Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Most absurd poker "thinking" you have heard in a live game? Most absurd poker "thinking" you have heard in a live game?

03-12-2009 , 09:45 PM
That looks like a 9 high straight flush to me. Take out a heart and you have a 10 high straight
Most absurd poker "thinking" you have heard in a live game? Quote
03-13-2009 , 06:06 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by pfapfap
For cryin' out loud, why the hell do you people insist on talking like this at tables? NO STRATEGY. NO CRITICISM.
This.

If you must say something, just agree with them when they make an idiotic play -- "Yeah, you definitely had to call there.", "Nothing you could do about that.", etc.
Most absurd poker "thinking" you have heard in a live game? Quote
03-13-2009 , 06:09 AM
This.
Most absurd poker "thinking" you have heard in a live game? Quote
03-13-2009 , 07:16 AM
I am such a donkey. I love all this stuff and am sure I make as many errors... you guys would just love to play me!! Great thread.

This morning in cheap game...

JdTd one caller to the BB and I am in late position raising 3*BB (my standard raise in this game)

BB calls as does first caller

Pot 3c Ts 4s

I raise 1/2 pot after a check and see fold call.

Turn 3s

Ok I know a flush is sitting in front of me but feel I need to show some continuity and bet 1/3 pot. He re-raises me what I put in and I figure he has the flush to my 2 pair. I know I am pretty much on a 2 outer (I have not discounted the fact he may have a 3) but have large implied odds (in my carrot chewing donkey mind) so I call.

River is Tc making my boat.

He puts in a raise of the blind. I re-raise 10* that and he re-raises so I push all in thinking no way he called on the flop with trip 3's and suddenly has got all aggressive on me. He calls.

He turns 5h 3h for 3's over T's and I more than double up.

Feel free to rip me a new one for my errors... it will help me learn!
Most absurd poker "thinking" you have heard in a live game? Quote
03-13-2009 , 07:34 AM
Playing in a bounty tournament last night and i flop TPTK after turn board shows Q56T. River comes 2. put him on maybe any ten so bet 8500 of my remaining 18000. guy just calls and shows 34 for the nuts. could have won himself an extra £25 cause i probably would have called rest of stack. I asked why didnt you move in on me and get my bounty he said i knew i wasnt gettin anymore out of you I went on to knock him out lol
Most absurd poker "thinking" you have heard in a live game? Quote
03-13-2009 , 09:29 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by dys
I am such a donkey. I love all this stuff and am sure I make as many errors... you guys would just love to play me!! Great thread.

This morning in cheap game...

JdTd one caller to the BB and I am in late position raising 3*BB (my standard raise in this game)

BB calls as does first caller

Pot 3c Ts 4s

I raise 1/2 pot after a check and see fold call.

Turn 3s

Ok I know a flush is sitting in front of me but feel I need to show some continuity and bet 1/3 pot. He re-raises me what I put in and I figure he has the flush to my 2 pair. I know I am pretty much on a 2 outer (I have not discounted the fact he may have a 3) but have large implied odds (in my carrot chewing donkey mind) so I call.

River is Tc making my boat.

He puts in a raise of the blind. I re-raise 10* that and he re-raises so I push all in thinking no way he called on the flop with trip 3's and suddenly has got all aggressive on me. He calls.

He turns 5h 3h for 3's over T's and I more than double up.

Feel free to rip me a new one for my errors... it will help me learn!
YOU JUST RIPPED HIM A NEW ONE, good one sir. well played
Most absurd poker "thinking" you have heard in a live game? Quote
03-13-2009 , 12:53 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by CardSharpCook
T5
A6789

I makes a nine high straight.

nice try. But where I come from a straight flush is not the same thing as a straight.
Most absurd poker "thinking" you have heard in a live game? Quote
03-14-2009 , 11:56 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by bigDee
In this one home game I play in there's this guy that thinks straddling is a good decision no matter what because you get position preflop. I told him it doesn't matter because you're prob first to act post flop but he didn't care because he said position preflop is the only thing that matters.
like steamboatin', I like to throw a bunch of smart-sounding B/S out there sometimes. One night, playing fairly deep, I raise UTG about 6x blind, it's folded (strange in and of itself) to button who over-raises the pot, and says, "watch out, I have position on you". Blinds go away, and I mumble, "Position is only for LIMIT holdem, it's over-rated in No Limit". He then says, "Where did you hear that? That's stupid".

So I push. and grin.
Most absurd poker "thinking" you have heard in a live game? Quote
03-14-2009 , 09:22 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by jman220
Oh, I can do so much better than the 5-bet.

1-3 Spread Limit Holdem at Turningstone Casino, Circa 2002. (I think the blind structure was a $1 small blind, and a $1 big blind).

Villain is older man in the Small Blind, sitting next to his wife, with around $250
Hero is on the button, has Villain Covered (Barely), and Gets KK

2-3 People Limp, gets to Hero in the button who raises to $4.
Small Blind Raises to $7. Folded around to Hero who raises it to $11, Small Blind Caps at $14, hero Calls.

Heads up on the flop (the cap at Turningstone was 4 raises, but if it was heads up, raises were unlimited).

