Quote:
Originally Posted by Gizmo
...What's the next step?
Thank you both for listening and giving me genuine responses.
The next step in my eyes has to be acknowledging and attempting to the solve the problem of virgin/incel/almost-incel-shaming in the same way that feminists have made excellent progress condemning that of slut-shaming (something that they have my full backing on).
Now I'll be the first to admit that a major (possibly even the main) reason why this doesn't happen is because of male competitiveness, which also has its roots in evolutionary biology. It is, for a lot of men, nice to feel that you are not merely genetically lucky, but also more skilled than other men. That you've beaten out the competition via a kind of conquering expertise.
But, women and feminists do have to hold some responsibility too; because whilst you both say (and I believe you're both sincere) that you do feel sympathy for the lonely and acknowledge that they exist, I do feel that your responses betray a tolerance of those who don't. "Meh, what do you want me to do about it?" *is* a problematic response to being told about other peoples' discrimination.
Many people, both feminists and competitive males, simply don't believe, or worse, do believe and deny, that there are undeserving, lonely, discriminated-against incels.
Many of the responses in the Sexodus thread amounted to precisely that attitude.
"Lolz its not a real problem"
"Yeah lol virgins have it worse than black people"
"So what if some bitter woman-haters can't get laid? Start with the woman-hating that's your first problem"
Didace is quite a useful opponent for me in this regard, as I recall him saying, without irony, "oh, you think that virgins are discriminated against because that's how they're portrayed on TV. I get it, you don't understand the difference between real life and fiction". *
Of course, when Sgt Rj popped up to say words to the effect of "well I'm sorry, and this is harsh, but yeah, being a virgin past a certain age is kind of off-putting to us women... really sorry but it does imply a certain lack of social ability or underlying issues"** Didace happily enough came out with a predictable stream of straw-men and insults trying to silence me in response to probably the biggest example of him being proven demonstrably wrong.
In essence, I am, in this small sphere, asking you to check your privilege. Literally in exactly the same way that commonly-derided 'social justice warriors' (the reasonable ones) ask men to do. I'm not saying that what these 'nice incels' suffer is as severe a societal problem as sexism/racism...***
...I'm simply saying this:
Remember the Sri Lankan friend I brought up earlier? I love him. I wish the best for him. And in the frightening and depressingly possible scenario that he never gets to experience love, I want him to know that he has a safe space away from mockery and discrimination where he can receive human compassion.
And...here's the thing...
I DON'T want that one safe space for him to be on a woman-hating MRA board.
I hear you. As much as these 'nice incels' exist, many of them aren't. Many of them are bitter. Many of them have issues.
Want less of those guys? Help to combat shaming men for their lack of sexual conquests. This will literally improve the lives of men, women and the relationship between them.
Why do I still identify with this group? Because I sincerely believe that they're experiencing social injustice; the kind of which the world would be a better place without.
That's basically it.
* And by the way, how on Earth does negative portrayal in pop culture *not* count as a form of disrespect and discrimination?
** I completely respect Sgt RJ's honesty on this one. This is just a heterosexual woman being honest about her involuntary sexual desires, despite the sexist climate in which we live where women are still shamed for doing so.
*** I'm not quite sure why I have to specify that. Even making the point that there are other priorities isn't how you deal with something that you think is a genuine problem in any sense whatsoever. Doctors don't shrug their shoulders at the guy with the flu and inform him that there are people with AIDS and cancer.