168
Alien 3
3.5/5
This is a review of the 2003 'Assembly Cut', rather than the theatrical version.
Having the unfortunate start of being the third movie in a really stellar franchise, this suffers from any sort of comparison with Alien and Aliens. However, the Assembly Cut version is actually a pretty damn good movie. It's almost 4/5. The recut adds coherency (and 30 minutes extra) to the original, and also some sense of scale of epicness (shots of driving cattle through the terrible planetary weather; miles of oil derricks on a shoreline), and it is a significantly better movie than the one I saw in the cinema in 1992.
Still, it has problems. It's hard to sympathise with a bunch of murderer/rapists. There are some great visuals and characters here though. I particularly liked Charles Dance, Charles S Dutton, Brian Glover, Paul McGann, and of course Sigourney Weaver, but the whole cast was very solid.
It also suffers from a bagginess that the extra 30 minutes brings. The story is definitely better for the inclusions, but I can't help feeling a little trimming here of there, removing 10 minutes or so via a set of judicious minor cuts, would make it better.
Enjoyable, but always leaves the nagging feeling...where did the 2 facehuggers needed to explain the plot actually come from?