Flop: K83

Small Blind Raises to $3. Hero raises to $6. Small Blind Raises to $9. Hero Raises to $12. Small Blind Raises to $15. Hero Raises to $18. Small Blind raises to $21. Hero Raises to $24. Small Blind Calls.

(Ok, I guess he has a set of 8's and finally figured out I might have KK...)

Turn: 2

Small Blind Donkbets $3. Hero Raises to $6. Small Blind Raises to $9. Hero Raises to $12. Small Blind raises to $15. Hero Raises to $18. Small Blind Raises to $21. (At this point the whole table is ooing, and aaahing, and I'm figuring that villain thought better of me having KK and is continuing to value-bet the hell out of his 88). Hero Raises to $24. Small Blind Raises to $27. Hero Raises to $30. Small Blind Raises to $33. Hero Raises to $36. Small Blind Calls. (I guess he realized I might have Kings again).

Turn: 2 Small Blind Donkbets (Again!) $3. Hero Raises to $6. Small Blind Raises to $9. Hero Raises to $12. Small Blind Raises to $15 ...... Goes back and forth for a while. At around $60, I start to ponder the possibility that Villain somehow stayed in with pocket 2's until the river, but decide that the possibility is so remote based on the flop-play, that I will just continue raising him until until Small Blind gets it all in and hero calls. Literally, $3 at a time we build a $500 pot. This hand also led to an interesting strategy discussion on these boards a few years ago as to what point the Hero should just call, assuming both players had an infinite stack-size.

Hero Tables his KK.......



Villain Tables:





Spoiler:

AA!?!



Not the most ridiculous thinking I've ever "heard" at the poker table, but definitely the most ridiculous thinking I've ever "seen" at the poker table.

I had a similar hand playing $3/6 limit back in the glory days of Party Poker. Villain open-raises in EP, I 3-bet with QQ in late position, villain caps. Flop is something like QJ7. Next three rounds go donk/raise/RR/cap, with a final board of QJ732. My top set of queens is the nuts. Villain shows AA, of course.

Another glory PP hand, either $2/4 or $3/6: 6 or 7 handed preflop, I'm in the blind holding Ace-rag. Flop comes down 333, and is checked around. Turn is the case 3. I bet out, and get five callers. I bet out again on the river, bet three callers, one guy folds, one guy raises. I 3-bet, and one of the middle callers whines in the chat box about "hey, stop raising, all you are doing is raising the rake in a split pot!". Five(!) people get to showdown on a capped river. The three of us with the nut Ace kicker split the pot.

After a pause, one of the non-ace callers types "ooooohh... I'm a moron".
Most absurd poker "thinking" you have heard in a live game? Quote
03-14-2009 , 10:13 PM
I hear this one all the time.... someone raises from UTG then 2 callers then CO calls 10x bb with J4 off in a 50bb capped game becuase hes PRICED IN!
Most absurd poker "thinking" you have heard in a live game? Quote
03-15-2009 , 03:33 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Spicole
I had a similar hand playing $3/6 limit back in the glory days of Party Poker. Villain open-raises in EP, I 3-bet with QQ in late position, villain caps. Flop is something like QJ7. Next three rounds go donk/raise/RR/cap, with a final board of QJ732. My top set of queens is the nuts. Villain shows AA, of course.
I don't play limit poker ever but is this really THAT terrible of play by AA?
Most absurd poker "thinking" you have heard in a live game? Quote
03-15-2009 , 05:58 AM
I thought the "online poker is rigged" discussions on two plus two were just a joke, but....

Tonight at the casino they start up with an "online poker is rigged" discussion. The dealer is in on it talking about this hand he saw. One guy to my left says he paid $450 for some software that tracks your hands and after 2000 hands or so it can predict what cards will be dealt because all the poker sites use a random number generator which is exploitable. Now if they would only make one of those predictors for the state lottery....
Most absurd poker "thinking" you have heard in a live game? Quote
03-15-2009 , 06:01 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by StackerBA
I don't play limit poker ever but is this really THAT terrible of play by AA?
It really is THAT terrible.
Most absurd poker "thinking" you have heard in a live game? Quote
03-15-2009 , 12:00 PM
Playing 5-150 and 2 players get into a raising war on the river. Guy sitting to my right who has the whole get up going (ipod, sunglasses, hat) tells me that the aggressor in the pot either has "the joint" or 72. I ask why those are the only 2 possiblities and he says "well when you bet, you have the nuts or nothing".
Most absurd poker "thinking" you have heard in a live game? Quote
03-15-2009 , 04:37 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by StackerBA
I don't play limit poker ever but is this really THAT terrible of play by AA?
Well, put yourself in his shoes. Let's say you have AA (I have aces, woo!). Flop comes QJ7. You bet, the lone opponent on the button raises, you re-raise, and he caps. Turn is a 3. You donk bet into the button, he raises, you re-raise, and he caps. River 2. You bet, the guy on the button raises. The button has now raised and re-raised on the flop, raised and re-raised on the turn, and raised again on the river. What does he have?

