Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
WTF is it w/ transgender  students and bathroom/locker rooms? WTF is it w/ transgender  students and bathroom/locker rooms?

05-14-2016 , 01:32 PM
Watch your step, Howard! Watch every ****ing syllable! Gotta stay on the right side of these new Nazis. They're changing the rules just about every day, it seems. Brave new world.
05-14-2016 , 01:45 PM
Comparing trans rights to black civil rights = bogus!
Comparing terminology suggestions to Nazis = no problemo!

You are of course free to use whatever terminology you choose.
05-14-2016 , 01:48 PM
Nazis was used figuratively there, cmon. smh
05-14-2016 , 02:10 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by TheDuker
FYI, "transgendered" is also on the list of terms that should be avoided (which I only learned while researching for this thread). See the GLAAD Media Reference Guide.


The link above will help with this. People have actually been thinking about these issues for quite some time.
Thanks
05-14-2016 , 02:19 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by kioshk
Equating the civil rights movement with this trans **** is laughably bogus and the perfect symbol of how bankrupt our society is right now, that this ludicrous analogy is carrying the day.
Seems like comparing bathrooms to water fountains is one of the least controversial analogies I've ever used.

Like "Stop bitching, you have your own bathroom" is literally separate but equal logic.
05-14-2016 , 02:43 PM
Thread should be re-titled "Old Men Yell At PC Cloud"
05-14-2016 , 02:54 PM
Good luck talking to these numbskulls, Howard. I'm outtie.
05-14-2016 , 03:01 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by kioshk
Good luck talking to these numbskulls, Howard. I'm outtie.
Well it's been a great cameo, shame that the loony left have so crushingly censored your enlightened perspective.
05-14-2016 , 03:24 PM
i am very pleased that this issue is so stupid that it took this long for anyone to make a thread about it. no offense to the op.

when i was younger, i used to entertain myself by using the women's room when i was with a group of people that would be surprised by that. i only did it 3 or 4 times, but every time it happened, the women i encountered agreed it was at least a little bit humorous to see a dude in their bathroom

nobody ever yelled at me or reported me to management.

i am a little concerned that experience may eventually turn me into some kind of sexual predator. but if that happens i should be able to sue somebody for not positioning armed guards outside of every public restroom.
05-14-2016 , 04:00 PM
mat, today you might get charged and classified as a sexual offender I.e. have to inform govt when you go to another city

Sorry for dumb questions but is this issue mostly related to kids?... Adults shouldn't care as long as personal safety is assured...

Local magazine celebrated trans-sexual 6 or 7 year-old on cover... I thought it was outrageous. Suck up the uncomfortable feeling till at least 14 or 15 years old.... To me it's too liberal, over-reactive parenting. 7 year-old shouldn't know anything about TG issues
05-14-2016 , 05:31 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by rivercitybirdie
mat, today you might get charged and classified as a sexual offender I.e. have to inform govt when you go to another city

Sorry for dumb questions but is this issue mostly related to kids?... Adults shouldn't care as long as personal safety is assured...

Local magazine celebrated trans-sexual 6 or 7 year-old on cover... I thought it was outrageous. Suck up the uncomfortable feeling till at least 14 or 15 years old.... To me it's too liberal, over-reactive parenting. 7 year-old shouldn't know anything about TG issues
TheDuker obviously doesn't agree with this.
05-14-2016 , 05:35 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mat Sklansky
i am very pleased that this issue is so stupid that it took this long for anyone to make a thread about it. no offense to the op.

when i was younger, i used to entertain myself by using the women's room when i was with a group of people that would be surprised by that. i only did it 3 or 4 times, but every time it happened, the women i encountered agreed it was at least a little bit humorous to see a dude in their bathroom

nobody ever yelled at me or reported me to management.

i am a little concerned that experience may eventually turn me into some kind of sexual predator. but if that happens i should be able to sue somebody for not positioning armed guards outside of every public restroom.
Why do you believe a lawyer would even take such a case, let alone win? In my view you'd be in for a pretty rough go during the discovery phase. Could be convinced otherwise.
05-14-2016 , 07:20 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Howard Beale
U.S. gives sweeping guidance to schools on transgender students.

First, how many transgender students can there be? And at what age is 'transgendered' determined?
Second, is it really THAT horrible that a boy that looks like a girl should be made to use the girl's room considering that that a transgender student is already going through who knows how much difficulty?
Third, how are schools supposed to pay for this (and how many additional facilities do they have to provide)?
Fourth, transgender locker rooms? How does that work?
Fifth: You're an insensitive bastard!
BBC has a piece on England's only gender identity clinic for children
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-36275877

