Quote:
Originally Posted by MiXeR
Not really but thank you anyway. First of all I dont know why anger, arogance, sarcasm, cynicism and all that acting of God in your reply but that is something you should solve on your own (or not, your choice sure, just please dont drag me in to your personal problems and lets all try to stick to the theme or just please ignore my post(s) and skip it).
Thanks other guys for kind replys as well, but must say Im not asking so much about theory and math in here. Im quite familiar with it and I understand general principles of it. Im aware of that IT IS mathematical (and tho in "practice" as well) possible that I throw a head of a coin billion times in a row at a huuuu...uuuge sample, therefor this to happen in my life time is veeeee...eery unlikely, so yes, I know Im not entitled to actually anything.
I would just like to get some opinions, "practical thoughts" from winning poker players - experts (like they are any other yeah:P based on their experiences and knowledge, not so much theoretical "by the book" explanations. And I would like to say, Im not trying to suggest or judge anything, Im just curious:
- is 500K hands "downswing" so common that every "average" winning poker player should expect "one" now and there in his poker career?
- if yes, than is it possible (but sure not necesary) that (at least) live cash game players like Ivey, Doyle, Ungar, Harman, are just huge luckers?
- furthermore is it, or how common it is that "2 tables" (<- playing aprox. 1K hands per day) winning online holdem players will struggle with such a "unhappy" stretch almost 3 years (a bit more or less, depending on their level of skill sure)?
- if so much luck is really involved in this game is it worth to play it (beatable?) unless you grind 150K hands per month?
Thank you!
Mixer, I play for a living and post here sometimes. I don't get as annoyed as some other posters here probably because I post far less frequently and thus don't have to deal with much of the nonsense that they try valiantly to clear up over and over again.
My answers to your questions. Without any math--if you are seeing such a downswing, then it is possible. Not necessarily likely, but possible and likely means nothing. Why? Because there are a ton of players out there playing a ton of hands, and some of these players will experience this and sad as this may seem to you, you are apparently one of them. That's it.
Is it possible that some or many of the successful live players, especially tourney players (greater swings) are huge luckballs? Yes. Period. I've heard it said that it is possible that a lifetime is not enough to be sure what the actual ev is of a live MTT player. Too much variance, not enough hands. Maybe some of the greats were just on the good side of a huge variance swing. How to tell? One way is to look at cash game results for the same player and online results if they play there as well. Also read what they've written, if anything, on strategy or anything poker related and make your own judgement.
Practical advice? If you're running this badly, variance is NOT the only explanation. The games are tougher and you have to improve steadily just to keep up. Having been a winner 5 years ago says nothing about whether you are one today (or very little). I had a good friend who was better than I was 5 or 6 years ago who went from a 120k winner one year, to 65k the next to breakeven to minus 70k. He then quit. Never complained about rigging or luck, but simply admitted the game was too tough for him because he wasn't willing to put in the work to keep up or keep ahead. And that is what it is, HARD WORK. I work on my game nearly every single day. My strategies and tactics have evolved enough so that I am in many ways a very different player than I was three years ago and wildly different than at any time further back.
Get away from this thread; find a home in an appropriate strategy thread and discuss hands there; listen to players who have results you would like to emulate (not losers whining or complaining of rigs, luck, bad beats, etc.); watch videos from established winners at your game; and determine whether you can still beat the game. If not, quit or do it as a pastime; if yes, get on with it.
To your last question. It's unanswerable as it stands. Which game/s? What buyins/stakes? How good are you truly relative to the game today? How much do you need to make monthly to get by/be happy (depending on where you live/family status/etc.)? And so on. The real question is: Are you willing and able to do the HARD WORK it takes to be a truly successful poker player and are you psychologically able to handle the swings that are a part of it. This thread is full of people who cannot answer yes to both questions and seeing a rig is their way of dealing with that.
That's it. Practical and no anger or sarcasm. Can you do the above? If yes, you'll do fine. If no, I expect to see you trolling youtube poker videos in the near future claiming it's all rigged.