Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
The great "Poker is rigged" debate - Collected threads edition The great "Poker is rigged" debate - Collected threads edition
View Poll Results: Is Online Poker Rigged?
Yes
3,502 34.89%
No
5,607 55.86%
Undecided
929 9.25%

04-16-2011 , 06:31 PM
I find it humorous that you can't seem to distinguish between the randomness of a manual deal performed right before your eyes and a computer-generated deal created on a computer server half a world away.

Sure, I've heard many boors belittling a dealer in the casino for "screwing" them when they suffered a bad beat for a pot they considered to be their God-given right to claim for themselves. I've seen it in blackjack, poker, and any of the various carnival games offered in the casino. Such behavior is childish, ridiculous, and without a basis in arguable fact. Their contention of a "rigged" game is ridiculous.
However, there is a big difference between cards dealt out of a shoe or randomly shuffled deck and those given to you by a computer that serves to generate a profit for its operator. I find it very telling that over a third of the responses to the survey presented at the beginning of this thread consider online poker to indeed be "manipulated", at the very least. Sometimes perception is reality, my friend, and if you deny that universal truth then we have nothing else to discuss.
The very fact that more than 1/3 of the players surveyed on an online poker forum consider it to be a very real possibility that the online game might be manipulated is BAD for the game!
Why do you suppose that the average $2-$5 player in casinos plays for stakes of 25 or 50 cents online? I know. I know. We've all heard it 100,000 times. More hands are dealt per hour than in the live game. However, a player who considers himself to be an "advantage" player in brick and mortar casinos due to the fact that he is a winner over time at those stakes should likewise be an even greater advantage if he can now see more hands per hour.....shouldn't he? I know. I know. Again we've all heard it before that the reason he must play for the smaller stakes is that the level of play is much higher at similar stakes online. Again, why would that be so????
It appears to be self evident to me that the average>>>>winning<<<<brick and mortar player feels that he is disadvantaged online due to the fact that he is playing not only his cards, position, stack size, and opponent in the online game, but that he must add the fifth dimension of playing against the site to his decisions in online play.
As far as the "racism" of being mistrustful of the legitimacy of a game dealt by a server from an unregulated offshore site to a player in the United States........I guess I must plead guilty as charged. I'm not sure which "race" I am prejudiced against so much as the "prejudice" of mistrusting the integrity of an unregulated game.
The great &quot;Poker is rigged&quot; debate - Collected threads edition Quote
04-16-2011 , 06:40 PM
I just want to see how much longer this thread lasts. I always thought it was mostly American players making the stupid claims. I wonder if the complaints will keep coming (now that the major 3 are down in the US).
The great &quot;Poker is rigged&quot; debate - Collected threads edition Quote
04-16-2011 , 06:45 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by BustaHimesCLH
The government are the first to break the law...
Either way they want tax on our funds that's fine there should be no way they could just steal the funds we have on the site.

As for you I'd punch you square in the jaw if I ever met you
You did business with an illegal organization. If you played in an illegal underground card room that money isn't yours. It's seized if there is a raid. As for punching me hey I am 6 foot 2 and 240. Not fat either. Give it your best shot pal.
The great &quot;Poker is rigged&quot; debate - Collected threads edition Quote
04-16-2011 , 06:56 PM
I'm 6'1, 210 and am overweight... U must be sick buff to have 1 inch but 30lbs on me.
Whatever makes you feel better kid.

@Stu+stu: This site is made up of mostly Americans, of course they would be the majority.
Go to a french forum and you fill find people saying their (regulated 100% legal) poker sites are rigged..

Better yet, go to a casino. You will hear the same thing. BJ machine shufflers, video poker, slots, ect.. They are all rigged according to the masses..
The great &quot;Poker is rigged&quot; debate - Collected threads edition Quote
04-16-2011 , 06:56 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by banonlinepoker
Yep everything that has happened last 24 hours is all a joke.



