Quote:
Originally Posted by Cotton Hill
As for Tyrion, he was railroaded into a death sentence by his father, his sister, and the woman he loves. I'd imagine that sort of changes a person, I mean his rant at his trial, dude is seriously pissed off at all the idiots and scumbags around him to the point of kinda snapping. Plus he didn't intend to kill anyone at first, Shae attacked him and killed her in defense. At that point he probably DGAF and blames his dad for everything, including Shae's death.
As for Mance, you have to remember his army is large but disorganized and poorly equipped. They knew they had a chance at taking the wall because the Knight's Watch had become a skeleton crew and they could win a war of attrition. Based on the shots I saw Stannis' force was hardly a handful, looked like many hundreds of well armed and trained mounted soldiers. This is the army he bought with Bravos money to retake the throne, so it's not just a couple of dudes. Yeah in reality the wildlings would have probably fought much longer before they realized it was hopeless but they just sped it up a little.
I don't think the army was bought by Stannis. He said that he had about 4,000 men, and I don't think the army he used was larger than that (maybe a few thousand tops). Also, if you look at their armor, it's the same that we have always seen for his men (I would assume that sellswords would have their own armor already).
As mentioned, a few thousand armored knights will destroy an unprepared and undisciplined force. The wildlings were caught completely off guard and likely many were not even armed at the time. With knights coming at them from both sides, they were doomed. Also, I think the 100k includes everyone with Stannis, so that would be a decent number of non-fighters.
Agree on Tyrion. I don't think he really had a plan when he went to Tywin's room as he had no weapon. He likely just wanted to confront his father and understand why he sentenced him to death for a crime he didn't commit. It also seemed unclear to me whether after he got the crossbow that he was always going to kill Tywin. I think if Tywin had not been so arrogant, Tyrion might have let him live.