Quote:
About 1,400 young people under the age of 18 have been referred to the Gender Identity Development Service over the last year.
Three children aged three were referred to the clinic in the past year, compared with none in the previous year.
Dr Carmichael says she's noticed that those transitioning are getting younger.
"Young people [are] making the full social transition - that means living full-time in their preferred gender inside and outside the home - at earlier ages," she says.
"It's something that comes through from those we've seen coming here in recent months."
I assume that 1400 is a fraction of the total number..
05-14-2016 , 07:21 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by adios
Why do you believe a lawyer would even take such a case, let alone win? In my view you'd be in for a pretty rough go during the discovery phase. Could be convinced otherwise.
Can you be convinced it wasn't serious?
05-14-2016 , 07:51 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by adios
Why do you believe a lawyer would even take such a case, let alone win? In my view you'd be in for a pretty rough go during the discovery phase. Could be convinced otherwise.
i was kidding, but i'm pretty sure anyone can find a lawyer to do anything these days. lawyers are ****ing cocksucsuckers imo. and one of my closest friends esq. agrees
05-14-2016 , 10:16 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by rivercitybirdie
7 year-old shouldn't know anything about TG issues
Why? Kids already learn about the differences between genders at a really young age - especially if they have a brother/sister of the opposite gender.
05-15-2016 , 12:14 AM
Well, at least the threads a hit! Nobody likes a dull one. That DC guidance piece addressed the question of a, how should I put it?, transgendered female inside a boy's body (ok?) wearing a dress and heels to school. The remedy was to get rid of the heels since they're not allowed for girls and to make her (?) wear a longer skirt. Although 'her' might be wrong bec they go into detail about what to call people and suggest 'students' and 'scholars' instead of 'boys and girls.' There's also some confusion about what happens when a transitioning (as they put it) scholar wants to play on a team that would have been considered once upon a time as appropriate for what a cursory exam would reveal as a particular sex. I await further developments and the lawsuits that are bound to follow.

Meanwhile the **** storm has already started. Great job, iyam. Give the social conservatives a hot button issue on a silver platter in a crazy election year.
05-15-2016 , 12:16 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by TheDuker
Thread should be re-titled "Old Men Yell At PC Cloud"
AGEISM, itt. Very illiberal of you, for shame.
05-15-2016 , 12:28 AM
Not sure why dress code would be even a little bit of a problem. Wear the uniform of whatever gender you prefer.

Sports is probably the only area where things get messy but even that doesn't really matter for younger age groups.

But to be honest this just looks like you're moving on from the topic you opened in hopes of finding problems elsewhere.
05-15-2016 , 12:44 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Bladesman87
Not sure why dress code would be even a little bit of a problem. Wear the uniform of whatever gender you prefer.

Sports is probably the only area where things get messy but even that doesn't really matter for younger age groups.

But to be honest this just looks like you're moving on from the topic you opened in hopes of finding problems elsewhere.
Not really. Two things about this bothered me: First, I very much dislike social conservatives and this gives them fodder. In an election year! Think of the fund-raising emails and letters that are going to go out. The speeches, the hysteria. Second, I think that there's an over-reach bec the absolute insistence that a trans person MUST be able to use the locker room/rest room of their gender identity is, frankly, ridiculous. Yes, I get it, but the difficulties are real, and I think there are going to be a tremendous number of parents that are infuriated and I'm afraid of how they'll vote. I don't want TRUMP as president. Yes, he said transgender persons were welcome in TRUMP tower but those are adults. My suggestion regarding separate facilities is being disparaged and one poster mentioned curtains! Well, what's the difference between a separate room and curtains? Same thing except it's not results oriented enough for some.

I brought some of this on myself, of course. I could've used a more sensitive thread title but that's not my style, I like 'catchy.' However, I will bear this in mind if I ever start another thread on a controversial topic.
05-15-2016 , 02:25 AM
Quote:
the absolute insistence that a trans person MUST be able to use the locker room/rest room of their gender identity is, frankly, ridiculous.
You keep saying this but I'm yet to hear why.
05-15-2016 , 06:23 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by TheDuker
Comparing trans rights to black civil rights = bogus!
Comparing terminology suggestions to Nazis = no problemo!

You are of course free to use whatever terminology you choose.
The endless strained parallels of race issues to sex issues are often bogus and gum up the thinking in my view. The problem stems from the fact that the sexes are actually sometimes different in meaningful ways and the races aren't.

This isn't to say anything about the bathroom issue. Make that a non-issue again in my estimation.
05-15-2016 , 06:28 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mat Sklansky
i was kidding, but i'm pretty sure anyone can find a lawyer to do anything these days. lawyers are ****ing cocksucsuckers imo. and one of my closest friends esq. agrees
Yeah I knew you were but in NC, with the new law, it might actually be a sex crime. So your scenario might actually be closer to reality than you might have thought.
05-15-2016 , 06:33 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Deuces McKracken
The endless strained parallels of race issues to sex issues are often bogus and gum up the thinking in my view. The problem stems from the fact that the sexes are actually sometimes different in meaningful ways and the races aren't.

This isn't to say anything about the bathroom issue. Make that a non-issue again in my estimation.
Good post.
05-15-2016 , 06:37 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Bladesman87
You keep saying this but I'm yet to hear why.
Could a pervert who is not a transgender "game the system" by claiming to be a transgender?

      
m