Doesn't matter where you live, you did business with a site that was blatantly breaking the law of another country and was totally open to having all assets frozen and owners thrown in jail.

Actually I don't do freerolls. Waste of time. I have a $10 avg buy in on FTP. As for live I do decent. An play actively but you can go on blaming and degrading people that don't share your vision of a world were laws are to be ignored and lashing out when your money is frozen and ultimately taken from you. I can't help the fact you cheated the US out of tax revenue and made criminals rich and now is acting like a 18 year old high school girl that got felt up at the movies. I kind of feel bad for you guys now that have to go to the local mall and sell American Eagle clothes or sunglasses because your internet moves won't have a snowballs chance in hell at a live table and your uber aggressive moves are met with over the top raises from live players that can read you like the morning newspaper. Best of luck.
Do you even understand what a hypocrite you are? Not quite sure how I degraded you,other than to point out you sound,and write as if your education ended around the time you were fitted for long pants. But you go on to say that anyone who actually wins at poker isn't qualified for anything but a job at their local mall. Having a high i.q. is a trait common to successful people, and certainly all but compulsory in the online poker world. You go on figuratively dancing on peoples graves if it makes you happy,i'm done with your nonsense,and sorry I ever responded to it.
The great &quot;Poker is rigged&quot; debate - Collected threads edition Quote
04-16-2011 , 07:04 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by NFuego20
Seriously?

What about UIGEA did you not understand? This is a fairly simple case of our country trying to force legislation on other parts of the world who don't subscribe to our laws. The internet creates all kinds of jurisdictional issues that didn't exist in the past. Naturally the DOJ was going after all payment processors facilitating the moving money to and from the sites, and the sites had a choice to either pull out or work around that. Regardless of some of the specifics, it was hardly a big secret that there's been a cat and mouse game going on for a long time. And it will continue.

Of course the USA is saying they broke the law. In their eyes they did. The WTO says the USA violated trade agreements by passing UIGEA, so the very laws being used to prosecute poker sites are illegal in their eyes. At a minimum, it's an incredibly complicated situation. But as usual, everybody wants to look at it as black and white, one side or the other. Try and have some appreciation for the complexity of the situation. If you didn't realize all this stuff was going on going in, and that these kinds of risks were out there the whole time, and that poker sites have been struggling to pay their customers for years due to DOJ efforts, you've been living under a rock.
More smoke and mirrors from you and the others.

Bottom line, there is plenty more reason to believe that more illegal activity has been going on at Stars and FT. They knew that they were breaking U.S. law and still did it anyway. To be fair, we all took part in this and understood the risks. This is not my point though, my point is that we can and should be more suspicious than ever. That is all I am saying.

I sincerely feel for the players who got caught up in this. I was sitting next to a guy at the Palomar Club playing NL cash game today who has almost $400k stuck on the sites. Another player had $65k stuck and couldn't pay his taxes on time. The DOJ and our government do have some real douche bags who been given too much power. There are also some good people trying to help turn things around. Things do need to change in this country and fast, but that has nothing to do with how the sites decided to deal with a problem. Now we have caught more of a glimpse of the possibilities.
The great &quot;Poker is rigged&quot; debate - Collected threads edition Quote
04-16-2011 , 07:06 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by banonlinepoker
I will spare the forum the gloating as I bask in the afterglow of the day that I knew was coming. In fact anyone who kept any money in these sites after last November when FTP couldn't get their money after deposits where made should not be upset they lost their money. That was the biggest red flag and just screamed US GOVT GOT YOU!

Now you can still blame the US, blame government etc but the true fact of the matter is that a law was passed and whether you liked it or not you sure as hell should have respected it. Did you? Of course not, you listened to Howard Lederer and the PPA and ran around with some sense of entitlement and some diluded fantasy that poker is all skill and is legal. I will steal a stupid word from nfuego WRONG!

