Quote:
Originally Posted by Marn
The latest study done by Danmark statistik(2010-2014) showed that non western immigrants were convicted of rape 8x more often than native Danes.
I'm assuming your numbers are correct. The question then, is: why are immigrants more likely to be convicted of rape? The alt-right and anti-Muslim posters have their answer, but it would be foolish to conclude they are correct based on these numbers.
The first thing to notice is the variation from year to year. I'm supposed to believe that in 2011 Muslims were 11.5x as rapey, but in 2012 they cut their tendencies in half, only to spike again in 2014? That seems obviously wrong. The variance is much more likely to be because these are fairly rare events, and so random variation in the numbers is causing large fluctuations in the relative rates here.
Since you didn't link to the actual study, I also wonder how these comparisons are made. Did they control for age? If immigrant populations skew younger, then that could account for some of the difference. What about income? Immigrants are obviously going to be less wealthy. What happens to the difference in rates when this is taken into account?
And this data is for convictions, so wealth might matter there as well. Are immigrants acquitted at the same rate as native-born Danes? Charged? Amnesty International argues that rape is not taken seriously in Denmark:
Quote:
Furthermore, only one in five reported rapes results in a conviction. The vast majority of cases are closed by the police or the prosecution and never reach trial. Most cases are closed due to “the state of the evidence”. However, in almost half of these cases, the victim had suffered physical injuries. The failure to effectively prosecute the alleged perpetrators of rape would indicate that Denmark does not fully comply with its responsibilities to protect women from gender-based violence.
Perhaps Danish police are simply more likely to look the other way with respect to rape when the accused is a native-born Dane. I don't know if that's true, but I'd be surprised if more than half of immigrant rape cases were closed without prosecution.
So, by itself, the disparity here tells me next to nothing.