I'm new to the forum. I would be inclined to lurk a little more and post in other threads before starting a new thread myself, but I need an answer to this question.
Here's the hand history from a hand I played tonight on Bodog:
Code:
Please note: You can only view your own down cards. Other players will only see your cards if they were played through to showdown.
« Prev Hand | Next Hand »
Hand Number 1577561718
Start Date 2009-04-10 23:33:14
End Date 2009-04-10 23:34:49
Pot Size $51.00
Rake $2.00
Game Type Hold'Em
Play Mode Real
Table Name Warwick Hills
Structure NL
Table Stakes Min Bet Max Bet Ante Blinds
$0.50 $0.25 $0.50
Community Cards 2h 8s Ad 4c 5d
Player Information
Screen
Name Seat
Position Cards
Dealt Start/End
Amount Total
Bet Win/Loss
Amount
PlayerX 1 Ah 6d $46.75/$21.00 $25.75 $-25.75
SillyRabbit 2 $58.55/$58.55 $0.00 $0.00
juguete 3 $64.80/$64.80 $0.00 $0.00
2Hi 5 $70.40/$70.40 $0.00 $0.00
Me 6 2d 2c $39.95/$65.20 $25.75 $25.25
brewhasurf 7 $34.40/$34.40 $0.00 $0.00
youngb4life 8 $12.40/$10.90 $1.50 $-1.50
Hand Actions
Player Action Action Data Timestamp
brewhasurf Set dealer/Bring in spot 7 23:33:14
youngb4life Ante/Small blind $ 0.25 23:33:14
PlayerX Big blind/Bring in $ 0.50 23:33:14
PlayerX Card dealt to a spot A 6 23:33:14
SillyRabbit Card dealt to a spot 23:33:14
juguete Card dealt to a spot 23:33:14
2Hi Card dealt to a spot 23:33:14
Me Card dealt to a spot 2 2 23:33:14
brewhasurf Card dealt to a spot 23:33:14
youngb4life Card dealt to a spot 23:33:14
SillyRabbit Fold $ 0.00 23:33:17
juguete Fold $ 0.00 23:33:20
2Hi Fold $ 0.00 23:33:20
Me Raise $ 1.50 23:33:24
brewhasurf Fold $ 0.00 23:33:32
youngb4life Call $ 1.25 23:33:34
PlayerX Call $ 1.00 23:33:39
Betting round completed Last active pot = $4.50 23:33:39
Card dealt to table 2 8 A 23:33:39
youngb4life Check 23:33:41
PlayerX Check 23:33:45
youngb4life Sit out next hand 23:33:47
Me Bet $ 3.75 23:33:55
youngb4life Fold $ 0.00 23:33:56
PlayerX Call $ 3.75 23:34:00
Betting round completed Last active pot = $12.00 23:34:00
Card dealt to table 4 23:34:00
youngb4life Stand up 8 23:34:02
youngb4life Stand up true 23:34:02
PlayerX Check 23:34:10
Me Bet $ 8.50 23:34:24
PlayerX Call $ 8.50 23:34:29
Betting round completed Last active pot = $29.00 23:34:29
Card dealt to table 5 23:34:29
PlayerX Check 23:34:35
Me Bet $ 12.00 23:34:46
PlayerX Call $ 12.00 23:34:49
Rake amount $ 2.00 23:34:49
Betting round completed Last active pot = $51.00 23:34:49
Me Showdown Show card: Three of a Kind
2 2 2 A 8 23:34:49
PlayerX Showdown Muck card 23:34:49
Me Hand result $ 51.00 23:34:49
I changed my screenname to 'Me' and the screenname of the other player to 'PlayerX' and left the rest of the hand history as is.
My question is: If PlayerX mucked, why can I see his hole cards in my hand history?
While we were playing, I never saw his cards. They were mucked. I went back and asked PlayerX in the chatbox whether he had showed. He said he had not.
I'm aware that in a brick and mortar casino I can technically require him to show his cards even though he acted behind me... Although this just isn't done regularly (and shouldn't be), I've seen it done on a couple occasions and the floor manager was called over, yada yada yada, and the player was required to show. (And the player who asked to see the cards was told that repeated requests from him would not be accepted).
Last edited by TBOPACY; 04-11-2009 at 12:53 AM.