Poker is not all skill, it's gambling. Instead of going after congress heavy you put all your eggs in a basked with the PPA and Annie Duke. Well where did that get you? Now we have our resident tax dodgers and people who knowingly broke the law blaming everyone but where the blame lies. YOURSELVES. I have no sympathy for you, the Indians in Canada or anyone that participated in this, and no Monteroy I am not a bigot or racist for thinking so. I am the son of an immigrant who loves the fact he took a boat here and immigrated here LEGALLY. He did so because he wanted to live in the best country in the world. This country has laws. Some you like, some you don't but we have a system and it works and it's the best in the world. In a few months time we will be able to play online poker in the US. Legally and safely. The route we had to take to get there wasn't the quickest and this is due to many factors one of which the sad path this country has taken with electing Barack Obama and now finding itself in an ideologic war that will take two more years to play out. This has facilatated a battle for a budget and a debt ceiling debate that will take all of congress' time till at least fall. Which will delay a debate on a bill this country needs to creat jobs, tax revenue and let us all enjoy a game that is fair, regulated and honest. I look forward to that day, may it soon come.
wrong
The great &quot;Poker is rigged&quot; debate - Collected threads edition Quote
04-16-2011 , 07:07 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by banonlinepoker
So let me get this straight. You are mad because you broke the law, got caught and can't get your money so it's my fault? Come on already stop being diluded into this "We are not doing anything wrong!" propaganda. The second you deposited money to play poker over the internet you broke the law. Same as I do when I play underground in a state where poker is illegal. Now can the state arrest everyone? Of course not, logic and budget dictate otherwise. They do a token bust periodically where the owner gets popped, fined and maybe a short sentence and everyone playing at the time loses their money. Now I can thump my chest and say it's my right to play but in reality it's against the law! Until the state passes a law saying it's legal nothing changes because some guy with man boobs and the PPA tell you different. Now if you can look at things from a logical perspective and see things for what they are and not what you want them to be you will be on your way to understanding what happened yesterday and why your out that money. Your energy will be better served getting congress to act and pass a law that benefits us all.
wrong
The great &quot;Poker is rigged&quot; debate - Collected threads edition Quote
04-16-2011 , 07:09 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by banonlinepoker
Doesn't matter where you live, you did business with a site that was blatantly breaking the law of another country and was totally open to having all assets frozen and owners thrown in jail.

Actually I don't do freerolls. Waste of time. I have a $10 avg buy in on FTP. As for live I do decent. An play actively but you can go on blaming and degrading people that don't share your vision of a world were laws are to be ignored and lashing out when your money is frozen and ultimately taken from you. I can't help the fact you cheated the US out of tax revenue and made criminals rich and now is acting like a 18 year old high school girl that got felt up at the movies. I kind of feel bad for you guys now that have to go to the local mall and sell American Eagle clothes or sunglasses because your internet moves won't have a snowballs chance in hell at a live table and your uber aggressive moves are met with over the top raises from live players that can read you like the morning newspaper. Best of luck.
wrong
The great &quot;Poker is rigged&quot; debate - Collected threads edition Quote
04-16-2011 , 07:11 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by banonlinepoker
You did business with an illegal organization. If you played in an illegal underground card room that money isn't yours. It's seized if there is a raid. As for punching me hey I am 6 foot 2 and 240. Not fat either. Give it your best shot pal.
wrong
The great &quot;Poker is rigged&quot; debate - Collected threads edition Quote
04-16-2011 , 07:11 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by quarantined
Do you even understand what a hypocrite you are? Not quite sure how I degraded you,other than to point out you sound,and write as if your education ended around the time you were fitted for long pants. But you go on to say that anyone who actually wins at poker isn't qualified for anything but a job at their local mall. Having a high i.q. is a trait common to successful people, and certainly all but compulsory in the online poker world. You go on figuratively dancing on peoples graves if it makes you happy,i'm done with your nonsense,and sorry I ever responded to it.
I am with you on this. It is a real 120lb Douche bag move to be pissing and ****ting on peoples online poker graves. These are real people with families to take care of and bills piling up. In the work I do, I talk to people in these kinds of situations and help them look at their options to move through financial and personal disaster. This is some really serious **** happening in peoples lives and should not be wielded as an opportunity to take a cheap shot.

