Quote:
Originally Posted by Terminal
From my recollection, he pulled in player 2's cards, as he was directly in front of the dealer, player 2 was in the 9 seat right next to him. From what I remember player 1's card were still in front of him. He was pushing the pot in that direction and reaching for his cards, but player 2 stopped him.
This is a bit of a curveball .. If P1's cards were still in front of him while the pot was being pushed .. AND that's when P2 tried to claim the pot, then this gets a lot more confusing as to why there's confusion!!
We've been concentrating on what cards were in the muck already .. maybe, maybe not mixed with stub/Board .. and this would suggest a much more straight forward solution.
Not to put more pressure on OP since he was late to the part as far as observations, but we also could've had the Dealer continue to mix cards together during the discussion.
Regardless of what actually happened, this is a good spot to talk through as there's plenty of scenarios that are all slightly different from one another that could affect potential rulings. GL