Quote:
Originally Posted by LordJvK
Oh I see. SJWs didn't cause them to become anti-SJW, flock together and create a base of support for Trump. I see.
These things would have happened because these people are deplorables anyway. Is that what you are saying?
In point of fact, no, SJWs did not "cause" them to become anti-SJW. Also, I thought you were a strong believer in individual responsibility?
More generally, the theoretical problem I have with your attitude towards this kind of question is that you seem to think social movements are invalidated by the presence of counter-movements. You seem to assume that if a counter-movement exists that is a strong indicator of some failure on the part of the movement. But, I think if you ask any specialist in social movement research, they'll tell you that basically all social movements spawn counter-movements, and all social movement framings prompt counter-framings. I'm literally unaware of a single counter example.
You also seem to assume that the people who were active #gamergaters were somehow open and positively disposed towards feminist concerns until the SJWs turned them off by being too strident, illiberal, or whatever else. There's basically no evidence to support that, and a great deal of evidence to the contrary. In previous discussions with foldndark, I tried to make the point that opposition to SJWs is often couched in terms of a disagreement about methods, which tends to obscure the fact that there are really strong disagreements about goals and about the reality of social inequalities. #gamergaters were never just complaining about the methods of SJWs.
Last edited by well named; 02-02-2017 at 03:45 PM.