Quote:
Originally Posted by Cuepee
This would force everything to the SC and Trump would have claimed to be the one in Power until resolved.
I cannot, for the life of me, figure out what would happen at that point. Trump would be proclaiming 'The VP has not completed the process and Biden is not sworn in. By our Constitution we do not yet have a new POTUS. I am still POTUS'.
Would the Secret Service, Military, Police, others take an order from Biden anyway to remove Trump if he said 'I am POTUS until the SC says otherwise?' Could they act on authority technically Biden was not vested with because we all believed he 'deserved' it and 'would' get it eventually?
It would have been a mess. Surely dem voters and Trump haters would hit the streets and some anarchy would ensue and Trump would want just that. He would then command the most vicious response he could hoping to polarize his side to him, to over look his election antics (for those on the fence) and just approve him crushing Dem 'rioters'.
If a sane president had been in office, then the January 6 riots would have been no threat at all to the U.S. government, aside from the physical threat to the people in the building, even if the rioters had succeeded in disrupting Congress's confirmation of Biden's election. In other words, if a bunch of conspiracy derpers had stormed the Capitol while Mitt Romney or John McCain had been in office, it would have been big news, of course, but not a big threat to the U.S. government.
Trump's plan was more or less what Cuepee is suggesting. He wanted to get a huge number of derpers in Washington on January 6 because he thought it would put pressure on Pence to precipitate a Constitutional crisis. Only Trump knows exactly how far he wanted those derpers to go on that day. This effort was misguided for three reasons. First, Pence never seriously considered doing what Trump wanted him to do. He made a show of considering his options, but that's as far as it went imo. He had no intention of going down in history as "that guy". Second, Trump had no chance of prevailing in the SCOTUS. The reasoning would have been wonky because the system isn't designed to address what Trump was trying to do, but I'm extremely confident that the SCOTUS decision would have gone against Trump, probably in a 9-0 opinion. Third, in the face of an adverse SCOTUS opinion, Trump's only option for staying in power would have been to do so by force. That would have required the support of the military, FBI, etc., which Trump did not have.
By no means am I downplaying what Trump did. Any time you have a president who is actively attempting to precipitate a constitutional crisis, it's a three-alarm fire. And as many on this forum have noted, if Trump hadn't been so ham-handed and hadn't been such a fool, the threat would have been even more significant.