Quote:
Originally Posted by BDHarrison
What's the best way to punish players who intentionally act out of turn as an angle?
86 them, the same way you punish players who intentionally violate any other rule in the room.
A useful guiding principle is that rules are not designed to punish players. They are especially not designed to punish players who make accidental mistakes, which is the large majority of time mistakes are made. They are not designed to take one player's money and give it to another player as punishment or otherwise. They are designed to create a fair game, and to arbitrate irregularities as fairly as possible.
Furthermore, as discussed above, there are ways to defang this angle anyway, by simply making sure other players (and in particular, the player whose turn it actually is) knows that the bet isn't binding. Now you have the option to do what you were originally going to do anyway. Or, if you'd like, you can try to use the new information you have to your advantage, just like you might do with any other (false) tell. But sometimes you'll be wrong. What you don't get to do is get a guaranteed check raise in on the field, most of whom did nothing wrong.
This is an old argument anyway. We've debated this 10s or 100s of times already.