My 5* match list c/p from another site
:
ROH:
Joe vs Kobashi
Bryan vs KENTA - GBH V Night 2
Punk vs Joe - Punk/Joe II & All Star Extravaganza II
Do Fixer vs Blood Generation - SuperCard of Honor
Morishima vs Bryan - Manahattan Mayhem II
Bryan vs London - Epic Encounter
Bryan vs Nigel - 6th Anniversary Show
Nigel vs Aries - Rising Above 2007
Briscoes vs Steenerico - Ladder match - Man Up
BJ Whitmer vs Jimmy Jacobs - Cage match - SuperCard of Honor II
PWG:
Young Bucks vs Super Smash Bros - Death to all but Metal
Young Bucks vs Super Smash Bros vs Future Shock - Ladder match - Threemendous III
Steen vs Generico - Ladder match - Steen Wolf
Elgin/Cage/Steen vs Ricochet/Swann/Fox - ASW 9 Night 2
Dragon Gate USA:
Richards vs Shingo
WWE:
Bret vs Austin - WM 13
Edge/Rey vs Angle/Benoit - No Mercy 2002
Punk vs Cena - MitB
Angle vs Austin - SummerSlam '01
HBK vs Undertaker - WM 25
TLC II & III
HBK vs Benoit vs HHH - WM 20
Austin/HHH vs Benoit/Jericho - 5/21/01
NWA/WCW
Flair vs Steamboat - Chi-Town Rumble & Clash & Wrestle War
Flair vs Funk - Great American Bash & Clash
Psychosis vs Rey - Bash at the Beach '96
Eddie vs Rey - Halloween Havoc '97
Flair vs Windham - Battle of the Belts II
TNA:
Joe vs Styles vs Daniels - Unbreakable 2005
AJPW:
Jumbo vs Tenryu - 6/5/89
Jumbo vs Misawa - 6/8/90
Jumbo/Taue vs Misawa/Kawada - 12/7/90
Kawada vs Misawa - 6/3/94
Kawada/Taue vs Misawa/Kobashi - 12/3/93 & & 5/21/94 & 6/9/95 (GOAT match and not close)
Kawada vs Hansen - 2/28/93
Jumbo/Taue/Fuchi vs Kawada/Kobashi/Misawa - 4/20/91
Misawa vs Kobashi - 1/20/97
Kobashi/Kikuchi vs Can-Ams - 5/25/92
Hansen vs Kobashi - 7/29/93
Taue vs Misawa - 4/15/95
Sasaki vs Kawada - 10/9/00
Kawada vs Tenryu - 10/28/00
NOAH:
Misawa vs Kobashi - 3/1/03
Kobashi vs Sasaki - 7/18/05
NJPW:
Okada vs Naito - 3/4/12
Okada vs Tanahashi - 6/16/12
Okada vs Tanahashi - 4/7/13
MiSu vs Tanahashi - 10/8/12
Goto vs Tanahashi - 11/11/07 & 6/18/10
Iizuka/Nagata vs Kawada/Fuchi - 12/14/00
Shinjiro Ohtani vs Ultimo Dragon - 8/4/96
El Samurai vs Kanemoto - 6/5/97
Jushin Liger vs Shinjiro Ohtani - 2/9/97
Jushin Liger vs Great Sasuke - 7/8/94
Okada vs Tanahashi - 1/4/15
I have more than this that I just haven't written down and some others I want to rewatch before I call them 5*. I know not many on this forum are huge into star ratings but if you want to watch some excellent wrestling, this list is perfect.