pursuit of profit and accumulation of wealth will always create this situation.
No !
Like I do not call socialism-> communism like republicans love to do …
Communism and capitalism (formerly Re: Gulags vs Mass Incarceration) Quote
07-17-2021 , 08:07 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Victor
I understand that you are on the spectrum and dont understand themes and conveyance.

To be explicit, I am not miserable (well sometimes but arent we all) but I am a few months away from it if I lost my job or something catastrophic happened and I am comparatively very well compensated.

so while I am in the 1% or 5% or whatever, you can be sure that much of the world is struggling.

and that is by design. bc capitalism destroys wealth and resources and creates an subsistence underclass to be exploited so that a few at the top can amass insane fortunes.

you should be against that. but you have been indoctrinated since birth and are now set in your ways. and tbf, it took me awhile to change.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plantation_Covenant
Quote:
The Plantation Covenant of Guilford, Connecticut, sometimes called the Guilford Covenant, was a covenant signed by the English colonists as the founding document of Quinnipiac (modern New Haven) on 1 June 1639. The covenant stated:
We whose names are herein written, intending by God's gracious permission, to plant ourselves in New England, and if it may be in the southerly part, about Quinpisac [Quinnipiac], we do faithfully promise each for ourselves and families and those that belong to us, that we will, the Lord assisting us, sit down and join ourselves together in one entire plantation and to be helpful to the other in any common work, according to every man's ability and as need shall require, and we promise not to desert or leave each other on the plantation but with the consent of the rest, or the greater part of the company, who have entered into this engagement.
As for our gathering together into a church way and the choice officers and members to be joined together in that way, we do refer ourselves until such time as it shall please God to settle us in our plantation.
In witness whereof we subscribe our hands, this first day of June 1639
My hunch is Lagtight is probably fine with that sort of communism but stops short of putting guns to heads to get people to care and share more.
Communism and capitalism (formerly Re: Gulags vs Mass Incarceration) Quote
07-18-2021 , 01:59 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Montrealcorp
Imo there is different degrees of capitalism like there is degrees in socialism economy …..

Capitalism is still the best foundation yet human as found to exchange goods and prosper .
The problem of capitalism today is that isn’t capitalism anymore or in another word , it’s cronyism capitalism .

Any extremes in any field are bad , regardless if it is communism , capitalism , socialism , etc .

At its base capitalism is great , just need a bit of framing to make sure capitalism isn’t just profitable for just a few but for the majority of people .
Well said!
Communism and capitalism (formerly Re: Gulags vs Mass Incarceration) Quote
07-18-2021 , 02:02 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by John21
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plantation_Covenant


My hunch is Lagtight is probably fine with that sort of communism but stops short of putting guns to heads to get people to care and share more.
Your hunch is quite correct. I would prefer to call the Plantation Covenant communalism instead of communism, since communalism is voluntary, while communism is not.
Communism and capitalism (formerly Re: Gulags vs Mass Incarceration) Quote
07-18-2021 , 04:42 AM
Quote:
You seem to speak as if poor people or low middle class are paying lot of tax…..

It’s rather the contrary.
They benefit from tax since they pay lower than what they receive in exchange .
The rich shouldn’t care anymore about tax for the last 20 years .
so everyone wins?




clearly everyone does not win, since to pay A we must rob B, but also because there is a substantial transaction cost to fund the bureaucracy that robs B to pay A. Instead, you have different classes, net tax payers, and net tax consumers. The whole point of the state is that some can live parasitically off others, because creating wealth is hard and it is much easier to simply steal what someone else has created.

A fun fact, the origin of the class war theory was not Marxoid in nature. Actually, the theory was first put forth by two French libertarian theorists, Charles Compte and Charles Dunyoer. They correctly identified that it is not the rich vs poor, but rather those who benefit from state largess vs those who are forced to bear the cost.
Communism and capitalism (formerly Re: Gulags vs Mass Incarceration) Quote
07-18-2021 , 05:57 AM
We are talking about economics right ?
What productive is it to the economy to have all time high in bonds, stocks and real estate ?
What does that bring positively to the bottom 70% of the population ?

And like I said ….
How can you say the rich loses money by paying tax when those tax are used to bail them out on Wall Street ?
Are you serious ?

Who you think profits the most for the protection of the US military for his foreign and domestic assets ?
The poor guy at 8$ an hour owning nothing ?

But one of the reason mathematically it’s working with higher tax for the rich to help the most needed it’s because money is not a linear value .
It changes , by a lot .
It got massive diminishing return .

1$ for an homeless is incredibly more valuable to him than to a billionaire, even tho it’s the same dollar .

It ain’t about pure nominal value in economics .

Tax ain’t stealing from the rich .
Tax bring a better , more balance and SAFE society for those that are privilege .
It is in their best interest to have a peaceful society .
That too has value, safety isn’t a free entitlement, it cost money to provide -> tax !

Paying tax to provide a society to maximize equal opportunity to succeed for everyone , to a certain degree of course, is massively ev for a society and it’s economy .
Communism and capitalism (formerly Re: Gulags vs Mass Incarceration) Quote
08-19-2021 , 02:34 PM
Communism and capitalism (formerly Re: Gulags vs Mass Incarceration) Quote
08-19-2021 , 05:10 PM
PokerGamble,

Does your profession, coaching poker players to win money playing poker, fall in the ‘wealth creation’ category or the ‘parasite’ category? It’s a very interesting profession to choose for someone with your views. You’re the bureaucracy in your understanding of the world, you’re the money lost in the transfer between the rec and the pro.

Last edited by phoneaccount; 08-19-2021 at 05:15 PM.
Communism and capitalism (formerly Re: Gulags vs Mass Incarceration) Quote
08-19-2021 , 06:29 PM
Oh good. Another taxation is theft zealot. This always ends well.
Communism and capitalism (formerly Re: Gulags vs Mass Incarceration) Quote
08-19-2021 , 07:04 PM
I got my motor vehicle excise tax bill today so I may be more open to persuasion than usual
Communism and capitalism (formerly Re: Gulags vs Mass Incarceration) Quote

      
m