Quote:
Originally Posted by Mason Malmuth
Hi Busto:
Tilt is simply when you lose the ability to think rationally in a poker game. So when I say your brain is locked up, this is exactly what it means, your ability for rational thought is mostly gone.
And this is from page 9 of Real Poker Psychology:
Perhaps in the interviews I have done this should have been made more clear, but I think it is clear in the text. For instance, I say that in both "pseudo tilt" and "searching," even though it can look like tilt, the player in either one of these states is still making his decisions in a rational manner. Thus he is not on tilt.
Best wishes,
Mason
I didn't find Mason's arguments about poker psychology to be particularly persuasive, though I haven't read the book. He describes tilt as "your brain locking up," but doesn't really get into what exactly that means or why it would happen. He simply says that it is because you don't sufficiently understand "poker concepts." This seems kind of like the same type of pseudoscience that Mason rails against elsewhere. Is your "brain locking up" a reduction in working memory due to a certain level of stress hormone in your blood? Before we can get into the causes of tilt, we would need a more scientific description of what exactly it is that we are talking about.
Saying that tilt is simply playing suboptimally and telling players to learn how to play more optimally doesn't seem particularly helpful and almost seems like semantic sleight of hand. If tilt is indeed due to a certain level of stress hormone (cortisol etc.), then it definitely seems like things such as meditation could help in reducing tilt.
I think poker decisions are like complex mathematical word problems where you have to identify relevant variables and weight them properly to come to the correct answer (bet/raise/fold). As much as you study, every problem is somewhat different (at least if you are willing to deviate from GTO). So having stress reduce this problem solving ability could conceivably hurt your results no matter how well you understand poker. If your working memory or ability to focus is reduced, your answer will be suboptimal both for the word problem and for the poker hand. A player could get a perfect score on a poker theory test but play much worse in a real game due to the effects of stress/anger. Mason's advice would help them do better on the theory test, but wouldn't help them with moderating their stress levels which is the crux of the issue imo.
There is a large literature on the effects of stress on problem solving and I would think that would be relevant to Mason's book.
Last edited by Frankie Fuzz; 12-14-2015 at 06:24 PM.