Well, I gave seeding and bracket-making a shot. Some notes: in seeding, I wasn't just seeding objective quality or personal preference, but was seeding how strong I thought these matches were in terms of vote-getting on this board. However, I even tweaked that a bit when it came to matchups that show up more than once. For instance, the second ladder match between Razor and HBK would objectively be higher in a vacuum, but I think it comes off weaker than its predessor at WM X, so that hurt its seeding.
I tried to bracket it so that rematches between two competitors were booked into the same region. I did this so we didn't end up with something like Flair v. Steamboat or whatever showing up twice in the Final Four. I figure that it makes it more interesting to have a number of unique competitors in the Final Four...so this will make some regions a bit stronger than others, but I felt that a bit of imbalance was better than a Final Four without diversity. Of course, there's a reasonable chance we'll see HBK show up more than once in the Final Four, since he shows up in 1/4 of the matches of this tourney.
Anyway, this is just my proposal. It can be edited to re-seed, add/remove matches, etc. But I thought since this thread was languishing for the past week that I'd throw this up there.
http://www.bracketmaker.com/tmenu.cfm?tid=417336