Had to DQ u sir, Batista is not black, european, doesn't carry a prop to the ring, a non-wrestling athlete, a re-formed tag team, a tag team specialist, A TITLE BELT and I don't think he ever wrestled in a non title wrestlemania match (didn't look it up though).

This is sheep not peehs. No answers are wrong

#1: GOAT non-title WM match:

Taker/Michaels WM 25: 7
Y2Dennis 7
True North 7
LordCC 7
Tragichero 7
Dylan 7
Eliminator 7
Robfish 7

Michaels/Angle: 2
wesrwood 2
Gobias Ind 2

Austin/Hart: 2
yankeys316 2
anguyen92 2

Rock/Hogan: 1
gusmahler ACE

First MITB match: 1
eyebooger ACE

Lawrence Taylor/Bam Bam Bigelow: 1
Burdzthewurd ACE

George Wells/Jake 'snake' Roberts: 1
LKJ ACE

Michaels/Taker WM 26: 1
BackFromABannin ACE

You know in his defense, didn't Batista carry a chain or some sort of box in his first gimmick in 2002? And the fact that he has won few tag titles with Mysterio, Ric Flair, and John Cena. And he had participated, with Evolution, in that 3v2 match against Rock n Sock at Wrestlemania XX.

Wow, I really didn't think HBK vs Undertaker is really that popular here. It was great as it is in my wrestling forum but people saw Austin vs Hart as the GOAT.

SCORECARD:

Y2Dennis 7
True North 7
LordCC 7
Tragichero 7
Dylan 7
Eliminator 7
Robfish 7
wesrwood 2
Gobias Ind 2
yankeys316 2
anguyen92 2
gusmahler 1
eyebooger 1
Burdzthewurd 1
LKJ 1
BackFromABannin 1

Sweet made it home in time for the reveal!

Yes good start!!

#2 GREATEST PROMO AFTER A 6 MONTH+ HIATUS:

The Rocks 2011 Return: 6
LordCC 6
Dylan 6
gusmahler 6
eyebooger 6
anguyen92 6
wesrwood 6

Ric Flair in Greenville: 2
True North 2
Gobias Ind 2

Jericho 2012 'silence': 2
BackFromABannin 2
Burdzthewurd 2

Jericho Debute: 1
Y2Dennis ACE

Jericho 'save us': 1
Robfish ACE

Warrior's WCW Debut: 1
LKJ ACE

Rock's heel turn in 2003: 1
Tragichero ACE

X-pac's return after WCW fires him: 1
Eliminator ACE

Hogan's WWE return on RAW: 1
yankeys316 ACE

I knew I should have gone with the recency bias.

Also - I knew I wanted to pick HBK/Taker, didn't know which one - I'm so glad I picked the first one! I was also considering Bret/Owen at WMX

hahahaha

lol and followed that up with an ace...really considered doing the rock's newest promo too, blahh...

This is what I was going for but can't find the promo yet. Also, didn't think to add up if he was actually gone for 6 plus months this time

From Wiki - Johnson finally dropped the Undisputed WWE Championship to Lesnar at SummerSlam, ending his final championship reign, and making Lesnar the youngest WWE Champion in history, a record previously held by The Rock.[102] The Rock then went on an extended hiatus from WWE.[71]
The Rock began his last villainous turn on SmackDown!, publicly criticizing Hulk Hogan and taking the persona of a smug sellout who made it clear the WWE (and its fans) was no longer a priority.[103] Their WrestleMania X8 rematch at No Way Out ended with The Rock claiming victory again, with assistance from Vince McMahon and the referee, Sylvain Grenier

SCORECARD AFTER 2:
Y2Dennis 8
True North 9
LordCC 13
Tragichero 8
Dylan 13
Eliminator 8
Robfish 8
wesrwood 8
Gobias Ind 4
yankeys316 3
anguyen92 8
gusmahler 7
eyebooger 7
Burdzthewurd 3
LKJ 2
BackFromABannin 3

I'll definitely have to make it a point to re-watch Taker/HBK, because I thought Austin/Hart was a lock.

Definitely had no idea on the promo, but not watching US wrestling in 10 years will pretty much do that.

Austin/Hart is a way better match, but HBK/Taker is more likely to be the sheep answer because it was recent and more people have seen it.

Its all right, I thought so too. I guess if these two ever clashes in the tournament bracket, then there's going to be some hard discussions to be made then.

I hadn't seen HBK/Taker I, I saw II, but people kept saying I was better. Austin-Hart is really good, too.

So glad no one said HHH-Taker II.

#3 GOAT athlete to put on the tights:

Lawrence Taylor: 6
anguyen92 6
Tragichero 6
yankeys316 6
eyebooger 6
Eliminator 6
True North 6

Floyd Mayweather: 4
LordCC 4
BackFromABannin 4
Robfish 4
Dylan 4

Mike Tyson (I guess we can accept it): 2
Y2Dennis 2
gusmahler 2

Dennis Rodman: 1
Gobias Ind ACE

Karl Malone: 1
wesrwood ACE

Adam 'pacman' Jones: 1
Burdzthewurd ACE

Peter Taglianetti: 1
LKJ ACE

Damn was going to go with LT

Again it's not peehs. Every answer is supposed to be accepted.

SCORECARD AFTER 3:

Y2Dennis 10
True North 15
LordCC 17
Tragichero 14
Dylan 17
Eliminator 14
Robfish 12
wesrwood 9
Gobias Ind 5
yankeys316 9
anguyen92 14
gusmahler 9
eyebooger 13
Burdzthewurd 4
LKJ 3
BackFromABannin 7

Anybody willing to do the scorecard after I post answers?, this is harder than I thought and I'm super tired

LOL I went with LT because I couldn't think of anyone who did remotely well, I also considered Tyson but as he never had a match LT it was. Following this pattern I think I have an ace in my future

I wish you had done occasional non-wrestlers characters, like Shane O'Mac. He was awesome.

#4 GOAT RE-FORMED TAG TEAM

'NEW' Midnight Express: 5
LordCC 5
gusmahler 5
wesrwood 5
yankeys316 5
Tragichero 5

Four Horsemen (? I'm guessing Mongo/Jarrett): 4
anguyen92 4
Dylan 4
True North 4
Y2Dennis 4

New Hart Foundation: 2
Robfish 2
eyebooger 2

Demolition: 2
BackFromABannin 2
Gobias Ind 2

LOD 2000 w/sunny : 1
Eliminator ACE

NEW LOD w/Heidenrich & Animal: 1
Burdzthewurd ACE

Doink & Doink & Doink & Doink....basically a bunch of Doinks: 1
LKJ ACE