Quote:
Originally Posted by Jon_locke
I show one card all the time. I can't recall ever being asked or required to show the second
It was also my understanding that show one show all meant show your hand to 1 player and you have to show it to all of them. I remember hearing about anti taunting rule before but it is enforced literally never (maybe more so at small games though)
Jon_locke , at your level games i wouldn't expect you guys/gals to call this on each other, you guys taunt each other in much more imaginative effective ways
Quote:
Originally Posted by DeadMoneyWalking
I'm pretty sure the second rule only exists as a misinterpretation of the first.
Quote:
Originally Posted by chillrob
"Show one show all" does mean show one player your hand and anyone else can ask to see it, enforced in almost all rooms.
"Show one show both" is a separate rule, which is in place in only a few rooms.
Yes they are separate rules
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ric Flair WOOOOOOO
i dont like the rule cuz it only really happens when someone asks another player who doesnt play in the room often or is inexperienced if they will just show 1 card and then when they do they quickly bring up the rule that you have to show both and make the dealer flip the other
Quote:
Originally Posted by jjbooey
The biggest problem I have with it is when a nitty reg angles a rec player with it..ie
NR: ahh cmon show one card
RP: happily shows an A
NR: tells dealer I want to see both cards!!
RP: wtf no I only showed you one like you asked!
NR/dealer: that's the rule!! Flips over other card..
and now RP is mad and NRs continue to make the games at CAZ miserable
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jon_locke
i've never seen this happen once after lots and lots of hours
As a dealer i will enforce this rule per its "spirit", anti taunting, if a player asks to see one card of another player and that player does show one, then someone asks to see the other per the rule...no dice , ill kill it. He didnt taunt anyone he showed it when asked as a courtesy, take the info you got, but that is it.
Quote:
Originally Posted by DeathDonkey
I don't think they can invoke it mid hand but that is actually a rule at TS, anti taunting as DC said. It's been called on me
Quote:
Originally Posted by chillrob
If it is ever enforced while action is pending, as in that example, then it is the worst rule I have ever heard of.
No intended to be used while action is pending, to be used after showdown.
Quote:
Originally Posted by chillrob
Sounds like it is the rule at TS...I definitely played in an underground game where that was the rule. It could have started as a misunderstanding of the first rule though.
My understanding that it is in the TDA rules for tourneys so it is becoming something more common