Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Weird Situation at Showdown - discarded hand is live? Weird Situation at Showdown - discarded hand is live?

01-17-2023 , 05:13 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by JimL
He verbally declares his hand
He's an idiot for wasting our time. He was called, show it or fold.

Quote:
Originally Posted by JimL
So I toss my hand facedown forward.
Can't believe people fold to a verbal declaration.
People angle, people misread their hands, people mishear the declaration.

Quote:
Originally Posted by JimL
I then reach back for my cards. The dealer had put them at the edge of the muck
Dealer is an idiot for not putting the hand deep in the muck.

If I was dealing your hand would be mucked and the pot pushed without seeing a hand.
Weird Situation at Showdown - discarded hand is live? Quote
01-24-2023 , 05:04 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by steamraise
He's an idiot for wasting our time. He was called, show it or fold.


Can't believe people fold to a verbal declaration.
People angle, people misread their hands, people mishear the declaration.


Dealer is an idiot for not putting the hand deep in the muck.

If I was dealing your hand would be mucked and the pot pushed without seeing a hand.
Great job at reading certain words and completely missing context.

Literally everything you commented on was addressed in the post you were commenting on. You should try to read it and actually understand it.
Weird Situation at Showdown - discarded hand is live? Quote
01-24-2023 , 02:11 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by JayKon
I did before. Go find it yourself.
Actually my recollection, confirmed by a cursory search, is you named two rooms (Commerce and Bike) which had the magic muck type rule 40 years ago. You also claimed your current (primary) room has such a rule but you never named that room.

If you actually provided the name of a NV or CA room which currently has such a rule, my apologies. I would ask that you please post a link to the post.

If there isn’t or you can’t locate that post to link, it would be even easier to simply post the name(s) again here.

But it isn’t that such room or rooms exist in CA, maybe NV or elsewhere. I think nearly everyone knows or will concede some such rooms exist. But you claimed they not only exist in CA, but that they are still common in CA today. Can you substantiate rooms with a magic muck type room are common in CA today?
Weird Situation at Showdown - discarded hand is live? Quote
01-24-2023 , 02:49 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by JimL
Great job at reading certain words and completely missing context.

Literally everything you commented on was addressed in the post you were commenting on. You should try to read it and actually understand it.
IMO Steam did read and understand the original post. Maybe the delivery was a little harsh but what did Steam get wrong

1. Rather than declaring his hand, if seat 8 REALLY wanted to speed the game along, tabling his hand or simply discarding his 5 high or maybe saying ‘you’re good’ would be faster.

2. Steam even specified your reason, mis-hearing the declaration, for discarding as one reason to not discard to verbal declaration

I am not certain what was the intent of your original post. Was it intended to show. Was it to show magic muck was bad/good?was it to show it is faster or slower?

I believe the root of Steam point is simply to show on multiple levels why your example is itself a poor example and thus not good support for any position.
Weird Situation at Showdown - discarded hand is live? Quote

      
m