Quote:
Originally Posted by =VH= Fan
1) They did not round up, they rounded down. And as luck would have it, the night ended with two all-ins getting busted by a third guy who had them covered so we ended up with only 13 making it. The guy who finished 14th for the flight will not cash either since he didn't make it to Day 2.
This seems like a mistake. The guy who officially finished 14th in your flight should be awarded a min-cash. Though he might be required to come back after day 2 starts, as they won't know until then how much he is to be paid.
Quote:
2) While I get that it's a nice feeling to already be in the money on Day 2, I think anyone who had to play through significantly more levels and possibly get their chips grounded down by higher blinds as opposed to a tourney where it just ends at a certain level regardless, is at a disadvantage to their other Day 1 counterparts. They will restart Day 2 at the lowest level completed and it's not an exaggeration that that may be level 16 or so based on the last one of these I played in December. You don't think having to navigate 5 more levels with far fewer chips and tables in play than on Day 2 is a disadvantage to the people who didn't have to do that, and doesn't change your strategy?
You're not understanding this. If you had quit at an earlier time, then you theoretically would have gone through these same grinding levels, but would have done so later on day 2, instead of that night. Since everybody played down to 10%, the average stack will be pretty much the same no matter which flight you got through, regardless of how many levels that flight played. If you start with 10K, and play down to 10%, clearly the average stack from each flight is going to be 100K, adjusted for rounding errors. That is, your flight had 147, and clearly there will not be 14.7 players coming to day 2, so whether it is 15, 14, or in your unusual case 13, the average stack from each flight is going to be about 100K. That will be true whether one flight somehow got it done in the first level, or if it took 40 levels. 10% is 10%.
But the phone issue you mentioned is a real concern. They can't apply that rule some of the time, but not all of the time, depending upon the whims of the dealer and floorperson. They should decide exactly how they want the rule to work, and then do their best to enforce it in EXACTLY that fashion.
Cheers, Greg Raymer (FossilMan)