Join Date: Jan 2008
Posts: 50,746
Ruling:
Last event, someone submitted an opponent for the best match question without specifying which iteration of the match they were referring to. Seeing as how one was much more famous than the other, I felt ok by giving them a grouping with the lowest scoring one. This time, someone wrote only "vs steamboat". My initial reaction was to group it alone. However, I've decided to continue the ruling from last time for one reason: I cannot find a legitimate edge gained from this if I group it with the lowest scoring group. They will always score lowest rather than taking their chance of getting the not lowest one.
If in the future this becomes a larger issue, the ruling might change. In this instance, I think it's ok still. Wanted to be transparent and will listen to thoughts on the ruling.