Again, I wish all of you the best getting through this crisis. You did not deserve for any of this to happen. We can blame our government and the sites for what has happened. All of this could have been avoided if steps were taken years ago. Greed has no humanity though...
The great &quot;Poker is rigged&quot; debate - Collected threads edition Quote
04-16-2011 , 07:12 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by quarantined
But you go on to say that anyone who actually wins at poker isn't qualified for anything but a job at their local mall. Having a high i.q. is a trait common to successful people, and certainly all but compulsory in the online poker world. You go on figuratively dancing on peoples graves if it makes you happy,i'm done with your nonsense,and sorry I ever responded to it.
No I didn't say people that win at poker are stupid but ones that engage in illegal activity and wonder they have lost their principal surely need some IQ checking for sure. It's borderline insane.
The great &quot;Poker is rigged&quot; debate - Collected threads edition Quote
04-16-2011 , 07:14 PM
tell me what you think . Late in tourney 1.5 mil. in chips bb has same I raise huge in position with ak suited he shoves all-in with ten four off and wins ????????????
I`m out like eleventh place. how does someone do that unless they know they are gonna win.. O yeah I check back the next day he won the thing.. 1600.00
I go to bed with 100.00 bucks
The great &quot;Poker is rigged&quot; debate - Collected threads edition Quote
04-16-2011 , 07:17 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by gjim44
tell me what you think . Late in tourney 1.5 mil. in chips bb has same I raise huge in position with ak suited he shoves all-in with ten four off and wins ????????????
I`m out like eleventh place. how does someone do that unless they know they are gonna win.. O yeah I check back the next day he won the thing.. 1600.00
I go to bed with 100.00 bucks
Highly suspicious. Can you post the hand history on that after running it through the hand converter?

Thanks!
The great &quot;Poker is rigged&quot; debate - Collected threads edition Quote
04-16-2011 , 07:21 PM
At least he shoved with 10,4 os instead of calling. He made a play and (presumably) got lucky. Once you called you were only about an 8:5 favorite.
The great &quot;Poker is rigged&quot; debate - Collected threads edition Quote
04-16-2011 , 07:24 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ksslim74
At least he shoved with 10,4 os instead of calling. He made a play and (presumably) got lucky. Once you called you were only about an 8:5 favorite.
Ya, there may be a ton of fold equity there with that move depending upon how big you raised. He is live if he gets called.
The great &quot;Poker is rigged&quot; debate - Collected threads edition Quote
04-16-2011 , 07:26 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by AnthonyB.
There are so many factors here,
How can a government that kept a blind eye and open ears to every banking dynamic of the online poker industry, decide to enforce a bill that they imposed 5 years ago ? Why the delay ? The impropriety has been glaring since the get go, and greed took over on Anniversary Sunday at Poker Stars. That tournament produced so much extra red tape for U.S. banks that the democrats decided to pop this pinata once and for all.
If you think that this indictment excludes defrauding of players, only time will tell. I 'll tell you this, I'm expecting to hear many many more details in this case, and I would be shocked if the defrauding of players isn't a huge part of it. The FBI knows the truth and I'm sure they erred on the side of caution by withholding accusations against these companies for bot use, or collusion etc. ( for now ) That announcement was sugarcoated by yesterday's indictment...We have only heard the beginning, and players will have a dead class action effort attempting to recover illegal gambling funds....Anarchy will ensue as the FBI freeze will stall funds , and this could very well be the first step towards legalization
stay tuned
Ding Dong the witch is dead,the witch is dead, the wicked witch is dead
The great &quot;Poker is rigged&quot; debate - Collected threads edition Quote
04-16-2011 , 07:28 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by BustaHimesCLH
The government are the first to break the law...
Either way they want tax on our funds that's fine there should be no way they could just steal the funds we have on the site.

