Quote:
Originally Posted by shakalakashakaboom
Post like this reek of a troll bookreader who wants to "speculate".
The sensible reason for having whitehat bookreaders in here has not only been put forth ITT and the previous one numerous times, but it is painfully obvious. But I'm not going to rehash it for you, because the thread doesn't need to devolve into that discussion every time some nitwit is either too dense to see the common sense in having whitehats in here, is too lazy to actually read back on the discussion he is reigniting, or both.
lol ok.
There are a number of people who want to live in the world created by the show, not live in the world created by the books. If we are not going to create three threads(book, show, hybird), then IMO we should go purely with show. I understand some people want to be made aware of the missing links that were made clear in the book and not in show, but there are people who dont want or care for that.
The people who want the history can achieve so pretty easily, for example by pm'ing one of the people with a good "track record" that have been posting itt. Maybe that should be the third thread, not really a discussion thread but a Q/A type thread for book readers to answer questions.
I dont do books. The number of books I have read since 6th grade I can count one one hand. I dont say it like its impressive, I know its not an admirable trait,but its the truth. If you dont believe me just see my grammar in my posting history.
At the worst I would like to see a panel of approved people(at most like 3, that would answer only when proposed with a question and always in a spoiler.
There has never been a GOOD reason why everyone and their mother needs to be posting in this thread. And the reason brought up doesnt include posts like "WOWOWOWOOWOWOW omg dragons!", or anything like that, but yet many book readers do so in this thread. Whats the gain of these posts? There is enough of both groups to not need crossover.