Mr. AA dropped the max $72 on the hand because he couldn't think beyond omfg I got AA he can't beat me omfg.
Most absurd poker "thinking" you have heard in a live game? Quote
03-15-2009 , 09:29 PM
Casual NLHE home game, 5 handed:

I raise KQs from UTG to 4xBBs on the first hand.
The whole table calls.

Flop is JT4 rainbow.

I bet a little under the pot and get 1 caller, everyone else folds.
A on the turn, I bet around the pot again, he calls.
Brick on the river, I bet around the pot again, he calls.

One of the guys (he's about 20 years older than me) who folded on the flop looks at me with the most serious face possible and says "Listen Shoe Lace, how can you bet so much when you have nothing? Wtf you only saw 2 out of the 7 cards. You must be one of those lucky players".

Then about 90 minutes later a different guy makes this comment towards me... "Man you're playing so tight than you're ruining the game for everyone, seriously just play more hands. We're playing every hand so you should play too, you never know you might win more".

At this point I've honestly played like 40% of my hands (I pretty much played every hand from the button/LP) and encapsulated myself into a fortress of chip stacks.

Coming from playing 99.9% of my games online I wish I lived closer to a casino. I didn't know poker players like this existed.
Most absurd poker "thinking" you have heard in a live game? Quote
03-15-2009 , 09:58 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Shoe Lace
One of the guys (he's about 20 years older than me) who folded on the flop looks at me with the most serious face possible and says "Listen Shoe Lace, how can you bet so much when you have nothing? Wtf you only saw 2 out of the 7 cards. You must be one of those lucky players".
This would have been about 1000 times more awesome if you weren't subbing your nick and he had actually called you a shoe lace.

Next game I'm at I'm gonna drop that line, it's golden. "Listen, shoelace, how can you bet so much when you have nothing?"

And yes, FYI I play against players like this in a home game 5 handed about 2-3 times a week, and 7-8 handed for higher stakes about once a month. I'm guessing its slightly more common to have this type of player at home than in a casino, although not by much.
Most absurd poker "thinking" you have heard in a live game? Quote
03-15-2009 , 10:52 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by DRybes
This would have been about 1000 times more awesome if you weren't subbing your nick and he had actually called you a shoe lace.
Heh, agreed. It wasn't until after I read the post that I realized it was his handle.

Sounds like 30s gangster speak.
Most absurd poker "thinking" you have heard in a live game? Quote
03-19-2009 , 04:46 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by StackerBA
I don't play limit poker ever but is this really THAT terrible of play by AA?
About halfway through the turn bet-raise-reraise-cap sequence, I start to ponder the possibility that maybe this guy flopped a set, I might want to check-and-call with my aces just in case he did.

And I suck at LHE.
Most absurd poker "thinking" you have heard in a live game? Quote
03-19-2009 , 05:11 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Such A Card
I thought the "online poker is rigged" discussions on two plus two were just a joke, but....

Tonight at the casino they start up with an "online poker is rigged" discussion.
one night in wild live game after a certain player got rivered for the 3rd time by a lesser hand he finally snaps and berates the dealer, asking why is he constantly getting shafted on the river. Then he says, "I should just play online, you don't see that kind of stuff".

I've yet to ask if he was serious or not. But I think he was.
Most absurd poker "thinking" you have heard in a live game? Quote
03-19-2009 , 05:27 PM
3-6 Limit hold'em, action unimportant before the river. 8 people to the river. The river board was A,K,Q,J,10 rainbow (may not have come out in that order).

Action: Check, check, check, bet, call, call, call, call, call, call, raise, reraise, call, call, call, fold, call, call ...


Last edited by GreedIsGood; 03-19-2009 at 05:39 PM. Reason: One too many 'calls'
Most absurd poker "thinking" you have heard in a live game? Quote
03-19-2009 , 05:36 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Koko the munkey
About halfway through the turn bet-raise-reraise-cap sequence, I start to ponder the possibility that maybe this guy flopped a set, I might want to check-and-call with my aces just in case he did.

And I suck at LHE.
But how high does that even register on the "absurd" level?
Most absurd poker "thinking" you have heard in a live game? Quote
03-19-2009 , 05:44 PM
Funny thread =)

I played in Vancouver @ a 1-2 table, and this guy tries to convince the table to read the fine print of poker sites. He said that he read it himself where fulltilt says that they are allowed to hold back 2 cards from a deck and give it to anyone in order to create more action... WTF?

=)
Most absurd poker "thinking" you have heard in a live game? Quote
03-19-2009 , 05:59 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by BadPlayer13
Heads up pre-flop.

Lady: I think you have aces but I call.
Me: Why did you call if you think he has aces?
Lady: Well, if he has aces, my 4-4 is about the same as K-K there. And there is no way I am folding K-K pre-flop.
Well, you inspired me. Took a very small amount of artistic discretion with the dialog:

http://www.xtranormal.com/watch?e=20090319175516887

Enjoy.

-regression-
Most absurd poker "thinking" you have heard in a live game? Quote
03-19-2009 , 07:00 PM
^^ Awesome.
Most absurd poker "thinking" you have heard in a live game? Quote

      
m