As for you I'd punch you square in the jaw if I ever met you
You simply do not commit assault unless you are bitter, angry and resentful! If you are that discouraged please fill free to refrain from this thread. I assure you 2+2 does not endorse violence or threats on their forum but wait they do allow you to degrade and insult posters with profanity and degrading remarks maybe it is allowed
The great &quot;Poker is rigged&quot; debate - Collected threads edition Quote
04-16-2011 , 07:36 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by AnthonyB.
Ding Dong the witch is dead,the witch is dead, the wicked witch is dead
"Come Out, Come Out, Wherever You Are" Isai Scheinberg and Raymond Ray Bitar
The great &quot;Poker is rigged&quot; debate - Collected threads edition Quote
04-16-2011 , 09:08 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by banonlinepoker
Yep everything that has happened last 24 hours is all a joke.
Everything that happened in the last 24 hours had nothing to do with players themselves.
Quote:
Originally Posted by AnthonyB.
Ding Dong the witch is dead,the witch is dead, the wicked witch is dead
What an odd, odd little circlejerk you have going for yourself.
The great &quot;Poker is rigged&quot; debate - Collected threads edition Quote
04-16-2011 , 09:20 PM
Otatop
players should of been aware of the US legislation on payment procceses if all the crap that was happening before this was not a warnning and sites should of made players aware they were breaking the law by depositing and any serious player who did not know this is pure dumb.
Give it up shill your morals match your masters.
The great &quot;Poker is rigged&quot; debate - Collected threads edition Quote
04-16-2011 , 09:24 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ken******
sites should of made players aware they were breaking the law by depositing and any serious player who did not know this is pure dumb.
You are misinformed. It's well understood and accepted by most legal authorities that the only players breaking any law are those playing in a state that has a state law specifically outlawing playing online poker. I think this applies in about 5 states, and it's explicitly ignored/unenforced in all but 1 state. The recent actions are not about players breaking any laws, and no such claims have been made by the DOJ. There is no federal law that prohibits players depositing funds or playing online poker.

For what the DOJ charges are about and the outlook for withdrawing player funds, you should read the legislation threads, rather than post nonsense here and validate your handle.
The great &quot;Poker is rigged&quot; debate - Collected threads edition Quote
04-16-2011 , 09:27 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by spadebidder
You are misinformed. There has never been any claim by any government agency that players are breaking any federal law by depositing or playing, and there is not such a claim now. It's well understood and accepted by most legal authorities that the only players breaking any law are those playing in a state that has a state law specifically outlawing playing online poker. I think this applies in about 5 states, and it's explicitly ignored/unenforced in all but 1 state.
suggest you look up the legislation on the payment processors and the legality.
man these shills just wont die.
You are not in my state dumbass contradict yourself much.
Nonsense thats why 3 major poker sites are now closed to US players and charges are filled you sir are a johnson.
The great &quot;Poker is rigged&quot; debate - Collected threads edition Quote
04-16-2011 , 09:45 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by otatop

What an odd, odd little circlejerk you have going for yourself.
Are you referring to the shill/site employee circle jerk?
The great &quot;Poker is rigged&quot; debate - Collected threads edition Quote
04-16-2011 , 09:50 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Lavahands
Hate to make this my first thread, but dammit, give the russians their own site to play on, do they ever lose a hand, a weak hand? If I see a Russian bet or raise preflop, im folding, hell if a russian is playing at a table Im not even sitting. They are just winning the most ridiculous hands out their, maybe 10% they will get air, and 90% take it home. I know this topic has been talked about many time but I just had to. wtf pokerstars/rubots.... =(
AGREED
The great &quot;Poker is rigged&quot; debate - Collected threads edition Quote

      
m